1. Tough call. Milo is incredibly fast. Far faster then Maximus, but on the other side, Milo is... flamboyant and does too many combat rolls while Maximus is very crisp, doesn't waste as much movements. Both have been shown to fight multiple opponents without difficulty. I think I would give it to Maximus, with difficulty, just thanks to his more.... efficient way of fighting.
2. The only fight scene I remember is his fight against Milo.. where he lost. The best feat I can think of is him disarming Milo.. and then losing. I see no reason to see why he would be a match for Commodus much less Maximus.
3. Another tough fight. Maximus is faster then Atticus, but Atticus is far stronger and I wouldn't say either are particularly far better skilled then the other (Atticus was nearly as good as Proculus). Both fight very brutally and don't waste a lot of movements with combat rolls (Milo). I think Maximus and Atticus would have a fairly even split.
4. Proculus is... kind of perfect. Almost like you took Milo's speed and Maximum's skill in one person... but then gave him the ego and personality of Commodus which is his main weakness. If he fights without that ego, he wins. If he fights IC, then he likely dies akin to how he died against Atticus.
Overall Maximus wins via having the better movie.
Log in to comment