Both are in street clothes, unarmed, are blood-lusted, and the fight takes place in Malcolm's office. Thor is from the first Thor movie when he is unworthy of Mjolnir. They start 20 feet away from each other. Win via KO or incapacitaiton. Who wins and why?
Malcolm Merlyn vs De-powered Thor
Merlyn stomps, and I don't think it's even close. Faster, better trained, better fighter, and he is not weak by any means. He broke Ollie's bow with a single punch and, while in normal clothes, beat Ollie in full gear. He also casually caught an arrow, and was fast enough to throw it with enough speed and strength to break protective glass. He tanked hits from Ollie's bow, which - in the same scene - broke a statue.
Thor never beat anybody with actual feats; he beat featless fodder guards. Merlyn beat a skilled and experienced fighter without much trouble, and Ollie has far better feats than Thor.
Please Log In to post.