magneto vs scarlet witch

I'm new so sorry if this has been done. If it has

could someone just send me the link?

scarlet...she's the hotness

The Witch

Most battles with Scarlet Witch can't really be accurate, in my opinion. I say this because everyone argues her latest M-Day feat. The thing is, she was nuts, and we have no concrete proof she would be able to do that in a battle. Doing something twice, especially so far beyond what the person was supposed to be able to do in the first place, does not make it the quintessential base for the persons power. I mean, I beat the living crap out of a huge-scary-jock-boy, but that doesn't mean I can do it again. Though, it also doesn't stop me from wanting to try again...or all huge-scary-jock-boys thinking I can do it to them. If only I was still in high school...

I say Magneto wins; he is the tried and true warrior. And by warrior, I mean killer. And by killer, I mean sadist.

Dont mutants who are related to eachother usually cancel out eachothers powers? so most attacks would have to be indirect im assuming. In which case i think Magneto has it.

Logic Mark III says:

"Dont mutants who are related to eachother usually cancel out eachothers powers? so most attacks would have to be indirect im assuming. In which case i think Magneto has it."

um no.

thats just for the summers brothers. Psylocke and Captain.....i forgot his name, are not immune to each other...nor are the Frost sisters

Phoenix God says:

"Most battles with Scarlet Witch can't really be accurate, in my opinion. I say this because everyone argues her latest M-Day feat. The thing is, she was nuts, and we have no concrete proof she would be able to do that in a battle. Doing something twice, especially so far beyond what the person was supposed to be able to do in the first place, does not make it the quintessential base for the persons power. I mean, I beat the living crap out of a huge-scary-jock-boy, but that doesn't mean I can do it again. Though, it also doesn't stop me from wanting to try again...or all huge-scary-jock-boys thinking I can do it to them. If only I was still in high school...I say Magneto wins; he is the tried and true warrior. And by warrior, I mean killer. And by killer, I mean sadist. "

You say that like Wanda hasn't been a great asset to the Avengers for years, like she's just some rookie with no experience. Even before Disassembled and HoM, the Witch was a force to be reckoned with.

I say Wanda. <3

Phoenix God says:

"Most battles with Scarlet Witch can't really be accurate, in my opinion. I say this because everyone argues her latest M-Day feat. The thing is, she was nuts, and we have no concrete proof she would be able to do that in a battle. Doing something twice, especially so far beyond what the person was supposed to be able to do in the first place, does not make it the quintessential base for the persons power. I mean, I beat the living crap out of a huge-scary-jock-boy, but that doesn't mean I can do it again. Though, it also doesn't stop me from wanting to try again...or all huge-scary-jock-boys thinking I can do it to them. If only I was still in high school...I say Magneto wins; he is the tried and true warrior. And by warrior, I mean killer. And by killer, I mean sadist. "

Wanda's feats aren't limited to House of M or even Avengers Disassembled. She kept Wonder Man alive simply by loving him. Created to living beings outta thin air. Dr. Strange (the Marvel U's greatest magic user) helped deliver Wanda's kids with no idea that they weren't real. She single handedly defeated Ultron by rearranging his molecules. There are more impressive feats which came long before House of M. She's no one trick pony by any means.

As to who would win in a fight. I couldn't say. I'd lean towards Magneto but I'm sure a strong case could be made for Wanda (with or without her House of M feats)

On paper, apparently SW has the edge because of the unlimited potential of her powers and the unexpected ways in which they work. But then again, Magneto has the faster reaction time and with his powers can easily end this match before it begins, just like her. I guess it all comes down, to who can react faster and that apparently is Magneto.

Great battle. I think Wanda would win, in a tough fight. She's already stopped Mags force fields before and her hex bolts should be able to defeat him.

magneto can beat any scarlet depending if he gets to her 1st.

scarlet witch has bad- ass abilities and crazy potential but she is no good in a fight

Didn't Magneto's Force Field stands against Proteus before and was able to manipulate Proteus' energies? If Magneto did, I don't think he can't d that to his daughter.

scarlet witch's powers work somewhat in the way that domino's do (before she started reality warping).  she could easily destroy magneto's force fields.

No More Magneto

" @rayn1984 said:

" Didn't Magneto's Force Field stands against Proteus before and was able to manipulate Proteus' energies? If Magneto did, I don't think he can't d that to his daughter. "

I assumed that Magneto was simply resisting Proteus' attempts to mentally possess him.  Proteus already used his "reality warping" powers on Magneto by turning the iron in his blood into lead. So Magneto clearly has no defense against "reality warping" powers.   "

If she is insane and in full House of M mode, Wanda would obviously win. Any other time, Magneto would completely dominate her quite easily. With her normal power levels, her feats aren't consistent whereas Magneto's are.

Depending on the set up Mags can win.

Scarlet Witch

Magneto.

*sigh* 

Magneto strangles her.

Scarlet Witch.

Magneto

Scarlet Witch.

Scarlet Witch turns her own Dad into rubble

She like a lot of the Scarlet Witch threads i read could just think Magneto out of existence period.

He could absolutely physically harm and kill her in the right circumstances Magneto is insanely powerful regardless.

Wanda wins before the fight even commences realistically because her reality warping powers alone are by far to much for Erik to play games with, she wouldn't even need the rest of her abilities if he no longer exists and never did.

Magneto

SW

Magneto wins, as of now.

Current Scarlet Witch, just like current Doctor Strange is depowered, due to Empirikull's actions on destroying magic, so in short magic is in bad state and is gonna be restored by slowly, and the magic users are now depowered because of that, they are barely mid-tier to say the least.

If we go by the versions by the time this thread was created, then Scarlet Witch wins this one, just casts some hax spell and done.

SW.

Wanda,any high tier sorcerer would beat magneto

Wanda. She's been stated to be capable of repeating House of M.

Wanda.

Magneto Wins. Magneto knows how to scarlet Witch. It can paralyze the Electromagnetic Field.

Magneto

Wanda stomps she can freeze time

@marygcrisostomo: @spydey328: as I’ve stated above Wanda can and has frozen time mid combat including against Thor while he was mid blitz

@emmafrostxmen: Yes I changed my mind after looking up their fight in AXIS as seen in a different thread

Magneto turns into a pile of bricks with a singe thought from Wanda

Scarlet Witch.

hmm this could go either way