Mace Windu runs a gauntlet

1. Savage Opress

2. Grandmaster Satele Shan

3. RebelsAhsokaTano

4. TCWMaul

5. FE Darth Malgus

6. SOD Maul

7. Count Dooku

8. Darth Vader

9. Yoda

10. SOR Revan

11. Darth Plagueis

8 IMO

Most likely stops at Vader.

Stops at Vader or Yoda

Stop at Vader

Round 1: Mace wins easily

Round 2: A challenge given that Ahsoka contended with Vader, but still probably wins 9/10

Round 3: Mace wins easily

Round 4: Mace probably passes, but FE Malgus is ridiculously powerful. He should definitely be above TCW Maul.

Round 5: Maul was casually dominated by Sidious, at least Mace was able to contend. It does not matter whether Sidious is holding back, I would say that he outclasses Maul by a fair amount.

Round 6: Wins 7/10

Round 7: Stops at Vader. Extremely close fight, but I always hold Vader slightly above Mace.

Round 8: Yoda is stated by multiple sources to be above Mace. I say he wins for sure.

Round 9: Comparable in terms of dueling, but Revan outclasses him for quite a large amount in the force IMO.

Round 10: ...

As far as the films go, Mace was always intended to be second only to Yoda himself as a fighter. This is extensively and repeatedly outlined in the various prequel documentaries, featurettes, insider interviews, etc. The Emperor comes in at third, maybe Count Dooku at fourth, and no one else in the mythos even comes close. That's what Palpatine vs Masters Agen Kolar, Saesee Tiin and Kit Fisto was supposed to hit across.

Legends he stops at Yoda. Beats Revan and Hego though.

The order of this is really wierd. Ahsoka is above Maul for starters

Anyway Mace isn't beating Yoda, i guess that will do.

@bayman007 Her beating a barley trying Maul doesn’t put her above him.

Borderline stomps every round with mildly increasing effort until the hard stop at Yoda.

I fixed the list

Stops at 9 imo.

Barely trying Maul lmfao. She beats Prime Maul as of S7, and by Rebels has grown significantly that she contended with Prime Vader on a DS Nexus. Maul has no such feats, other than being brushed aside by her, just before she faced her old master. She is above him, make No mistake about that

Bro you can’t keep using the excuse “they’re legends characters” for scaling and battles. SOD and TCW Maul are composite characters

Lmao no. Prime Maul is comparative to ROTS Anakin in power

@achillesspawn that may be true but some canon characters at different points in time for their character can scale above some legends characters at different points in time for their character

Anakin would destroy Prime Maul.

No, Anakin wouldn’t even destroy TPM Maul

@achillesspawn Satele ragdolling Malgus isn’t an “insane” feat, just a bit impressive. I don’t need to make it legends Maul because both TCW and SOD Maul are composite. I don’t think I should take out Ahsoka because at this point in time she is pretty powerful

Haha good one. Maul Was 100% trying lmao. Prime Vader is Rebels Vader, as confirmed by the producers of the show.

^what is that responding to?

Your joke comments.

I could envision TPM Maul putting up a fight to TCW Anakin but TCW or SOD Maul vs ROTS Anakin would be a better fight. If it’s ROTS Anakin he crushes TPM Maul

@bayman007 none of my comments were meant to be jokes

They sure as hell are funny. No offence.

@achillesspawn IIRC I looked on the Legends page for Gar Saxon on Wookiepidea and it showed him in SOD, which would be meaning that is his only source in Legends. The point is that makes SOD composite

@achillesspawn: Disney bought Star Wars in 2012 but the date of the split is 25 april 2014. Legacy vol 2 comic series started in 2013 for example, but it's considered legends.

SOD is definitely both legends and canon. I think some physical copies even have the legends banner.

What in the name of Christ is that order? Revan should be below Yoda, and Plagueis should be the penultimate round at best.

Legends: Prime (Office) or ROTS Mace beats everyone except Yoda. AOTC/TCW beats everyone except Dooku, Vader (possibly), Yoda and maybe Plagueis.

Yes, you can. The two operate by different rules and continuities. Son of Dathomir exists in both, as does TCW, but that's no different to Maul being in the films and the films being "continuity" to both. There are very clear differences between the two.

9 or 10

beats Plagueis though

Take this back actually, non Vaapad Windu would stop at Vader, and the order should be as follows:

1. Savage

2. Satele

3. Malgus

4. Dooku

5. Vader

6. Plagueis

7. Revan

8. Maul

9. Yoda

Don't know where to put Ahsoka since she isn't a Legends character.

Bro what is this list? You put Maul far above Dooku and above Revan and Plagueis. Yoda isn’t above Plagueis either. And Maul isn‘t far above Satele or Malgus.

What is this list? How is Maul above Revan and Plagueis?

Why is Yoda below Revan and DP?

Dooku and Vader die, stops at Yoda.