Luminara Unduli and Shaak Ti vs Adi Gallia and Depa Billaba

SCENARIO

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Four of the most prominent female Jedi Masters of their time engage in an dual to the death. Both Teams think the others have fallen to the dark side and betrayed the Jedi Order. Who is going to win and why?

RULES/SETTING

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Jedi Temple

No Morals

Everyone in their Prime

Canon & Legends Feats allowed.

BONUS ROUND

____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

All four Jedi Masters team up against an enraged Rogue One Vader. Can they take him together?

Team 2 since Shaak has no canon dueling feats.

Team 2 for sure, both Adi and Depa have better feats than Luminara and Ti is featless

@jedisympathiz3r: @nassergrant19: @uhu123:@alextheboss:

What about the Bonus Round?

If Tii has no cannon feats then team 2 wins.

Bonus round Vader stomps all 4 of them.

Team 2

Team 2.

Luminara Unduli is a prominent Jedi Master, but I don't see any reason to believe she can best a High Councilor. Team 2, therefore.

As for the bonus round, any single Master here is capable of holding their own against Darth Vader in single combat. He certainly cannot match with two, or three, or all four.

Shaak beats Depa. Luminara beats Gallia.

Team 2 in a close fight though in both canon and legends ti almost solos. I do not need to explain why, we’ve all seen the respect threads and we all know her canon fate is dubious.

Any two of these ladies of the force can match vader in an early fight, but in a marathon duel with the force skills included for prolonged single combat, ti is the only one with any real chance.

Shaak Ti's team due to her Clone Wars 2D feats.

This although Deepa is no slouch herself.

It says Canon and Legends feats, so I see no reason why Team 1 shouldn't take this decisively.

Ti does have a canon dueling feat in Star Wars: Women Of The Galaxy where its noted she fought Grievous to a standstill during the Battle of Coruscant until he used electric cabling to shock her and knock her out. Not that she'll need anything in canon given her EU feats are enough.

Intriguing. The cables bit is mentioned in the canon reprint of Lightsabers: A Guide to Weapons of the Force, but not the stalemate. Have you a scan?

It's either way in either continuity. Depa is the overall MVP regardless of continuity, and Luminara, the least impressive. It's all close, however. I believe that Depa or Gallia would outfence Luminara before Shaak can outfence Gallia. Team 2, hard-fought 6/10.

@wollfmyth209: @lord_tenebrous: i would like to see that too.

@cozyy1: Unfortunately, I don't have a copy of Women of the Galaxy on hand, but I've been trying to find one for months now. I did read Shaak's blurb back when it was initially released a year ago, so take this with a grain of salt.

I'll try to find the blurb again, or hopefully find the book and buy it and DM y'all the full paragraph.

Depa probs carries

Team 2. Adi is at least as good as Luminara, possibly better, and Depa is a better fighter than Shaak imo.

Depa is in a league above the others.

Team 2 without much problem

Depa > Shaak Ti

Gallia > Luminara

Team 2. Both members are superior to either of team 1.