Luke Skywalker VS Dracule Mihawk

Swordfight only, The only abilities that are allowed are Observation Haki and Force Precog. Speed is equalised as is strength. Luke still has his lightsaber and I will assume that Mihawk's sword is the same thing as a sith sword (which can match lightsabers if used correctly), so that both have the weapon they are best with.

VS

Luke.

Mihawk is more experienced and practices everyday by fighting those Humandrills on his island. He hasn't taken a hit so far in the series and he's barely tried in his fights, in fact he's looked bored when performing his best feats. I think he's the better swordsman.

And a busoshoku amped sword should match a lightsabre just fine.

@leo-343: Mihawk should stomp

@leo-343: Depends on the person using it. But assuming we are using Grand Master Luke then its pretty strong.

Mihawk

Luke eclipses Mihawk in skill, and is variant of Precognition is superior.

There is no proof of Mihawk having precog and he miserably failed to cut dying Luffy (Who had no precog at the time).

@d3athstroke: No proof of him having precog? Who taught Zoro haki then? The monkeys?

@goldroger said:

Zoros precognition feats please ?

@d3athstroke: Sensing Pica and pin pointing his location and where he would appear next in Dressrosa and sensing a wild animal in the Fishman palace.

@goldroger said:

He did not sense Pica. Disconnected parts of Golem where turning back into stone and Zoro was cutting them off to see which ones remained animated. What wild animal did he sense and how ? scan please.

@d3athstroke: No, when he was riding that bull with Luffy he used observation haki to sense where Pica would appear.

Sensing an animal: http://img.mangastream.com/m/5/64985431/2ea13764f1d181e890467fe1fbbb941f.png

Mihawk. One slash from his sword can split a glacier apart, Luke wouldn't even come near him without being sliced apart.

@goldroger: sensing an animal is not precog... Sensing when someone is about to attack or something bad is about to happen is(glimpses into the future).

That is more of sensing a presence.

@saikyo3000: Luke would have no problem dodging that. Both are the best in their respective universe and am not sure who will win. Will go with Mihawk though since force powers are a no-go. If he had full use of the force then Luke wins.

@leo-343: Still doesn't make it precog:P. He has been shown using observation haki but not the precog form of it is what i should of said i suppose.

Mihawk should win with these conditions

@leo-343: That is a better example(with hodi) though i only remember luffy using it to dodge water bullets. so a scan would be cool. Not necessarily true. Dunno how good his mastery over observation haki is so he my not be able to use the precog aspect of it. To my knowledge he has never been shown using precog. Knowing observation haki doesn't mean you have it mastered is what i am getting at i guess.

@leo-343: Exactly. The only comparison we have is Zoro..and he isn't anymore skilled than someone like Jacen Solo or Mace Windu even. GM Luke is by far the most adroit duelist in the entire Star Wars Mythos. Zoro nor Mihawk can't compare.

@leo-343: I didn't say Jacen or Mace were leagues below Luke, I said they were more skilled than Zoro. Mihawk has virtually no skill feats to compare with Luke, literally the only benchmark we have to go off on is regarding Zoro and even that's ill-defined past "he's much less skilled".

@leo-343: Based on actual skill feats against other well established fighters and relevant accolades?

Off topic, but is there a star wars respect thread, so i can see some of their feats.

I know they are a lot stronger in the eu, but isnt that now non-canon since disney took over.

"effortlessly matching Vista while looking in another direction"

Both Vista and Mihawk were casual and both stalemated each other, Mihawk is Vista leveled.

Vista and Mihawk never fought before then so saying Mihawk is the best swordsman is wrong, he simply has the title.

Luke is more skilled by feats. One Piece "skill" is rather shaky, because it ends up just becoming slice slice cut cut stab stab until one guy falls over after one strike (unless they're Zoro).

@pantypolice: Lol, if he isn't the best swordsman why does everybody regard him as the best swordsman?

Skill feats for Luke?