Jocasta Nu vs Eldra Kaitis

Round 1: Force only

Round 2: Saber Duel

Round 3: All-out

Battle takes place inside the Jedi Council Chamber.

@frozen, @darthor, @jedisympathiz3r, @emmafrostxmen, @daddyprometheus, @sheevsmacker, @void_reborn, @alextheboss, @thebluedragon20, @turtleman1878, @gangorca, @warlockmage, @heiqn, @geekryan@marvelfan1992, @supremegeneration, @angelica10, @lightyagamigod2, @xmen5ever, @maulsmacker, @uhu123, @lord_tenebrous, @sonofdarkness, @the_swaggot, @samgee, @dirtyluna, @cryolancer47, @lazerbeak, @gaoron, @god_vulcan, @straight-fire, @eredin12, @achillesspawn, @catman5, @shroudofsorrow

Jocasta is middling in the force and barely competent with a lightsaber according to Sidious so Eldra should win all rounds

Proof:

Jocasta isn't much of a combatant. She's a historian and not one that's knowledgable in the force like Treya who's really powerful but more of knows everything about the galaxy. But this isn't really going to help her in a fight against a Jedi semi-warrior

Bump

R1: Probably Eldra

R2: Could go either way

R3: Jocasta shoots her

@rhubarb: I wasn’t intending to include the saber-gun in Jocasta’s arsenal when I made the thread, lol.

@a_fine_edition:

I figured, still I always love to bring it up in light of Jocasta's lack of combat experience

@rhubarb: fair enough

R1: Eldra

R2: Maybe Jocasta

R3: Eldra wins mid-high diff

Bump

Jedi Master and former council member vs promising Padawan. This seems somewhat one sided.

@americanspeeddemon: Jocasta's actual performance and feats say otherwise in my opinion. Being on the Council didn't stop her from losing to the Grand Inquisitor before he received his Dark Side training, and didn't stop her from getting jumped and KO'd by Cato Parasitti. And as posted farther up, Sidious holds her in intensely low regard, seemingly below average for a Jedi.

Bump

Eldra easily. Jocasta is explicitly an awful combatan who got stomped by pre-training GI. Eldra held her own and even kinda beat Pre-TPM Maul

@cheth: I wouldn’t say he stomped her, but she was definitely on the losing end of that fight.

@a_fine_edition: I mean on one hand I do agree that Maul > Eldra, but it was a 6 page long duel in which Maul scored two kicks and Eldra scored one lightsaber hit and one force push, and a duel she ended up winning (he killed her with a backstab after she thought the fight over). This is something unimaginable for Jocasta to replicate after being stomped by pre-training GI lol

Don't know if Darth Sidious of all people calling you "middling in the force and barely competent with the lightsaber" is really that bad in reality. Different people have different standards. In Legends, Sidious reffered to Sedriss as "a moderate force-wielder" which is pretty much the same as "middling", yet he could hold his own against DE Luke, so these taunts by Sheev are hardly an indicator of much.

The Grand Inquisitour who Jocasta held off was still the best of the inquisitours, including Prosset Dibs who pre-Dark Side turn was "as strong as any Jedi I have known" according to Mace Windu and didn't get stomped by a holding back Mace in their duel.

Eldra's feat against Maul, stupid as it is, is still better but it's a probably a fairly close contest.