Jacen Solo Vs. Darth Sidious (Read OP)

OK, this fight will have three rounds.

Round 1 is Darth Caedus under the same circumstances that allowed him to do well against Luke Vs. RotS Darth Sidious

Round 2 is the same as Round 2 except its DE Sidious

Round 3 is Dark Empire Sidious Vs. Jacen Solo when he briefly achieved Oneness during the climax of the Yuuzhan Vong invasion

Who wins the fights?

Round 1: Sidious stomps.

Round 2: Sidious stomps

Round 3: Arguable. I'd still give it to Sidious, but i might be wrong.

Bump

Round 1 Sideous wins, though not easily.

Round 2 Sideous stomps

Round 3 don't know, its a close one.

@guttridgeb said:

Round 1 Sideous wins, though not easily.

Round 2 Sideous stomps

Round 3 don't know, its a close one.

If Caedus was able to do well against Luke, shouldn't that mean he could do well against Sidious since LotF Luke>Sidious?

@shroudofsorrow said:

@guttridgeb said:

Round 1 Sideous wins, though not easily.

Round 2 Sideous stomps

Round 3 don't know, its a close one.

If Caedus was able to do well against Luke, shouldn't that mean he could do well against Sidious since LotF Luke>Sidious?

I've always thought the main reason Jacen did well was due to Luke holding back a bit. I might be wrong though.

Thinking about it, Round 1 could go either way so I'm not sure on that one.

@guttridgeb: Oh. I was under the impression that there were additional circumstances involved that allowed Caedus to do well.

Bump

Bump.

Sidious wins all rounds.

Round 1: Caedeus. Seriously, Luke might not have been at 100% after the death of Mara, but he was still Grandmaster Luke and Caedeus WAS stalemating him, and Sidious wasn't as powerful before he returned from the dead.

Round 2: Sidious. While I might be the head of the "Star Wars feats aren't as impressive as they seem" brigade, Darth Sidious, post resurrection, was the most powerful Sith of all time (except MAYBE for Darth Nihilus). He won't stomp, but he wins handily.

Round 3: I really don't know. I'm not sure what Jacen was actually able to accomplish in this state. He might arguably have had the same potential as Anakin/Luke, and he briefly came one with the force itself, which would imply that he would become a Force God, but I really don't know if that holds true.

I'm most curious about round 3

Uhhh, Jacen stomps round 3.

Why? I'm not disputing, it's just Darth Sidious being the most powerful sith lord of all time seems like he should have the advantage

Yeah...sidious should have the advantage for most of the rounds....3rd round is arguable...

Bump

Between Grandmaster Luke, Dark Empire Sidious and Darth Caedus in his Prime, who wins?

Jacen stomps round 3 for sure

Jacen.

Sidious.

Jacen.

Sidious

Sidious

Jacen

1. Sidious in a good fight. Jacens probably around an unamped Windu level here but with more esoteric powers at hand to balance that out.

2 Sidious stomps

3. Jacen blinks