• 59 results
  • 1
  • 2
Avatar image for extant
#1 Edited by Extant (111 posts) - - Show Bio

Who takes the win?

No Caption Provided


No Caption Provided
No parallax kthx. Regular Hal, one GL ring, standard equipment.
Composite rainbow Hal can shut up.
Avatar image for geraldthesloth
#2 Posted by geraldthesloth (32690 posts) - - Show Bio

Surfer

Avatar image for kentaxx
#3 Posted by Kentaxx (2405 posts) - - Show Bio

Current Hal would probably win
Before gl 36 im not sure,

Avatar image for extant
#4 Posted by Extant (111 posts) - - Show Bio
@Kentaxx said:
" Current Hal would probably winBefore gl 36 im not sure, "
@geraldthesloth said:
" Surfer "
why?
Avatar image for king_saturn
#5 Posted by King Saturn (222900 posts) - - Show Bio
Silver Surfer wins here
Avatar image for emerald_general_jai
#6 Posted by Emerald_General_Jai (2480 posts) - - Show Bio

I think Hal can win this. I don't see Surfer as that far above the GL's in all honesty. An Hal's the best they have.

Avatar image for sleuth
#7 Posted by Sleuth (2649 posts) - - Show Bio
@King Saturn said:
" Silver Surfer wins here
"

Avatar image for king_saturn
#8 Posted by King Saturn (222900 posts) - - Show Bio
@Emerald_General_Jai said:
" I think Hal can win this. I don't see Surfer as that far above the GL's in all honesty. An Hal's the best they have. "
How the hell is Hal as strong as the Silver Surfer ? The Surfer has a far greater range with his powers...
Avatar image for decept_o
#9 Posted by Decept-O (8098 posts) - - Show Bio

Oh, man, much as I love Hal Jordan......oy...Silver Surfer would probably take it.  The fact of the matter is, Silver Surfer wields the Power Cosmic, and can survive in most any environment, especially space, a lot longer than Hal. 

Remember, Hal is still human despite his powerful GL ring, and would eventually tire.  Surfer doesn't have such weaknesses, is near invulnerable.  Yes, Hal can erect a protective aura and all, but how long can he maintain it?  His willpower is key, but again, natural fatigue would set in. 

Also, keep in mind Surfer's strength is incredible, in the 100 Class, or am I mistaken?  I can't recall, I should look it up but I am going off memory here.  Yes Hal can use the ring to assist in the strength department, but Surfer's strength is not dependent on a ring nor anything else. 

Also, I think given the powerful cosmic nature of Surfer's blasts, they'd tear right through anything Hal would create and shoot. 

I really, really want to say Hal, but just due to the fact how incredibly powerful Surfer is,  he'd take it. 

I could be wrong.

Avatar image for king_james_5
#10 Posted by king_james_5 (99 posts) - - Show Bio

the current hal would win, but not the regular one

surfer

Avatar image for sinestron
#11 Posted by Sinestron (199 posts) - - Show Bio

Hal Jordan could win and thats who my vote is for. Silver Surfer is very powerful, but the green lantern ring is one of the most powerful weapons ever made. Both Hal and Norrin have had their powers bestowed upon them by very powerful immortals. I just think Hal is the better warrior here.

Avatar image for extant
#12 Posted by Extant (111 posts) - - Show Bio

This isn't composite whatever Hal, it's standard GL Hal as shown in the image.

Avatar image for emerald_general_jai
#13 Posted by Emerald_General_Jai (2480 posts) - - Show Bio
@King Saturn said:
"
@Emerald_General_Jai said:
" I think Hal can win this. I don't see Surfer as that far above the GL's in all honesty. An Hal's the best they have. "
How the hell is Hal as strong as the Silver Surfer ? The Surfer has a far greater range with his powers... "

Most of which can be accomplished w/ a GL ring if used correctly. If you go based on the normal everyday powerset they use (not their most exotic) Hal can match him in EP blasts and has his constructs. Norrin isn't really a warrior, whereas Hal is. I don't think he can simply overpower him, or any GL really (w/e gap there is, it isn't that large) and Hal has what he needs to beat SS.
Avatar image for extant
#14 Edited by Extant (111 posts) - - Show Bio
@Emerald_General_Jai said:
"
@King Saturn said:
"
@Emerald_General_Jai said:
" I think Hal can win this. I don't see Surfer as that far above the GL's in all honesty. An Hal's the best they have. "
How the hell is Hal as strong as the Silver Surfer ? The Surfer has a far greater range with his powers... "
Most of which can be accomplished w/ a GL ring if used correctly. If you go based on the normal everyday powerset they use (not their most exotic) Hal can match him in EP blasts and has his constructs. Norrin isn't really a warrior, whereas Hal is. I don't think he can simply overpower him, or any GL really (w/e gap there is, it isn't that large) and Hal has what he needs to beat SS. "
Rephrase: how do you know what the gap is? because their powers are similar or what?
Avatar image for geraldthesloth
#15 Posted by geraldthesloth (32690 posts) - - Show Bio

are gl rings immune to trasnmutation?

Avatar image for nibiru
#16 Posted by Nibiru (683 posts) - - Show Bio
@geraldthesloth said:
"are gl rings immune to trasnmutation?"

Yes.
Avatar image for emerald_general_jai
#17 Edited by Emerald_General_Jai (2480 posts) - - Show Bio
@Extant said:
"
@Emerald_General_Jai said:
"
@King Saturn said:
"
@Emerald_General_Jai said:
" I think Hal can win this. I don't see Surfer as that far above the GL's in all honesty. An Hal's the best they have. "
How the hell is Hal as strong as the Silver Surfer ? The Surfer has a far greater range with his powers... "
Most of which can be accomplished w/ a GL ring if used correctly. If you go based on the normal everyday powerset they use (not their most exotic) Hal can match him in EP blasts and has his constructs. Norrin isn't really a warrior, whereas Hal is. I don't think he can simply overpower him, or any GL really (w/e gap there is, it isn't that large) and Hal has what he needs to beat SS. "
Rephrase: how do you know what the gap is? because their powers are similar or what?"

I'm talkin about the gap in power. There are people who think SS is magnatudes more powerful than the Lanterns (even the main 4 Earth Lanterns) and that even current Ion would get owned. There are those who think their equals, and those who think GL rings are more powerful. I'm of the opinion that their quite close, w/ maybe a small advantage to SS. Mostly i based it off their standing in their relative universe's and the strength of the foes they fight (SS being comparable w/ Thor, Sentry, Hulk, and the fact GL's have enough power at their disposal to beat opponents of that level)  makes me think their in the same range, or as most battle boards i visit refer to it Herald Class. I think a GL ring makes you anywhere between a low-tier (rookies) to mid-tier (Vets) herald. Master's of the ring (Hal, John, Kilowog, Kyle, Guy) are Top-TIer, which is where SS is placed. While i think Kyle would loose (he, just like Norrin isn't really a warrior at heart, and SS being more powerful would edge him out, though if Tomasi keeps turning him into a Veteran Soldier my opinion will change soon.) I think Hal would edge Norrin out most times, he would find the way to win.
Avatar image for bumnut
#18 Posted by bumnut (1847 posts) - - Show Bio

Surfer, 9.5/10! He can do things well outside of Hal's abilities ;-)

Avatar image for jade1977
#19 Posted by Jade1977 (1029 posts) - - Show Bio

As much as I love Hal, I think the Surfer would probably win. He is simply too much for any one GL to handle.

Avatar image for sesaw
#20 Posted by SeSAW (3694 posts) - - Show Bio

Surfer could beat Hal, Kyle, and John together and Im not being bias either

Avatar image for truepwnge
#21 Edited by TruePwnge (2798 posts) - - Show Bio

Surfer can win and Hal can win. Its very close.
I think Hal might take it since his personality is more hardcore, if we stay true to Surfer the Silver guy is a peacemaker. He came from a peaceful race, he likes to talk while fighting and never totally unleashes himself say like doing something totally hardcore like turning his opponent to vapor. Surfer is not a true destructive fighter, just an advanced man transformed by Galactus with incredible powers. I think Hal will be able to eventually do something to win

That's not saying Surfer can't win, the fight could easily go his way. A GL once lost to Silver Surfer, there is no shame in it. Surfer is incredibly powerful can beat just about anyone, Wonder Woman, Superman maybe even stomp Darkseid.
if we stay true to Surfer's personality I think Hal can win since he's more aggressive and cunning

Hal wins, just barely


Avatar image for lagoonboy2
#22 Posted by lagoon_boy (11337 posts) - - Show Bio
surfer wins, hal can put up a fight a good fight but the lantern will soon run out ( and if not surfer can break away ) surfer is more faster and speed with a strengt comined are dangerous force to be messing with
Avatar image for truepwnge
#23 Posted by TruePwnge (2798 posts) - - Show Bio

Yeah maybe I'm a little biased saying Hal takes it

Surfer can probably win this

Avatar image for lagoonboy2
#24 Posted by lagoon_boy (11337 posts) - - Show Bio
@TruePwnge said:
" Yeah maybe I'm a little biased saying Hal takes itSurfer can probably win this "
lol
Avatar image for weapon_x_badazz
#25 Posted by weapon x badazz (713 posts) - - Show Bio

Norrin

Avatar image for truepwnge
#26 Posted by TruePwnge (2798 posts) - - Show Bio

Surfer probably drains the ring of its energy

Avatar image for lagoonboy2
#27 Posted by lagoon_boy (11337 posts) - - Show Bio
silver surfer takes this, it wont be easy, cuz i believe surfer cant absorb plasma (if im right)
Avatar image for akwa
#28 Posted by Akwa (4780 posts) - - Show Bio
King Saturn said:
Silver Surfer wins here

Avatar image for vegeta
#29 Posted by vegeta (5244 posts) - - Show Bio
Avatar image for silverman91
#30 Posted by SilverMan91 (483 posts) - - Show Bio

if fight s in character the SS wil not win this his personality will lead him down hill, if fight is bloodlusted...well.......bye bye hal
Avatar image for jeronimo
#31 Posted by Jeronimo (809 posts) - - Show Bio

The Silver Surfer's powers are NOT dependant on his state of mind. Also, SS does not fatigue. 
 
The Silver Surfer takes it.
Avatar image for fire_brand
#32 Posted by Fire-brand (2342 posts) - - Show Bio

i'd bet that Norrin could drain Hal's ring and leave him powerless. even if he couldn't, Norrin is nigh invulnerable and is far faster and stronger. Plus, his energy projection is arguably higher.

Avatar image for the_mjolnir_wielder
#33 Posted by The Mjolnir Wielder (8467 posts) - - Show Bio

Current Surfer could probably handle Hal, but he would get WTFpwned by Kyle.

Avatar image for sexy_merc
#34 Posted by Sexy Merc (42478 posts) - - Show Bio
@The Mjolnir Wielder said:
" Current Surfer could probably handle Hal, but he would get WTFpwned by Kyle. "
I had a feeling you would bring in Kyle for some reason...
Avatar image for the_mjolnir_wielder
#35 Posted by The Mjolnir Wielder (8467 posts) - - Show Bio
@Sexy Merc said:
" @The Mjolnir Wielder said:
" Current Surfer could probably handle Hal, but he would get WTFpwned by Kyle. "
I had a feeling you would bring in Kyle for some reason... "
Hey, we have to continue to remind everyone who the undisputed top GL is ;)
Avatar image for sexy_merc
#36 Posted by Sexy Merc (42478 posts) - - Show Bio
@The Mjolnir Wielder said:
" @Sexy Merc said:
" @The Mjolnir Wielder said:
" Current Surfer could probably handle Hal, but he would get WTFpwned by Kyle. "
I had a feeling you would bring in Kyle for some reason... "
Hey, we have to continue to remind everyone who the undisputed top GL is ;) "
He always was in my eyes, even as a kid, lol. I just finished my collection of every appearance he has in comics a week ago. Had to buy that hideous Marvel vs DC crossover.
Avatar image for comicstooge
#37 Posted by ComicStooge (22062 posts) - - Show Bio

Silver Surfer takes down a large section of the Green Lanterns by himself.

Avatar image for the_mjolnir_wielder
#38 Posted by The Mjolnir Wielder (8467 posts) - - Show Bio
@Sexy Merc said:
" @The Mjolnir Wielder said:
" @Sexy Merc said:
" @The Mjolnir Wielder said:
" Current Surfer could probably handle Hal, but he would get WTFpwned by Kyle. "
I had a feeling you would bring in Kyle for some reason... "
Hey, we have to continue to remind everyone who the undisputed top GL is ;) "
He always was in my eyes, even as a kid, lol. I just finished my collection of every appearance he has in comics a week ago. Had to buy that hideous Marvel vs DC crossover. "
I sold that crossover already, 99.9% of the fans had no idea where any of them stood as characters.
Avatar image for the_mjolnir_wielder
#39 Posted by The Mjolnir Wielder (8467 posts) - - Show Bio
@ComicStooge said:
"Silver Surfer takes down a large section of the Green Lanterns by himself."
No, he doesn't
Avatar image for sexy_merc
#40 Posted by Sexy Merc (42478 posts) - - Show Bio
@The Mjolnir Wielder said:
" @Sexy Merc said:
" @The Mjolnir Wielder said:
" @Sexy Merc said:
" @The Mjolnir Wielder said:
" Current Surfer could probably handle Hal, but he would get WTFpwned by Kyle. "
I had a feeling you would bring in Kyle for some reason... "
Hey, we have to continue to remind everyone who the undisputed top GL is ;) "
He always was in my eyes, even as a kid, lol. I just finished my collection of every appearance he has in comics a week ago. Had to buy that hideous Marvel vs DC crossover. "
I sold that crossover already, 99.9% of the fans had no idea where any of them stood as characters. "
Well, I had to make sure I had all of his appearances and to my knowledge, I finally do.
Avatar image for difficlus
#41 Posted by difficlus (10659 posts) - - Show Bio

SS wins this probably 10/10

Avatar image for spidey_15
#42 Posted by spidey 15 (17883 posts) - - Show Bio

SS 
=]

Avatar image for pr_beyonder
#43 Posted by Pr_Beyonder (2528 posts) - - Show Bio
@spidey 15 said:
"SS =] "

@difficlus said:
"SS wins this probably 10/10 "
Avatar image for sexy_merc
#44 Posted by Sexy Merc (42478 posts) - - Show Bio
@difficlus said:
" SS wins this probably 10/10 "
Using only current versions, he maxes out at 8.
Avatar image for difficlus
#45 Posted by difficlus (10659 posts) - - Show Bio
@Sexy Merc said:
" @difficlus said:
" SS wins this probably 10/10 "
Using only current versions, he maxes out at 8. "
how does Hal win the other 2 times?
Avatar image for spidey_15
#46 Posted by spidey 15 (17883 posts) - - Show Bio
@Sexy Merc said:
" @difficlus said:
" SS wins this probably 10/10 "
Using only current versions, he maxes out at 8. "
If we were going by classic versions?  
=]
Avatar image for push
#47 Posted by Push (1558 posts) - - Show Bio
@geraldthesloth said:
"Surfer "

With relative ease.  SS has access to unlimited PC, he doesn't need to rechard, and has feats that no GL has matched or shown capable of doing compared to a very high end herald like SS.  SS 9/10.
Avatar image for sexy_merc
#48 Posted by Sexy Merc (42478 posts) - - Show Bio
@spidey 15 said:
" @Sexy Merc said:
" @difficlus said:
" SS wins this probably 10/10 "
Using only current versions, he maxes out at 8. "
If we were going by classic versions?  =] "
Pre-Crisis Hal would win pretty easily.
 
@difficlus said:
" @Sexy Merc said:
" @difficlus said:
" SS wins this probably 10/10 "
Using only current versions, he maxes out at 8. "
how does Hal win the other 2 times? "
He's been able to react to people like Hank who has higher combat speed than Surfer and he's able to physically compete with class 100s. On top of that, he is very versatile.
Avatar image for spidey_15
#49 Posted by spidey 15 (17883 posts) - - Show Bio
@Sexy Merc: Oh, ok then! 
Well, can i ask how powerful pre crisis Hal was? 
=]
Avatar image for push
#50 Posted by Push (1558 posts) - - Show Bio
@Sexy Merc said:
Pre-Crisis Hal would win pretty easily.
 


Against the SS??