I think that the good doctor will win
Dr. Manhattan vs Silver Surfer
This topic is locked from further discussion.
@jojjimbo said:
Manhattan can create star system...yet it was stated that he couldn't even stop all of the Russian nukes...He's Omniscient, yet was fooled into believing that he had given his friends cancer, all powerful..yet he couldn't prevent the destruction of several major cities. for the last time, Manhattan isn't omniscient/omnipotent/omnipresent...he is not a god, hes a matter/energy manipulator...stop making false claims. Silver Surfer shows Manhattan what a real matter/energy manipulator can do.
I concur. I couldn't have said it better.
@Erik said:
@JediXMan:
I thought it was settled years ago that SS would easily crush Dr. Manhattan and it had absolutely nothing to do with who was more powerful but everything to do with SS's ability to absorb energy. Is this still true?
Oh yes. I just feel like calling the guy out on it. I usually wouldn't but he felt the need to bump a thread that hasn't seen action in almost a year; clearly this person must have something to say.
@JediXMan said:
@Erik said:
@JediXMan:
I thought it was settled years ago that SS would easily crush Dr. Manhattan and it had absolutely nothing to do with who was more powerful but everything to do with SS's ability to absorb energy. Is this still true?
Oh yes. I just feel like calling the guy out on it. I usually wouldn't but he felt the need to bump a thread that hasn't seen action in almost a year; clearly this person must have something to say.
LOL clearly.
Sorry I'm kind of new and I was wondering weather surfer can just call on his power source so Dr. Manhattan gets blasted.
Manhattan has almost every advantage. Doc is unkillable while Surfer is not. The battle ends with a pile of dust that used to be the Silver Surfer and Dr. Manhattan meditating on Mars.
@Zompirewolf249 said:
Manhattan has almost every advantage. Doc is unkillable while Surfer is not. The battle ends with a pile of dust that used to be the Silver Surfer and Dr. Manhattan meditating on Mars.
Read through the pages dude. I did. It's pretty clear that Surfer would win this fight.
@Zompirewolf249 said:
Doc is unkillable while Surfer is not.
He has only ever, ever come back from one single attack ever shown on pages, and this makes him unkillable? Intrinsic Field removal....that is it. Can you prove that every attack he would ever suffer removes an intrinsic field? You can't, and as such, stating he is unkillable is a little over the top=P
Ohh great Moderators of Comicvine!! I beseech you, come and help us in our time of need!! Please lock this terrible thread and end this cursed abomination. *Prays for the help of the Moderators!!*
@OmgOmgWtfWtf said:
Ohh great Moderators of Comicvine!! I beseech you, come and help us in our time of need!! Please lock this terrible thread and end this cursed abomination. *Prays for the help of the Moderators!!*
In terms of power on teh forums, Moderators are like what...Watchers? lol
SS is powerful but he has power source he has weakness list any weaknesses dr M tachyon is just a type radiation that kinda mess with his vision of the future besides that it does nothing to him glactus and other has power sources and weaknesses even if he wad trap into a blackhole he would ust think hisself somewhete else or trsp Ss into a force field inside the sun or just think him away or bring into the blackhole with him ss is still matter dr M is beyond the physical world its like trying to fight with the wind or cacthing water with holes in your hand dr M can trap ds into his body and ss foolishy
SS is powerful but he has power source he has weakness list any weaknesses dr M tachyon is just a type radiation that kinda mess with his vision of the future besides that it does nothing to him glactus and other has power sources and weaknesses even if he wad trap into a blackhole he would ust think hisself somewhete else or trsp Ss into a force field inside the sun or just think him away or bring into the blackhole with him ss is still matter dr M is beyond the physical world its like trying to fight with the wind or cacthing water with holes in your hand dr M can trap ds into his body and ss foolishy
1. What's stopping Silver Surfer from taking Dr Manhattan to the astral plane and screwing with him there?
2. Silver Surfer himself has stated he could make singularities in people head. He's even made a black hole beforehand (although he ran away from it lol).
3. Silver Surfer can Warp, and the furthest Doc Manhattan has ever teleported someone to is Mars.
4. Silver Surfer has flown through a sun. Not Just walked on its surface.
5.Silver Surfer can also turn intangible too. He can also trap people in his board too.
Simply put, Manhattan has done nothing to put himself on the level of Silver Surfer. He openly admitted that he could stop all the Soviet missiles. Silver Surfer channeled the energies of the crunch, and destroyed a Planet in his fight with Morg. Silver Surfer is a Telepath who can travel to the Astral Plane at will. Doc Manhattan didn't know he was tricked into thinking his wife had cancer. Doc Manhattan has transmuted Viet Cong Soldiers into bloody messes. Silver Surfer has transmuted alien who could survive in space into nothing but Atoms.
Calling Doctor Manhattan a silver surfer lite is being kind to the so called "Good Doctor". If you put an herald level character in the world of Watchmen they would be regarded as Gods too.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment