
Rules
- No Prep
- Full Knowledge
- In-Character
- Bloodlust Off
- Old Man Garp
- Stand Distance Is 40 Feet
- Win By KO/Death/Incap
Location

This topic is locked from further discussion.
Doflamingo ftw
It's kind of obvious that Garp would win this.
Back in the old days, only Whitebeard and Garp were able to match Roger.
We have seen that even sick and hurt WB was able to fight against admirals, and Garp, while old, is still pretty healthy.
Garp refused the promotion to become an admiral many times.
Then he has feats like lifting millions of tons with one hand, easilly, speed blitzing Marco, destroying 8 mountains, breaking the head of a guy who cracked a small continent with a headbut... and we haven't seen him going all out yet.
anyways, we shall soon find out the full scope of DD powers, so it might be a good time to reopen this.
@mortein: Well,this is old man Garp who had passes his prime years ago.
@mortein: Well,this is old man Garp who had passes his prime years ago.
Yeah but in his prime he would have stomped DD, he was a Pirate King lv. character. Old Garp should be comparable with old WB. DD should be able to put up a fight, but I don't see him winning in any scenario.
Garp takes this, for those who said he passed his prime ? what are you talking about ? the man knocked Marco out of his phoenix form, in his old age he has shown to sign of losing a step, except falling a sleep lol
Based on feats- Doffy
Based on hype- Garp
Based on feats- Doffy
Based on hype- Garp
Based on feats- Doffy
Based on hype- Garp
This. I'd take Garp overall though.
doflamingo until garp proves otherwise
Garp is one of the two rivals of Roger he managed to corner him so many times that Roger considered him to be part of his crew. He has the hype of being the hero of the marine, father of the most wanted men of the World, grandfather of the future PK, rival of the former PK, Whitebeard reacted immediately to Garp entry in the war. He is clearly among the very top of the OPverse while Doffy isn't. Yonkou, admirals, Mihawk, Dragon, Yonkou's FM are all portrayed to be above him.
His shown feats are awesome too, old man managed to handicap a legend of the Pirate World with one punch and to inflict damages to Marco while Kizaru wasn't able to do so before Onigumo clasped Seastone Cuffs on him.
doflamingo until garp proves otherwise
Garp is one of the two rivals of the Roger he managed to corner him so many times Roger considered him to be part of his crew. This is his hype the hero of the marine, father of the most wanted men of the World, grandfather of the future PK, rival of the former PK, Whitebeard reacted immediately to Garp entry on the war. He is clearly among the very top of the OPverse while Doffy isn't. Yonkou, admirals, Mihawk, Dragon, Yonkou's FM are all portrayed to be above him.
His shown feats are awesome too, old man managed to handicap a legend of the Pirate World with one punch and to inflict damages to Marco while Kizaru wasn't able to do so before Onigumo clasped Seastone Cuffs on him.
impressive but still not definitive proof he wins so until they go into detail on his power and in this case his current power imo doflamingo wins by default.
@kal-l: im not saying that doflamingo beats everyone im saying that without feats you cant make a case for roger or garp so that is why garp loses for now but when and if he shows some of his true power that can change. and this is current garp and they haven't shown how his strength now compares to how he was in his prime. by hype of course roger should win as well as garp but there is little to prove it with actual feats.
@98115: Okay so if I get your reasoning even though Oda says that Roger was the strongest pirate of the World (only Prime Whitebeard was able to tie with him) as we didn't see him fighting, you'd choose Doffy over him. This is ludicrous. Usopp has feats unlike Roger, guess he'd win.
Old Garp does have feats and portrayal.
His shown feats are awesome too, old man managed to handicap a legend of the Pirate World with one punch and to inflict damages to Marco while Kizaru wasn't able to do so before Onigumo clasped Seastone Cuffs on him.
His feats showed a tremendous amount of strenght and his haki seems to be at the top as he is the only man who managed to reached the top of the World without mastering any weapon or any DF. On top of that he mastered the forms of the Rokushiki which allowed him to teach it to Coby.
Garp easily takes this one Donflamingo is no push over though but i believe garp is way stronger than he leads on he refused to become an Admiral given he was offered the position he fought guys like Whitebeard and Gol.D Garp takes this mid difficulty
It's pretty obvious that Garp is stronger.
If you say Garp isn't stronger than Doffy, then you are more or less saying he's weaker than his grandson Luffy.
Garp would shit on his life. He is without a doubt admiral level, shit he drew blood on Marco casually.
Garp.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment