DCEU Superman (BladeOfFury) vs EMH Thor (Maestromage)

I personally agree that the word engine feat was an outlier but blade fury proved Superman has a distinct speed advantage and since there both in character he’d likely stop Thor from using his AOE.

My vote goes to BLADE of FURY

Edit- idk why but now I want to see a CAV between DCEU Wonder Woman and teen titans 2003 starfire

my vote goes to @maestromage

Both made some incossistences in their argument, of how outliers work but he did it less and blade of fury was in other areas too.

I got surprised by how much Blade tried to lowball, as one time he said that ant man weight should be around 920 tons but next in a scene where he was about the same height he said that the ship that was arguably larger and more packed than him was...30 tons (?) or the frost giants boulder that was more than 1/3 their size is... barely human sized (?)

I mean i get that they are suposed to lowball each character, but i didn´t fell for that. His 3/last post was EXTREMELY well done a work of art tho

Could you expand a bit on your reasoning?

@asgardianweapon: Wow, thanks!

I wish I knew about this thread when BoF during our tourney CaV.

Truly a contrarian.

@thespartanb345t: smh noooooo

I was considering putting Maestro's arguments up against yours, but chose not to.

@bladeoffury: It'd be hilarious if he actually broke down your World Engine argument and you just used that against mine beat-for-beat.

That'd be genius-tier debating, using my counters to his argument to respond here while also countering them back yourself in our thread.

@thespartanb345t: But if either of you would have seen the other thread, you'd also be able to use my own arguments against me

Sure, I thought you presented your arguments better, you showed why EMH Thor was clearly superior.

Bump for voters

@bladeoffury: 3-D Chess move, use bad arguments on purpose so we steal bad arguments.

Vote Tally

@maestromage gets my vote

I am going to be as brief as I possibly can. This debate wasn't even close. @bladeoffury made some pretty claims and his overall argumentation was rooted in arbitrary fan calcs to lowball every single feat presented for EMH Thor and his weird consistency rebuttals. Maestro outdebated BoF in every single relevant aspect, from strength to speed to durability. It was just an overall sweep, with Maestro presenting more concrete feats and scaling that seemed much more consistent than the World Engine, for example.

I came here backing that Thor would win and that honestly hasn't changed. DCEU superman can beat a jobbing Thor and has a slight speed advantage is what I got. My vote goes to @maestromage and @defiant_will perfectly describes why.

After reading this debate I have to go with @maestromage. His argumentation was consistent and went back to the same references to book his argument to look strong.

Well, it seems like the voting is done. Final Tally:

Thanks to everyone for voting.

@maestromage: gg

Supes can't even handle Ragnarok Thor let alone EHM Thor.

GG