1. I never said BP's claw one shots arthur. U can see every post of mine and try finding even one, i bet u wont. I just said his claw can hurt arthur. Cap's shield has tanked all kinds of bullets from a handgun, rifle shots, high calibers and quinjet shots and never even got a scratch on it. His shield has also tanked powerful energy blasts from tesseract-based energy guns, powerful chitauri energy blasts, iron man's repulsors and loki's scepter energy blasts without getting even a scratch. His shield was also frozen for almost 70 years, tanked powerful mjolnir strikes and a grenade launcher shot without, again not a scratch on it. There are many more impressive durability feats for that shield and none has even made a scratch on it, until it met with BP's claws.
2. Does a sound mean that it made contact? Again, it didnt make contact simply by the fact that bucky's arm didnt have a scratch or even his coat. While those claws scratched cap's shield fine. If u want to talk about common sense, u must really really learn again from the start, because ur statements are senseless
3. Step's axe attacks are different from BP's claw attacks. Step's axe attacks have stronger impact, but BP's claw attacks are much sharper. Steppenwolf's axe attacks are strong by blunt force, not sharp. His attacks did one shot the amazons, but it didnt scratch even one of them as we can clearly see throughout the fight. I also never said BP's blunt force attacks can take arthur down, but his crazily sharp claws are very lethal against arthur.
4. Yes he is superior in agility, speed and skills which will all help him get the better and upper hand against arthur. It's true we didnt get to see BP cutting a bullet, but it is there in a tie in comic which is 100% legitimate here as this is MCU BP. Bucky and clint being able to tag him are feats for them, not anti feats for BP. Now i'm not saying BP will dodge all, but he will dodge most. It's like a guy who is faster, more agile, has superior skills, more durable and has crazily lethal and sharp claws against someone who is stronger. Even if arthur has his trident, he wont be able to land even a single throw or swing on BP. His trident throw really pales in comparison to a bullet shot which BP cut. His swing has only hit a weakened steppenwolf (after getting beaten up and thrown around by supes) who was a very big guy/target and much slower than BP in that weakened state.
1. Yeah i know you didn't say it, that's way I wrote 'if you think'.(And the fact that you were overselling claws damage implicitly suggesting that you might be thinking this) But now we have settled that his claw can't one shot him, that implies he's gonna need multiple shots. And only thing BP has that have chance of hurting Arthur. And BP hardly manage to tag anyone with Claws in actual fight. So it all becomes assumption. And most of the attacks you have mentioned that Cap's shield took are not piercing attacks which are capable of scratching. And Cap's shield has few scratches before. Not as good as BP's claw but still enough.
2. Yes there was an impact sound. It was clearly there. I already told you the damage depends on the force you exert while swinging, which appears to be less in that instant. The same argument you made about Steppenwolf. Not every shot of his axe has same piercing impact. it depends on the pressure he exerts while swinging. That's what inconsistency is. And it is common sense.
3. Again same point. We all know SW's axe is less sharper than BP's claws. And yes it also has blunt force due to SW's superior strength. Still it doesn't take away it's piercing ability. Considering it pierced almost every material. And I definitely didn't say that you were saying "BP's blunt force attacks can take Arthur down". We both certainly know it can't, from the beginning. BP's only shot is his claws. That too multiple.
4. Yes those feats are not in the movies, But I didn't have any problem you bringing that up. So Bucky or Clint tagging him are their feats or whether it is anti BP feat, it doesn't matter. We are comparing two different cinematic universes. So Arthur can't be in MCU to perform the feats. So I have to use the references from the characters in their universe. Same way you are using Steppenwolfs references to determine the outcome. So from their fight I can clearly tell BP can be tagged even though BP is agile enough to cut bullet in half .And without using much agility or skills. SO Arthur has every possible chance of tagging BP. Now the last point you mentioned is the definition of low balling. Yes SW took hits from Supes, same way Arthur took hits form Steppenwolf . And Steppenwolf's durability is far better than Arthur, as we evidently seen it. So they were both weekend at that stage. And they both have equal chance of hitting each other.
So come on man, this is really low-balling against Arthur.
Log in to comment