I would think TCW Obi-Wan Kenobi beats him.
ANH Vader is the same Vader described as a shadow of his former self. In fact ... let me pull up my ANH book of his fight with Ben Kenobi. I've not read it in a while:
The figure stepped out in front of him, blocking his entry to the hangar not five meters away. The outline and size of the figure completed the momentary puzzle. It was the maturity of the mind he had sensed that had temporarily confused him. His hand moved naturally to the hilt of his deactivate saber.
"I have been waiting a long time, Obi-Wan Kenobi," Darth Vader intoned solemnly. "We meet again at last. The circle has been completed." Kenobi sensed satisfaction beneath the hideous mask. "The presence I sensed earlier could only have been you."
Kenobi regarded the great form blocking his retreat and nodded slowly. He gave the impression of being more curious than impressed. "You still have much to learn."
"You were once my teacher," Vader admitted, "and I learned much from you. But the time of learning has long passed, and I am the master now."
The logic that had constituted the missing link in his brilliant pupil remained as absent as before. There would be no reasoning here, Kenobi knew. Igniting his saber, he assumed the pose of warrior-ready, a movement accomplished with the ease and elegance of a dancer.
Rather roughly, Vader imitated the movement. Several minutes followed without motion as the two men remained staring at each other, as if waiting for some proper, as yet unspoken signal.
Kenobi blinked once, shook his head, and tired to clear his eyes, which had begun to water slightly. Sweat beaded up on his forehead and his eyelids fluttered again.
"Your powers are weak," Vader noted emotionlessly. "Old man, you should never have come back. It will make your end less peaceful than you might have wished."
"You sense only a part of the force, Darth," Kenobi murmured with the assurance of one to whom death is merely another sensation, like sleeping or making love or touching a candle. "As always, you perceive it reality as little as a utensil perceive the taste of food."
Executing a move of incredible swiftness for one so old, Kenobi lunged at teh massive shape. Vader blocked the stab with equal speed, riposting with a counter slash that Kenobi barely parried. Another parry and Kenobi countered against, using this opportunity to move around the towering Dark Lord.
They continued to trade blows, with the old man now backing toward the hangar. Once, his saber and Vader's locked, the interaction of the two energy fields producing a violent sparking and flashing. A low buzzing sound rose form the straining power units as each saber sought to override the other.
***
Kenobi heard the approaching commotion and spared a glance back into the hangar. The squad of troopers bearing down on him was enough to show that he was trapped.
Vader took immediate advantage of the momentary distraction to bring his saber over and down. Kenobi somehow managed to deflect the sweeping blow at once parring the turning a complete circle.
"You still have your skill, but your power fades. Prepare to meet the Force, Obi-Wan."
Kenobi gauge the shrinking distance between the oncoming troops and himself, then turned a pitying gaze on Vader. "This is a fight you cannot win, Darth. Your power has matured since I taught you, but I too have grown much since our parting. If my blade finds its mark, you will cease to exist. But if you cut me down, I will only become more powerful. Heed my words."
"Your philosophies no longer confuse me, old man," Vader growled contemptuously. "I am the master now."
Once again he lunged forward, feinting, and then slashing in a deadly downward arch with the saber. It struck home, cutting the old man cleanly in half. There was a brief flash as Kenobi's cloak fluttered to deck in two neat sections.
But Ben Kenobi was not in it.
Star Wars (Novel) by George Lucas
If this fight is any indication of how Vader fought in that point in time I would say TCW Obi takes it. Obi-Wan at that time was approaching a mastery of Soresu (not quite there yet). He was still being outclassed by the likes of Dooku (even in martial skill). But even without his complete mastery of the form, he would still contend with Vader from ANH. Vader notes in the fight that Ben Kenobi still has his skill, he just lacks his former power, power, which Obi-Wan Kenobi would certainly have.
I also don't give much clout to Vader's TK, as he did not attempt its use against Ben Kenobi. I would think this battle would play itself out in a similar fashion, except Obi-Wan's enhanced youth and form would give him an advantage.
Vader didn't start getting good again until he discovered Luke was his son (shortly after A New Hope). Before that point he was definitely just a shadow, simply Sidious' lap dog with not real motivation or goal.
TCW Kenobi vs AHH Vader - 8/10 advantage to Kenobi.
TCW Kenobi vs ESB-ROTJ Vader - 10/10 advantage to Vader.
Log in to comment