I can see it going both ways but I'd argue for the dark side team.
Yoda fights Sidious - Sidious wins. He already did, so I guess no point arguying here.
Vader fights Anakin - Vader wins. I know this one may be debatable but in my opinion Vader is more mature with his powers, more experienced and cold-blooded. Anakin was very unbalanced as a mature jedi and extreamly cocky, which was cause of his defeat many times.
Obi Wan fights Maul - Maul wins. Again, maybe debatable, but Maul in his prime stomped Grievous (Son of Dathomir), defeated Qui Gon and Obi Wan at the same time, and only lost to PIS (Phantom Manace) Defeated Obi Wan again and let him live for an unknown reason... (The clone wars) and even held his own against Mace Windu and another jedi 2 vs 1 (Son of Dathomir) he is above Obi Wan in my opinion. Not far above, but he beat his ass several times and Obi Wan never directly defeated him without some PIS getting in the way until they were both old farts.
Mace Windu fights Count Dooku - Windu wins. This won't be an easy duel for Mace Windu. Dooku is strong enough with the force to avoid getting stomped by Windu, and he is one of the only duelists who can match Windu in saber work too. Obviously Mace will win eventually. After all he even bested Dooku's master. BUT the duel is not a stomp as well and will take some time.
So the end result will be Mace Windu vs Sidious, Vader and Maul. These 3 will gank up on him and defeat him shortly.
I know if we change matchups the result may change as well, but this is how I see it - Vader goes after his old, failed self, Mace and Dooku go against each other to prove who is a better duelist, Yoda and Palpatine clash in a fight of the strongest force users, and Obi Wan fights Maul, his old nemesis. Makes sens to me.
Log in to comment