CW Superman vs Smallville and DCEU Superman (Read OP!)

VS

Rules

• All Supermen have been exposed to the synthetic kryptonite gas. (Assume it affects all of them as kryptonite from their universe would.)
• Fight takes place in an abandoned warehouse.
• KO or incap
• CW Superman get feats from both Supergirl and Superman and Lois.
• The effects of the kryptonite won't wear off.

Who wins?

Smallville probably had the worst reaction to Kryptonite. Followed by DCEU and then CW.

CW comfortably given howe quickly he was able to recover from the gas.

Which version of Superman do you think is the most resistant to kryptonite?

Oh yeah, I forgot about that.

@darthsuper: Routh

Ah, thanks.

@thevamphunter said:

Routh Superman and Reeve Superman are the same person, and Reeve Superman pushed the moon at relativistic speeds. The Kryptonite island feat isn't an outlier.

@gohindasuperman:

1. There's no need for writers to do that, even so, Routh and Welling are the most powerful LA Supermen ever

2. Yeah, the Kryptonite started to expose itself when he was in space, but he still had been stabbed in the back

3. Okie

@thevamphunter said:

There are no Kryptonite anti-feats to even say this is an outlier. Every Superman takes Kryptonite differently, and DCEU Superman took a nuclear bomb while weakened as well.

@thevamphunter said:

Do you really expect DCEU Superman to take a nuclear bomb after getting stomped by Batman? He also was exposed more to the sun afterwards, so that helped.

@gohindasuperman: You're comparing kryptonite gas to a kryptonite shard that Routh's Superman got STABBED with. Small pieces of that Kryptonite shard could still be in his system, yet he still managed to fly up into the sky to heal. Which by the way he only did so that he could be full strenght to lift the island. He knew it was an island full of Kryptonite, that show's how strong he is. Don't forget, Reeves Superman and Routh's Superman are the same version so all their feats are valid.

OnT: Haven't really seen anything of CW Superman just because of the stuff i heard about making him look weak. But if according to others he can handle the Kryptonite gas better then i'll give him first spot. Second is definetly DCEU Superman with Smallville as last. Smallville's Superman had an inconsistent recovery with Kryptonite.

@thevamphunter said:

I was mentioning how Superman reacted to kryptonite in different versions. Until you give me Kryptonite anti-feats for Reeve/Routh Superman, what you're saying doesn't matter.

@thevamphunter said:

So, yes, Kryptonite should make a Kryptonian weaker, that's its purpose. Superman doesn't really have Kryptonite anti-feats because he has only one showing with it. Still, what you're saying is irrelevant. I CaV'ed with this Superman, and likely have more knowledge on him than most people on this thread about him.

This makes no sense whatsover. The foundation of that Island was Kryptonite. The sunstone Crystals became either corrupted or i can't explain it. But the crystal's became Kryptonite. With just a few seconds in the sun healing up after being Stabbed by a kryptonite shard, he manages to lift the whole Kryptonite island. You can't argu this. Go watch the movie, or least the scene where he lifts it. Massive kryptonite crystals around as he lifts it.

Huh? If i understand you correctly, i'm holding a mug. So therefor the boiling water wouldn't burn because it's in the mug.

Is it though? What if you get stabbed by a poisoned laced blade.

@gohindasuperman:

1. Oh, i didn't know that. He's still MFTL though, right?

2. Yeah

@gohindasuperman: The kryptonite crystals were right on his face. Doesn't matter where he is holding the rock. A kryptonian doesn't need to touch Kryptonite for it to weaken him. Just has to be somewhat close to it. Space argument is flawed, as he already lifted the island from the bottom of the ocean where it's much hard through the Earth's atmosphere out into Space. That's insane strenght.

SV’s Kryptonite resistance is so terrible that he could actually die from the Kryptonite gas. If he survives he still going to be useless anyway. CW fought in a room filled with Kryptonite gas for a bit which is far better than the Kryptonite resistance DCEU showed in BVS so CW should win.

Tyler, he managed to fight a Super Soldier, while drowning with Kryptonite, and the latter had powers and military training, if Henry or Tom were in this situation, they would have died within seconds

@deactivated-60ee0713dd622: I remember watching that as a kid, it was nuts.

If we are arguing depowered supermen, Smallville has the best skill feats by far. He fought well against Green Arrow, Zod, and a Fury. And he fodderized an elite soldier even after being shot with a kryptonite dart.