CW: Arsenal vs Black Canary

Arsenal:

VS

Black Canary:

In this battle, Roy Harper will take on Laurel Lance, who will win?

Laurel has her batons. Roy has his eskrima sticks. No canary cry or arrows

Fight takes place in a dojo. Starting distance is 10 feet.

Both are in character. Victory by ko

Who will win?

Black Canary gets killed off by a random shot from the writing staff....Roy does a flip

Accurate

@arcus1: lol seriously though im leaning toward Roy. As ridiculous as it seems his flips actually give him the advantage since he's a much harder to tag target. Laurel as good as she got doesn't have that many showings against that level of athleticism as most of her opponents are far more ground based.

I used like it when they teamed up together, F**k Arrow anyways Roy wins

Roy wins.

Arsenal wins just about every time in a somewhat difficult fight

@staticdwanyemcduffie: Yeah dude, those season 3 team ups were the shit.

I'll say Laurel, cause more feats versus Ninjas.

@arcus1: Just to be nitpicky, I actually believe Roy uses Batons and Laurel uses Tonfa.

Roy

@allstarsuperman: Though Roy reminded me of wannabe Nightwing in a way

@staticdwanyemcduffie: I actually thought they were going for a Jason Todd vibe.

@allstarsuperman: Though Roy reminded me of wannabe Nightwing in a way

Umm okay

@allstarsuperman: A little mix of both?

@staticdwanyemcduffie: ehh

true

I feel like Roy showed more acrobatic feats, where Laurel just beat people up. Roy was trained by Oliver, and Luarel was trained by Wildcat, who is obviously not on The Arrow's level. Therefore, I say Arsenal wins the fight.

@nightwingx012: She also got training from Nyssa.

@stahlflamme: That is true. I still feel Oliver is more skilled than Nyssa, though.

@nightwingx012: But does that really mean anything about skills? Ra's taught Nyssa and he is better than any of Olivers teachers. The best fighter in the world is not necessarily the best teacher in the world.

@stahlflamme: That is a very good point. Luarel would indeed have very good teachers. She may have better teachers, but I don't remember any incredible feats from her. Roy was seen using his Escrima with incredible speed and precision multiple times.

@nightwingx012: Wildcat did quite well against Ollie in h2h, they were pretty even. Ollie only won that fight because of archery

@arcus1: Yeah, Olliver and Tedd are kind of even. This fight will be closer than I thought...

Leaning towards Roy. Laurel had some good showings in that last episode but Roy was consistently pretty okay.

Any new thoughts?

Still Roy

Some feats for both

Lol True.

Roy. Laurel is very inconsistent on her fights. She can sometimes take on league of assassins, then the next episode she have a hard time fighting a street thief..

@swt_decadent: she's been much more consistent lately

Bump

Bump

@arcus1 said:

Arsenal:

Where can I get that leather jacket?

@modernww2fare: lmao

Black Canary is more impressive h2h to be honest

Roy dominates.

I really don't think he does...

I'm currently working on a RT for Laurel and surprisingly enough I find her to be more impressive than Roy in h2h combat by quite a margin. It really saddens me to say so... Roy may be a more versatile fighter, but Laurel has better feats.

I think I might side with Laurel