Poll Current Asta vs Current Luffy (155 votes)
Fight to the death
Location:WCI
Distance 10 fleet
R1: Standard Fight
R:2 h2h
Fight to the death
Location:WCI
Distance 10 fleet
R1: Standard Fight
R:2 h2h
@zorosavage22: false reasons.
@magmacha: of course you would think that where’s yours at dude
Luffy stomps
Asta>Luffy
OP>BC
I got no reason to lie, asta simply is stronger.
@magmacha: yeah right Luffy is way physically stronger than asta dude stop it.
Once again what is your reason besides that
Luffy still stomps
@zorosavage22: in h2h Luffy is much better, in standard combat, asta whoops him.
Asta stomps
Asta wins round 1 to which I agree, there is no argument to be made for round 2. Asta has 0 feats and experience in H2H combat and has no feats nor way to scale him on Luffy's level in H2H, having better speed won't grant him the win whatsoever, blunt damage is also severely reduced against Luffy, not counting Haki and all.
@magmacha: dude Haki ryou punches will put him down and Luffy is way better in combat than asta
@zorosavage22: can put him down if he can’t tag Asta. Luffy has FTL reactions WITH future sight and observation haki. Not no base form FTL.
@zorosavage22: can put him down if he can’t tag Asta. Luffy has FTL reactions WITH future sight and observation haki. Not no base form FTL.
99% of the times I don't agree with ZoroSavage22 but currently Luffy is ftl in base due to matching on equal footing (and speed) Kaido who previously blitzed Luffy while the latter was using future sight.
@magmacha: yeah he does way back in the beginning of posttimeskip he called lightspeed too slow dude and not to mention his gears which will multiply his speed by a lot
Luffy stomps dude
Luffy is a bad matchup for Asta.
Now if it was my boy Yuno that's a different story 😎
yuno gets slapped harder
I'm disapointed with the feats in One Piece. Luffy's best feat yet visually is still King Kong Gun in dressrosa and that was just multi-city block level visually. Not a single feat better than that has happened in one piece yet (physically speaking), not even Kaido has a physical feat like that. I still can't see how Kaido is country level in physicals or how luffy is country level in physicals either
99% of the times I don't agree with ZoroSavage22 but currently Luffy is ftl in base due to matching on equal footing (and speed) Kaido who previously blitzed Luffy while the latter was using future sight.
high tiers of OP have rel+ calced feats, Base form luffy without future sight and observation haki is not FTL, yes hes in base form right now but it wouldn't matter what form he's in if he's using haki to dodge attacks.
Also for the speed, OP verse is a reaction speed only verse with like 2 characters having LS movement, reactions wise luffy is still FTL only with OH.
@magmacha: yeah he does way back in the beginning of posttimeskip he called lightspeed too slow dude and not to mention his gears which will multiply his speed by a lot
Luffy stomps dude
You do know naruto dodging light from like a foot away was barely over light speed, luffy dodging light from that distance was like a sub rel feat if even.
asta has better light dodging feats and from point blank range.
Luffy with future sight easily reacts and calls LS slow, but later on even while using future sight he couldn't even react or keep up with kaido. This already puts Kaido in the FTL ranges casually for being faster then luffy can react even while using future sight and current luffy is easily going toe to toe with kaido. Its really not that hard to understand some ppl are just in denial about FTL OP.
@magmacha: oh yeah you mean when Luffy casually got up after they already fired and waited for them to reach him before casually dodging them and calling it too slow for him
Stop underestimating Luffy dude
@magmacha: oh yeah you mean when Luffy casually got up after they already fired and waited for them to reach him before casually dodging them and calling it too slow for him
Stop underestimating Luffy dude
...this guy, if you go look at that chapter you'll see that luffy barely tilts his head to dodge, he could've standed there and they still would've missed. Luffy calling them too slow isn't a support at all since there are so many antifeats in WCI regarding light speed. They're slow combat wise, reactions wise with OH Luffy is FTL nothing more.
And how am i underestimating Luffy when im very knowledgable about everything regarding him. His attack speed is decent, combat speed is garbage, reaction feat is FTL as i mentioned, and travel speed is absolutely horrendous. All one piece got going for them is reactions.
@magmacha: pls name those so called anti trash feats
Like everyone else said currently Luffy is ftl in base due to matching on equal footing (and speed) Kaido who previously blitzed Luffy while the latter was using future sight.
It doesn’t if you do know him it doesn’t change much if you still want to downplay his feats with ridiculous arguments
@adi_frost: it’s called scaling and calcs but you wouldn’t understand that since you think primebeard is lightning speed small island level dude
@zorosavage22: a roughed up sanji can't outrun bullets/rockets, lightspeed movement niji has to save him. The entire germa family is fodderness in antifeats with there lightspeed this that yet fell short of these expectations. Base or not doesn't matter for luffys reactions with future sight or observation. As a matter of fact, the constant use of light in wano is funny, characters are still getting hit by lightspeed attacks and the notion of light still being used. Clearly shows that OP isn't that OP.
Also your ignoring my speed points, you still haven't shown me anything to show >SoL speeds in OP outside of reactions.
@magmacha: you mean the same sanji was more focused on saving/protecting Luffy than anything else
Speaking of sanji he has literally been shown dodging a barrage of lasers easily multiple times during his fight with queen and your just downplaying once again to hype up Lsta
@magmacha: you mean the same sanji was more focused on saving/protecting Luffy than anything else
That doesn't make a difference, if anything he should be running away his fastest, oh wait i forgot he only got reactions not any other speed.
Speaking of sanji he has literally been shown dodging a barrage of lasers easily multiple times during his fight with queen
Oh thanks for clarifying FTL reactions, not like i already mentioned reaction speeds
and your just downplaying once again to hype up Lsta
dang you got me there, i was being a astatard...stfu and watch this combo
@magmacha: what I’m not listening to a clown who thinks that saitama has more will power than Luffy when doesn’t have any clear showings of it at all
Also most of those anti feats are for main story plot which people like you try to use as an excuse
Luffy oneshots dude
@magmacha: oh yeah by the way Sanji only gets hit twice in the whole escape from Cacao sequence., only one from a bullet that came from behind which he didn't even notice
@magmacha: what I’m not listening to a clown who thinks that saitama has more will power than Luffy when doesn’t have any clear showings of it at all
Its just facts, i dont say false things, him breaking his limiter was actually a great willpower moment basically the equivalent to unlocking advanced conq, except breaking/removing limiter>advanced conq
Also most of those anti feats are for main story plot which people like you try to use as an excuse
Actually the plot takes precedence over anything else, if the plot wills it, its happens
Luffy oneshots dude
Luffy one shots nothing
@magmacha: oh yeah by the way Sanji only gets hit twice in the whole escape from Cacao sequence., only one from a bullet that came from behind which he didn't even notice
twice is alot more than zero. and dam guess sanji's observation haki sucks, even oda said that observation haki is his "thing".
@magmacha: how do you automatically assume that faulty logic of yours dude
Ok so now it’s up to the plots will, wow dude your so desperate
Luffy destroys
@magmacha: how do you automatically assume that faulty logic of yours dude
was faulty my bad, sanji is even worse than what i said.
Ok so now it’s up to the plots will, wow dude your so desperate
I mean idk why ur arguing this, author>their story.
Luffy loses
^^
@magmacha: dang guess you don’t understand that observation Haki is not an automatic response and doesn’t always work if not calm or focus dude
@magmacha: dang guess you don’t understand that observation Haki is not an automatic response and doesn’t always work if not calm or focus dude
sanji just that bad at his own thing...;(
@magmacha: you still haven’t even give me a single reason on why asta wins at all
All you give me was downplay and faulty logic
@magmacha: you still haven’t even give me a single reason on why asta wins at all
All you give me was downplay and faulty logic
Speed and AP, thats all asta needs. BC has better AP calcs than one piece incase u didn't know.
@magmacha: no not really and last time I check saitama isn’t close to rel or faster than light since he couldn’t even catch a regular mosquito or grab a simple hammer in Rock Paper Scissors with his speed
@zorosavage22: funny you mention that cuz one punch man is a parody/comedy manga meant to entertain. Ever heard of funny gag moments? eh i guess not, one piece doesn't excel in that. Also that mosquito was just immeasurable and saitama couldn't catch it. :((((((((((
@magmacha: oh ok but when it comes to one piece you want to find ways to downplay the characters and by that logic that means the mosquitoe itself is the fast thing in opm also saitama is not a gag character dude and yeah I have how many moments does one piece have again oh yeah a dozen
@zorosavage22: never said saitama was a gag character, comedy man, one piece fans dont really understand what that is. gag moments can happen anywhere, opm is just that good at it.
@magmacha: saitama still not faster than a mere mosquito is pathetic dude
Your not changing anyone’s mind dude current Luffy base form is FTL just accept it there even multiple calcs and videos proving it other wise
@zorosavage22: that mosquito just that quick🤷♂️
You still bring up base form as if that has anything to do with his reaction and observation haki. That’s some NPC behavior.
@magmacha: or saitama is too slow
The same thing can be said asta reaction and his ki prediction
Also observation Haki also depends on your reaction speed too dude and Luffy has been barely using it in his fight right now against kaido
Like deyyy said Luffy with future sight easily reacts and calls LS slow, but later on even while using future sight he couldn't even react or keep up with kaido. This already puts Kaido in the FTL ranges casually for being faster then luffy can react even while using future sight and current luffy is easily going toe to toe with in his hybrid form. Its really not that hard to understand some ppl like you are just in denial about FTL OP.
@zorosavage22: mosquito is just that guy.
Yeah the same thing can be said about asta, except his peak >>>>> Luffy’s peak.
What do you mean he’s been barely using it, oda just ain’t flashy with the effects, he’s trying to get through wano. Combat speed plays a big factor, there combat speed is much fodder, they’re landing hits on eachother that aren’t FTL hits as a matter of fact they’re slow hits, you can blitz a FTL reactions character and that doesn’t result in any combat boosts as it just meant the other persons combat is fodder. Combat=/=reactions.
@magmacha: you’re so in denial dude everything is an excuse with you and that fact you still thing this way is pointless and useless
Luffy wins just accept defeat it’s not going to hurt you 🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
@zorosavage22: if ur a powerscaler so to speak, u would know everything I said just now was actually true. Ur making =/= connections between speeds. Im hurt at the fact that people actually believe Luffy wins.
@magmacha: if ur a powerscaler so to speak, u would know everything I said just now was actually true. Ur making =/= connections between speeds. Im hurt at the fact that people actually believe asta wins.
Luffy still curbstomp
@zorosavage22: EOS Luffy might win, but then again, EOS asta will also get much stronger…
@magmacha: ok so will EOS Luffy get over it
@zorosavage22: EOS Luffy has a good chance of beating asta, speed is still always gonna be the thing for asta.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment