@kilius:
No it just means he doesn't match up well against pressure fighters.
In other words, literally any aggressive duelist. Weak against any practitioner of Shi-Cho, Djem So, Ataru, Jar'Kai, Niman, and Juyo. The overwhelming majority of styles. That makes Dooku a stiff, extremely limited duelist whose expertise is in external aspects of a fight. Blade to blade, that makes him trash.
and Anakin doesn't match up well against stalwart defensive fighters.
Anakin matches well against anyone. His form is designed to overwhelm a defense. Like any other aggressive form. Defensive forms are designed to withstand an attack. There is no stylistic edge to be had, it just comes down to who is more skilled.
Doesn't make them trash it just means they all have their limitations that can be exposed.
If Dooku, whose style is primarily defensive, doesn't do well against aggressive fighters, then he is trash.
Basically the equivalent of the outboxer - the ultimate refinement of boxing - yet they don't tend to match up well against swarmers of a similar level. Bit of a cliché but styles DO make fights.
Boxing is not fencing, if you can't handle an attack then you aren't a good duelist.
Dooku's always struggled against pressure fighters. So not really.
Quinlan Vos, Obi-Wan, Anakin, Grievous, Asajj Ventress. The only people Dooku struggles against are fighters like Mace and Yoda who are actually comparable to him in skill.
No because not all lightsaber duelists are pressure fighters and not all pressure fighters are on Anakin and Maul's level.
The only lightsaber duelists who aren't pressure fighters are Shien, Makashi and Soresu stylists who are all defensive fighters.
Makashi is supposed to be the form for lightsaber dueling, and Dooku is the ultimate posterboy for Makashi, but he can't handle one of the most fundamental aspects of dueling? That makes no sense and would make him a poor duelist.
Log in to comment