Comedian and Judge Dredd vs Punisher and Chewbacca (movies)

Movie versions of the Comedian and Judge Dredd (2012) vs Punisher (War Zone) and Chewbacca (Force Awakens).

Movie feats only.

The Comedian is armed with two semiautomatic pistols, a grenade launcher, and a shotgun.

Judge Dredd has his Lawgiver.

Punisher has an assault rifle and two semiautomatic pistols.

Chewbacca has his bowcaster.

Battle takes place in the St. Paul Conservatory, starting at in separate wings (not in eye sight).

The Conservatory has multiple wings that look like this:

With more heavily wooded sections like this near the center.

So there are starting in big sections with not much cover, and there other sections with cover between them.

Good teamwork on both teams; they believe they are taking out opponents to their own private wars/missions.

In character. Win by any means.

Who wins and why?

I pretend you said The Punisher (2004) cause War Zone was a insult to the character but either way The Punisher and Chewbacca should take this

Any specific reasons why? Also, it's arguable which is the better movie or even character study, but The War Zone version was a tremendously more effective combatant than the Jane version.

Callouts: @i_like_swords@pokeysteve@super_soldierxii@oni_bane@cheesesticks@matchesmalone21@oceanmaster21@darth_wayne@nickthedevil@silent_bomber@comicstooge@yourneighborhoodcomicgeek

@jedixman@the_imperator@juiceboks@deathstroke19@The_Deathstroker@jacthripper@elderskaar@precrisisbardock@decaf_wizard@nfactor1995@darthsenju@amethystgravity@darthsenju@azronger@cull_obsidian

Holy shit. Ive been to that place.

Gotta go with Team 1. Chewy seems like a weaklink.

I think the main point of Chewie being here is that he is really strong. That and his bowcaster would do serious damage to anything it hit.

No knowledge on Chewy.

As for Punisher, Stevenson was the better Punisher and Jane had the better movie.

I actually got married there.

Yes--based on the couple scenes in FA where Han uses it, and it clearly does way more damage than a normal blaster. I would assume that if he can blast easily through Stormtrooper armor, he can do the same for the armor of anyone here. Plus, he's used to nature environment.

Agreed. But have you not seen the Star Wars movies? This is movie-only, no comics feats.

i'd like to say team 1, but i'm sure some star wars fanboy will be here to extol chewbaccas "eu" virtues where he's assuredly some intergalactic cross of deadshot and the hulk. happens in every star wars related thread

Thats pretty cool

So true....