Cap is unarmed, full knowledge for both, morals off, fight in street clothes.
Cap stomp. You have many fighters who can beat Arya in GoT verse. She is FAR from being that impressive. What is her best feast again ? Taking briefly advantage of a confused and surprised+holding back Brienne ? Lol.
Seriously this should be locked, Arya stand no chance at all. MCU DD (and not on his Defenders lvl) would beat Arya without a doubt.
@kingantagonist: Even after Brienne became aware of her opponent's capabilities, her defense was bypassed and she was tagged multiple times. D&D stated that Arya is one of the best fighters btw.
What's Cap's best feat? I'd say that DD has a better chance of beating her than Cap does, due to his armor's ability to deflect the sword (Cap doesn't have such luxury).
@bladeoffury: None of those people you mentioned are on Caps level, Brienne is a great fighter, i know she was able to take down the Hound with a bit of difficulty but there's nothing that her and Ayra have done that would be remotely close to what Cap has done. Also Meryn was caught off guard when Ayra killed him.
@bladeoffury: Umm...she was wearing heavy armor-her defenses were not bypassed at all and the fight ended not in a draw...but with Arya trying to reach up with a knife at a much taller opponent who was stabbing a longsword at her face.
Guess who wins that exchange 9 times out of ten?
I know it looked coll, but Arya realistically lost every exchange in that match...her only tags were with a small sword against plate, she was put on her ass, disarmed, and ended on a losing position.
@paytience: Actually, Arya also tagged Brienne in the leg, and the multiple times that she tagged Brienne in the body also count, as Brienne was trying to prevent that from happening. This was a sparring match, not an armor exhibition.
Are you suggesting that Arya couldn't have reached Brienne's neck with her knife at the end?
Evading Bucky's knife in CQC and countering with attacks.
Evaded another knife in CQC used by a trained solider
KOed him with his knee then threw him on the ground
Quickly disposed of a Mercenary
Dodging and countering crossbone’s attacks,
Dodged his blade and counter-attack
Theres more but does Ayra have any feats of CQC,reacting as fast or fighting someone who is fast as Cap?
@bladeoffury: She didn't tag her multiple times to the body...she tapped her once to the cuirass which would of done nothing even had Brienne only been wearing cloth. The other strike...you mean to her armored leg? She got teeped in the chest and put flat on her ass for that. Twice Arya tries to surprise Brienne with fancy maneuvers...and twice all it did was sacrifice her position and put her in situations that would have got her killed against a serious Brienne. That was the the first. Next was the only time she tried to exchanged with a fully engaged Brienne and she got disarmed. After that she again tries to surprise Brienne with a fancy maneuver, only to lose her posisition with the knife drop.
Yes, I am saying Arya would not have reached. First, Brienne was in position first. She stops and watches because she is super interested and surprised at how good Arya is. But Brienne literally stops so as not to actually stab Arya. She smiles immediately afterward. Second...the end position, with Arya reaching, only works if Brienne falls forward, in which case Arya dies as well. If Brienne hab simply followed through with the stab, then the best Arya could have hoped for was to land a cut before dying, as Brienne's thrust would have knocked her back...had Brienne had simply leaned or stepped back while stabbing, Arya dies without a hope.
Here's the link: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=4US9QGU2yQI
I haven't watched GoT yet but is her best feat being > 2 > 1 > 4 ?
I'd say that's below Cap's elevator feat, so he should take this. I wouldn't say it's a mismatch, though.
The elevator is a good one, but Cap only had to worry about one side for the most impressive part of he fight, and due to the cramped space, only several could stand in front of him at once. When his opponents all surrounded him, he got grabbed and tased immediately. When he had his back to the wall (or to the dude holding him in a headlock), I would like to mention that 5 out of 6 agents that he fends off were actually trying to restrain him, not tag him (no point in hitting him with their fists). Some of them were already restraining him before, and the rest go in unarmed in order to help out. So, we have no idea how many times Cap would have gotten tagged if all his opponents actually wanted to tag him.
Still an impressive feat, but I doubt it's superior to Arya's scaling chain when it comes to pure skill. He might compensate with his stat advantage, however. Pretty close fight imo.
Wasn't she hurt and depleted after a prolonged battle? Anyway, I chose to ignore the entire Battle of Winterfell. Jon was surrounded by like 50 weights at one point (they were literally on top of him) and kept cutting through them. The wights were shown ripping through stone with their bare hands and yet Arya (who is supposedly "well in line with her actual physical stature") could stop their blows.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment