Avatar image for swordofdamocles
#1 Posted by SwordofDamocles (300 posts) - - Show Bio

Same conditions but Bronn does not drink and he is fully rest

Bronn have current Podrick help

Standar gear for Bronn team

Round 2

Bronn have season 2 Jon Snow help, but all the Lannister are ready in full armor

Avatar image for Aristeaus
#4 Posted by Aristeaus (1096 posts) - - Show Bio

R1: Bronn and Pod stomp.

R2: Bronn and Pod stomp, while Jon looks on.

Avatar image for hollow_point
#5 Posted by Hollow_Point (1451 posts) - - Show Bio

Bronn and Pod should win handily, with Jon itd be a stomp

Avatar image for dark_globe
#6 Edited by dark_globe (658 posts) - - Show Bio

they win both rounds .

round 1 low diff.
round 2 is a stomp .

Avatar image for swordofdamocles
#7 Edited by SwordofDamocles (300 posts) - - Show Bio

@Aristeaus Podrick is not there round 2. Anyway you really think Bronn/Podrick could stomp those guys ?

@hollow_point Same, why do you think it would be a stomp round 2 ?

Avatar image for bearderby
#8 Edited by Bearderby (208 posts) - - Show Bio

@swordofdamocles: its a stomp, Podrick survived the Night King's attack - killed a lot of wights, huge piles of corpse around him, he once a mentor to rookies in Winterfell

Bronn is low-key weaponized Jackie Chan

Avatar image for dark_globe
#9 Edited by dark_globe (658 posts) - - Show Bio

@swordofdamocles:

round 1:
pod is already above average fighter trained by brienne for a long time .
even jaime admits he became a lot better and he is already battle hardened as well .
bronn would probably kill 2 of those guys just with his dagger ( dirty move , slit throat kinda stuff ) .

round 2:
case could be made even s2 jon may solo this with high diff. and some wounds .
add bronn and it is a stomp .

Avatar image for swordofdamocles
#10 Edited by SwordofDamocles (300 posts) - - Show Bio

@bearderby: Those guys are the elite of the Lannister army. The hound almost die fighting them (while not completely rested though), and Hound>>Bronn. Podrick showed good feats sure, but that does not mean he could be a huge factor with the elite of the Lannister army, in fact he would have arguably a hard time beating one of them in 1vs1.

@dark_globe Those guys>average knight. Podrick fought only one time (in a huge battle while doing something and not stabbing a guy in the back) and with those Boltons scouts.

@dark_globe season 2 Jon snow would be likely stomped alone. Not saying Bronn+ S2 Jon would not win , but saying Jon S2 can arguably beat them alone is a big joke.

Avatar image for dark_globe
#11 Edited by dark_globe (658 posts) - - Show Bio

@swordofdamocles:

it also has to do a lot with shows choreography as well .
in the first seasons fights were much more realistic and well depicted
(no way would the hound be able to one shot almost entire kingsguard and make it look like a walk in the park for him in s1 or s2)

current fight scenes are like jon and the hound one shoting everyone without even trying that hard .
and if by "average knight" you mean some brain damaged guy who falls down stairs on hounds sword without even trying to defend himself
than yeah they are better but the "tavern" guys also did basically nothing in the show (so just your assumptions and guesswork) .

also the Hound is not >> Bronn .
at best sandor =>bronn (debatable)

Avatar image for bearderby
#12 Posted by Bearderby (208 posts) - - Show Bio

@swordofdamocles: Bronn would've killed 2 of them the fight isn't even started, he is tricky bastard, he knows when is to make a move

I think its stomp.

Avatar image for cpt_nice
#13 Posted by cpt_nice (10039 posts) - - Show Bio

They should win round 1 with a bit of effort. Bronn is quite a bit below Sandor but a tavern brawl and cqc is right up his alley. He'd immediately stab the first guy with his dagger and he can beat 2 guys while Podrick occupies the rest.

Round 2 is a stomp, Jon and Bronnn clean house. Podrick can take notes.

Avatar image for swordofdamocles
#14 Edited by SwordofDamocles (300 posts) - - Show Bio

@dark_globe:

it also has to do a lot with shows choreography as well .

in the first seasons fights were much more realistic and well depicted (no way would the hound be able to one shot almost entire kingsguard and make it look like a walk in the park for him in s1 or s2)

We already having a debate about this on the Jon Snow VS Zombie mountain thread, so I will not going to make a whole point here about that.

current fight scenes are like jon and the hound one shoting everyone without even trying that hard .

None of those fodders Jon destroyed was on the lvl of those guys. Furthermore Jon in S2 was quite seriously under Jon S8 in everything.

than yeah they are better but the "tavern" guys also did basically nothing in the show (so just your assumptions and guesswork) .

They are not my assumptions, this was clearly said many times in the books and on the show heavily implied , how dangerous where the mountain band. Do you really those guys who are know to fight mostly in front lines and dangerous/terror missions are on the average Lannister-soldier lvl ?

also the Hound is not >> Bronn .

at best sandor =>bronn (debatable)

I strongly disagree, but this is your opinion, so ok.

@bearderby: Not saying you are wrong, but don't you think if in he first round he would likely one shot/badly wound Polliver with is knife , he would have trouble beating two/three of them at the same time ? Bronn carry only one knife so I dunno how he could one shoot to dude of that lvl one after another.

And about round 2 ? Don't you think if they are in full armor and ready before the fight (which mean they would be more deathly/strong challenge) Bronn would have maybe serious troubles even with rookie Jon snow help ?

@cpt_nice: Why do you think season 2 Jon snow is THAT skilled ? I think he would have likely trouble with one opponent of that level in armor alone, let alone two of them. Just my opinion

Avatar image for dark_globe
#15 Edited by dark_globe (658 posts) - - Show Bio
@swordofdamocles said:

None of those fodders Jon destroyed was on the lvl of those guys. Furthermore Jon in S2 was quite seriously under Jon S8 in everything.

than yeah they are better but the "tavern" guys also did basically nothing in the show (so just your assumptions and guesswork) .

They are not my assumptions, this was clearly said many times in the books and on the show heavily implied , how dangerous where the mountain band. Do you really those guys who are know to fight mostly in front lines and dangerous/terror missions are on the average Lannister-soldier lvl ?

if i´m not mistaken we are talking "show only" here .
there is nothing to suggest those guys are that good in the show
(they have never beaten anyone good , and they have no feats)
as far as show goes they are just another lannister soldiers just like the fodder jon casualy one shots now .

Avatar image for breakofdawn
#16 Posted by BreakOfDawn (2326 posts) - - Show Bio

Loses both because he's not bloodlusted for chicken.

Online
Avatar image for cromulor
#17 Posted by cromulor (2360 posts) - - Show Bio

Bronn stomps. Pod does a really good job here too. Same with Jon.

Bronn is a very quick and dirty fighter and he’s very used to tearing up armored opponents even if he has no armor on at all. Pod is already an above average swordsman.