In every JRPG franchise, there are characters that are chosen to set their world right, and there are those that are arguably messiahs. Whether you are a reincarnation of a legendary hero, someone who was gifted with the personification of death or being chosen as a vessel for a corrupt god. Who wins?
Battle takes place on Gaur Plains
Round 1: The Luminary starts off with his starting equipment, Makoto Yuki uses Orpheus only, Shulk starts off with his starting equipment including the base Monado
Round 2: Act 2 Luminary is equipped with the best equipment possible up to his fight against Mordegon. Makoto Yuki can use Personas that aren't the Ultimates of each arcana. Mid-game Shulk.
Round 3: Everyone is at their absolute best with the best equipment. End game.
Bonus round: All three vs the Demi-Fiend