okay who wins. i like frank okay i will change the scenario around a bit how about in a jungle no civilians. making both fighters able to fight at their best all though i have no idea why the bat would be in the jungle lol
Post Edited:2008-05-09 01:29:38
batman VS the punisher
This topic is locked from further discussion.
Firestormnuclerman says:
"Is this to the death?"
sure why not. sure batman has some gadgets and some marital arts. but frank also has a really good background not to mention the only gadgets that really would be the defining moment of this battle and thats his guns
How about everything? Haha. Batman is one of the most accomplished martial artists in the DC Universe. Frank has some military training, but usually relies on weaponry to get the job done. After fighting Bats hand-to-hand for a while, he'd try to create some distance and shoot him, which never works, because Batman dodges bullets better than Neo.
ronin alexsnder says:
sure why not. sure batman has some gadgets and some marital arts. but frank also has a really good background not to mention the only gadgets that really would be the defining moment of this battle and thats his guns"
Your words. Also, try using a rocket launcher up close. It has quite a detrimental effect on anyone near it, including the user (i.e. Frank). Batman is a master of an untold number of martial arts. I do not think he'd have any trouble dealing with Frank hand-to-hand. That's just basic knowledge of both characters. Frank would get handled by Captain America, who I don't think would be able to best Bats in h2h.
Not to mention I doubt even the Punisher would unleash a rocket on a street full of civilians.
Post Edited:2008-05-09 01:19:15
but for real in the end batman is human. frank doesnt just have some military background he has all military background and if you know anything bout the corp they have their own martial art program called MCMAPs which is a form of a whole bunch of martial arts combined. so id say frank has all of that making him also a very good hand to hand fighter. but when it comes to franks weapons he has alot more than guns a couple of rockets shot at the ground near the bat would definitely put the hurting on bruce wayne
okay im going to bed but i hope this will get continued so someone can convince me that the bat wins until then i will say frank is the man.
You know, it's a good question, and normally I'd agree with you 100%, but Batman dodges bullets all the freakin' time. Like I said, it must be in his job description. All I know is he's gone up against plenty of people with just as much firepower and training as Frank and he's still alive.
Korg says:
"ronin alexsnder says:sure why not. sure batman has some gadgets and some marital arts. but frank also has a really good background not to mention the only gadgets that really would be the defining moment of this battle and thats his guns"Your words. Also, try using a rocket launcher up close. It has quite a detrimental effect on anyone near it, including the user (i.e. Frank). Batman is a master of an untold number of martial arts. I do not think he'd have any trouble dealing with Frank hand-to-hand. That's just basic knowledge of both characters. Frank would get handled by Captain America, who I don't think would be able to best Bats in h2h.
Not to mention I doubt even the Punisher would unleash a rocket on a street full of civilians.
Post Edited:2008-05-09 01:19:15"
well the rocket thing could be true about unleashing it on a street full of people lol my bad. but the hand to hand thing stumps the hell out of me martial arts is martial arts. STR will also be a factor not to mention durability.
so you wont even admit that frank could beat the bat with his guns. how can a human dodge a machine gun.
Batman is on another level in terms of Hand to Hand combat. Really I dont see Frank as being much more then Deadshot.
ronin alexsnder says:
"Korg says:"ronin alexsnder says:sure why not. sure batman has some gadgets and some marital arts. but frank also has a really good background not to mention the only gadgets that really would be the defining moment of this battle and thats his guns"Your words. Also, try using a rocket launcher up close. It has quite a detrimental effect on anyone near it, including the user (i.e. Frank). Batman is a master of an untold number of martial arts. I do not think he'd have any trouble dealing with Frank hand-to-hand. That's just basic knowledge of both characters. Frank would get handled by Captain America, who I don't think would be able to best Bats in h2h.
Not to mention I doubt even the Punisher would unleash a rocket on a street full of civilians.
Post Edited:2008-05-09 01:19:15"well the rocket thing could be true about unleashing it on a street full of people lol my bad. but the hand to hand thing stumps the hell out of me martial arts is martial arts. STR will also be a factor not to mention durability.
so you wont even admit that frank could beat the bat with his guns. how can a human dodge a machine gun."
Your thinking of this all wrong. Humans cant dodge bullets. But comicbook humans can. How does a human never age? How does a vigilante who doesn't wear a mask never get arrested? You cant apply real life to comicbook life. Know what I'm saying?
Batman doesn't just know Martial Arts, he's a master of all forms of Hand to Hand combat. Frank may have training but he's nowhere near Batman's level in terms of Hand to Hand skill.
punisher has a habit of killing mother Fers. didnt frank put the hurting on Daredevil and spider man for a bit. probably both of those guys could beat the bat
haha, the truth comes out.
If it's any consolation, half the JLA wouldn't spit on him if he were on fire.
lol i hate most of the JL to but thats just my opinion im not a huge fan boy i always root for the underdogs and less popular people probably why i have given ML so many chances and defended him so much
I'm sure ML is a great guy to his friends...
If I see a someone post a battle that is pointedly a curbstomp in favor of the character that they've either named themselves after or is in their avatar, I'm quick to point it out. So, yeah I support the underdog pretty often too. In this case, Batman has more tricks up his sleeves and is a master martial artist.
well i really like the punisher and i just dont see him getting his but handed to him at all he is very skilled in hand to hand combat MCMAPs man. not to mention navy seals training. the punisher is a survivor
Do you see an average, or even top of his class Marine or Navy SEAL taking Batman on hand-to-hand? Of course not. I like Frank too, but his hand-to-hand skills are not anywhere near up to par with Batman's. Batman is master of pretty much all hand-to-hand techniques. He also rarely gets shot. Also, his suit is now apparently made out of kevlar, so anything other than a shot through the mouth or possibly the eye is kind of a moot point anyway. Like I said, if he has Bats in his sights, he can and will shoot him. I don't see him killing Bats with a pistol, skilled though he is in the use of firearms.
It's me.....Yea. BATMAN hands down....In the jungle, in the city, in space, in the center of the earth, in an airplane bathroom. Batman is simply going to win. Batman can't even get shot in the mouth or eyes.....because batman can bite a bullet in motion, and his eye lashes are made of super strong fibers. (^_^)
Satyrquaze says:
"I'm sure ML is a great guy to his friends... If I see a someone post a battle that is pointedly a curbstomp in favor of the character that they've either named themselves after or is in their avatar, I'm quick to point it out. So, yeah I support the underdog pretty often too. In this case, Batman has more tricks up his sleeves and is a master martial artist."
Who is ML?
BatmanBeyond says:
"It's me.....Yea. BATMAN hands down....In the jungle, in the city, in space, in the center of the earth, in an airplane bathroom. Batman is simply going to win. Batman can't even get shot in the mouth or eyes.....because batman can bite a bullet in motion, and his eye lashes are made of super strong fibers. (^_^)"
lol. in a burgerking bathroom
personally, Punisher is one of my all time favorite characters. But...the only way he beats Batman is if he shoots him. Hand to hand Punisher is outclassed. Frank is a very intelligent and resourceful warrior, but Bats has him in just about every every category.
well lets think batman was a martial artis punisher was a cammander war vet punisher took on spiderman batman needs to use gadgets to win agaist alot of people and batman had his back broke by Bain who was just a guy on steroids basicly punisher has broken skulls with his fist punisher has alot more exsperiance than batman more cut throat and while batman lost his parents Frank lost his family so punisher has more to fight and live for punisher has a much higher pain tolerance than batman he can get shot and just pull the bullet out like nothing batman gets punched by Havey Dent and gets knocked out as for who scarier punisher takes that hands down punisher has fought ninjas befor wher so stealth isnt batmans strong point. So in the end punisher wins.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment