Batman vs Solid Snake

The Legendary Mercenary

The Dark Knight

Round 1: Random encounter with standard equipment and morals on for both. Batman is New 52 and Snake is what he was during MGS2.

Round 2: Solid Snake gets his MGS4 gear but is in his prime and Batman is Post-Crisis.

Round 3: Composite versions for both. Both get one hour of prep time.

Round 4: Both get two weeks of prep time.

Round 5: Snake gets Metal Gear Rex and Batman gets the Justice Buster or Insider suit

Round 6: Batman has his Arkham feats and Snake has his MGS1 feats.

Snake stomps all rounds. His win-loss record has always included much more powerful opponents. He’s tougher than Batman, and his gear is better. Also his overpowered sneaking abilities make Batman’s look pitiful.

Batman is close in most areas but he doesn’t have any definitive advantages.

Snake.

Bump

Batman all rounds.

bump

@eredin12: lol batman has beaten darkseid and amazo and has taken on the whole jla on several occasions he routinely spars with wonder woman i don't think snake is stomping anyone

Batman stomps all rounds. He's faster, stronger, more skilled, more durable, and smarter.

There is literally zero advantage Snake has except *maybe* his willingness to kill. And that certainly isn't enough.

bruce stomps 3.4,5 and one and 2 could go either way

Batman stomps. And with prep, even worse. Snake is a formidable solider don't get me wrong, but Batman is on another league. A lot faster, stronger, smarter and more skilled in H2H.

@eredin12: he didn't have prep before the fight amazo attacked the watchtower and bruce was the only one home and he thought it would be an easy win and gave bruce a few seconds i mean he was chasing him and blowing things up behind him but had no urgency he didn't think bruce could do anything then he realized that he couldn't track bruce signature any more and was like ok this isn't fun any more and started trying but by then it was to late and that was literally a few seconds during the fight not before and he fought the justice league in a flashback when he entered there base and none of them knew him yet and he was able to take on all of them but superman and manhunter for several minutes.

there is a reason that all of the jla members have stated bruce is the most dangerous one he is easy to underestimate and if you give him the slightest chance to beat you you usually have already lost

i don't know snake's best feats in stats i just know there not better than wonder woman or superman

snake was already running from the bullets in the scan you showed bruce has plenty of feats on this level.

batman has defeated darkseid on 3 separate occasions and by defeat i mean went to darkseid wanting something fought him and got what he wanted not necessary leaving darkseid laying but achieved his goal while darkseid was trying to stop him.

@eredin12: our disagreement is you say snake stomps without prep i said it could go either way bruce might be a little slower i would have to see more from snake than what i have seen but it's been years since i played the games and judging by raiden i would say snake may be a little faster and stronger but bruce has beaten stronger than snake without prep in dirrect h2h and faster opponets and i don't think snake is as skilled as bruce.

Just did an edit with a 6th round

Snake has an almost perfect win-loss record in his verse. He’s actually beaten every other protagonist in the series. That’s Big Boss, Raiden, and Venom. These are not average opponents, these are protagonists who have their own entire games where they all perform impossible missions and eventually beat a whole team of superhumans. You can make a thread on any of these three guys vs Batman and they have the feats to go tit for tat. But Solid Snake is the one who actually defeated all three of them. Not sure if Bats has defeated any protagonist level fighters.

Snake stomps every round without prep. Batman is not on his level physically. Snake could one shot Batman and he outspeeds him to boot. He also has comparable fighting skills and standard equipment.

Snake stomps

@the_hajduk:

Jesus beating powerful protagonist who carry there own series is the bulk of what bruce does.

@comic_book_fan: lmao who do you mean? I can only think of Green Arrow but he isn’t that good in martial arts in the comics.

@the_hajduk: he has beaten superman flash wonder woman martian manhunter aquaman

he has beaten every skilled opponent in his universe too karate kid deathstroke lady shiva bronze tiger literally everyone at one point or another

You can’t use a motion comic for a legit speed feat lmao.

Also from what I’ve seen Liquid “tanking missiles” is no different than Big Smoke tanking loads and loads of gunfire, it’s just boss battle gameplay.

The difference is that Big Smoke took gunfire and died. Liquid Snake took missiles and he was still fine and you need to have another boss fight with him. So at the lowball we can assume he had to withstand at least 1 missile.

Snake knows CQC. Batman doesn't. GG no re.

Round 4-6 are Batman’s

Round 1-3 could go either way.

r1: snake

r2 to r5: batman lolstomps

round 6: could go either way

@the_hajduk: I just looked up the comic. One stinger missile was all it took to take down Rex (after Fox threw his sword into its guidance system). I don’t see how this is a lowball when it’s literally the story without gameplay.

@the_hajduk: lol he isn’t winning all rounds. He’ll bat stomps snake. Only round I see him winning is with no prep

@the_hajduk: All of those "protagonists" would lose to Bats as well.

Bruce has outdone Wonder Woman while sparring, has beaten Aquaman in H2H, has outsped Kid Flash, etc.

Being able to match/beat Justice League members is superior to anything Snake has done.

Batman

This has already been extensively debated before.

@eredin12: You realize that Batman has causally deflected bullets from a sub-machine at point blank with his wrist, disappeared in front of a police officer who was staring directly at him with his gun trained on him from a couple of feet away, and very casually dodged multiple missiles from Calendar Man who was wielding a missile launcher in both hands at close quarter and then in the middle of dodging this barrage of missiles Batman was able to disappear from his line of sight and take him out from behind. Batman has several speed and reaction feats that vastly supersede a lot of the feats you mentioned.

Batman wins all rounds.

Batman wins.

@eredin12:

I see that Comic Vine is still plagued with rabid Metal Gear fanboys.

1) No one claimed that Batman has supersonic reaction time which is what it would actually take to "really" bullets. Clearly Batman telegraphed the trajectory of the gunfire and put his arm up to block. Telegraphing while not as impressive as "really" dodging bullets is still very very impressive nonetheless. Human Raiden is not in this debate, so trying to scale Snake's speed off of a feat that Human Raiden performed is going to help your case unless you can show Snake performing a comparable feat. Beating an Human Raiden doesn't necessitate that Snake is faster than him. Batman has tagged and defeated characters faster than both Human Raiden and Snake like Deathstroke in close quarters combat, but that doesn't mean that he is faster than Deathstroke who has enhanced physical stats. This just means that Batman has an advantage like his superior martial arts prowess and intelligence that allows him to compensate for Deathstroke's enhanced physical stats. The same can be said for Snake who doesn't have speed or reaction time feats anywhere close to deflecting bullets with a katana.

2) No one is claiming that Batman is supersonic, and he doesn't need to be to beat Snake either. John Wick has never disappeared in front of someone looking directly at him with a gun trained on him from a few feet away in a open hallway, and I like to see the equivalent from CW Deathstroke since I am not really familiar with the Green Arrow television series.

3) Evidence that Calendar Man missed? Rocket Launchers can propel munitions out around 294 meters per second, and Calendar Man was wield two of them at the same time. The point is that Batman had no trouble dodging a barrage from Calendar at close range and disappearing in front of him while basically at point-blank range. Where is Snake comparable feat because anyone can just sit around and downplay feats?

4) You didn't post anything remotely impressive for Snake speed-wise!

Being able to run and push someone out of the way of turret fire from Mech is essentially a standard action hero troupe that can be found any piece of fiction ranging from movies, television shows, video games, books, comic books, and more where munitions and technology are involved.

Ocelot did not shoot lightning out of the air. The fact that you think he did is proof of your rabid Metal Gear fanboyism since metal can conduct electricity and there is not a shred of evidence to support the claim that Volgin's synthetic electrical discharges can move a fraction of a fraction of the speed of lightning that occurs during a lightning storm.

Batman has no problem punching through missile proof glass so I don't see why he wouldn't be able to hurt Volgin and Quiet either.

Added a 7th and final round.

@eredin12: All right then, should I delete round 5 as well and replace Hellbat with Justice Buster?

Edited a few things, should be better