Batgirl vs Shadowcat

Batgirl (Barbara)

VS Shadowcat Kate Pryde

Rules

-In Character

-No Powers / No Weapons / No Battle Suit

-H2H Only

-Win By KO

-Random Encounter

@frenzyflame: it says no powers

Batgirl should stomp

Barbara wins

Kitty due to phasing.

@dalastuchihaman: it says no powers. So Barbara stomps. Not sure why this was made. Kitty would be like a 5 out of 7 in marvels scale on fighting ability but Batgirl would be a 6 or 7. It would be like a amateur boxer fighting a pro.

@muvdcu: Wouldn't go that far.

Kitty has a serious h2h history to be spoken on and in alot of ways they're comparable....the major differences between them being that Barbara has more diverse opponents and actively spars with Batman, Batwoman, Nightwing and Black Canary to increase her skills even when in a wheelchair whereas Kitty has durability and far better physicals aside from speed.

I honestly would say this favors Kitty if it weren't for the recent Batgirl arc with her training with martial artist around the world showing how she'd deal with diverse opponents without her gear.

@koays: Kitty is more durable but she's actually only a 4 on fighting skill so Barbara clowns her. As long as Barbara can knock her out she would. I don't specifically remember Shadowcat doing anything that shows she is faster outside of activating her powers to dodge oncoming fire etc. Also Barbara would know pressure points and ways to disable her. The only way I see Kitty winning without powers is if she is considerably faster.

@frenzyflame: the post says no powers. So they can only use their stats and h2h skill. No gadgets for Babs and no intangibility for Kitty.

This is right no powers or gadgets=)