Bane (Nolan) vs Jessica Jones (MCU)

Both are as shown in the pictures (outfit wise) and are unarmed. The fight is to the death or KO and it takes place on the streets of Hell's Kitchen (start 15 yards apart).

Who wins and why?

Based on how well Nuke did, I'm tempted to give Bane a majority here.

However, Jessica can basically break him in half if she wants to. The problem is, she doesn't fight that way.

I'll probably side with Jessica; but I can see a good argument for Bane.

Thanks for reading,

Floopay

Either can one shot the other. And since neither of them had any skill to speak of, whoever lands the first hit wins.

Deal with it fanboys.

@floopay: Jessica had a pair of broken ribs when she fought Nuke. Nuke even said he probably would have lost if she wasn't injured.

While true, Nuke himself had been through a lot before that fight, and I'd wager Bane is at least as strong as Nuke, and a better trained fighter.

Thanks for reading,
Floopay

@floopay: What did Nuke go through before the fight that was in affect? I don't recall him showing any hindrances or it being implied he had any hindrances.

He was hospitalized like 12-24 hours before that fight. From a bomb that killed his comrades. He then went on to continually pop pills and ignore his injuries. IIRC, he had a head wound, some burns on his body, and might have been bleeding (been awhile since I watched the show last).

Thanks for reading,

Floopay

1. Bane has insane durability. Considering she pulls her punches whenever she's fighting a regular human (she has no prior knowledge of Bane here) it is very unlikely she will one-shot him.

2. Bane was incredibly skilled. During his fights with Batman he didn't just stand there and throw punches, he was almost a match for him in skill and was able to grab and counter some of his attacks.

Beat me to it.

Bane.

Bane

Jones get's her head crushed.

Jessica. Seriously she had an extended fight against Luke Cage who could drill his entire arm through a several layers of brick so lol at her being oneshotted. Whether or not she ends the fight is up to her since she's not going to go with her stronger punches off the bat but she more than capable of using more strength if she needs to.

Bane's only advantage is combat speed (and that's probably because Jessica holds back in most of her fights) and skill neither of which is good enough to bridge the state gap for a majority IMO.

Bane gets his back broken...

Depends on how seriously Jessica takes the fight. It's her's to lose IMO.

Lol. Jessica is so underated it's sad. She can jump like 100 feet and Bane is suppose to stand a chance. Give me a break. She isn't a great fighter, but she beats the crap out of bane.

Bane. Bane was able to take on Batman and Bats is far more skilled than Jessica in H2H. Jessica would have to fight someone like Daredevil or the Punisher in order for me to see her standing more of a chance

Still Jessica. Bane's skill advantage won't help him in the long run due to the heavy state advantage even if Jessica holds back.

Jessica. She does this to Bane

Is she even a part of the MCU?

Jessica is better all around except for combat skill...and even then Bane's only marginally over "none at all" in the realm of "throw haymakers." And ik he called being too stupid to even register flashbangs going off as "being initiated," but that's clearly interperetation. Look at his eye as they go off, you can see what hes thinking: "...Moooooo..."

Lol jk, jk, Bane is a master class to a clan of fodder ninjas because he punches gud, but the area of skill is only one advantage and in this case it doesn't translate to much beyond "you can expect punches" because Bane didnt really showcase too well. Jessica's okayish with expecting punches, so idk why anyone thinks punching gud should overcome her raw physicals.

I just looked up the show Jessica is in. The fight scenes suck so I'm giving it to Bane.

What are jessica's best feats?

Bane sweeps.

@apex_pretador: Killing someone with a full powered punch to the chest; tanking hits from Luke Cage who drilled his arm through several layers of brick, making a dent in a bus with his punch, and sent an officer flying a good 50-100 ft off-screen when controlled by Kilgrave; ripped a dude's head off his body with her bare hands (he was already dead and she did it in an attempt to be sent to maxium security prison); accidentally broke a bathroom sink when she first got her powers as a teen; can stop a (slow moving) car and saved a little girl while doing it,;wasn't KO'd by several taser; got shot in the shoulder and shrugged off the damage; got hit by a van moving the speed limit and only broke a few ribs; casually broke out of handcuffs and bent a metal chair with ease; etc.

I'd go with Jessica Jones.

Jessica. One blatant PIS feat from a 2x4 doesn't negate the fact that she was getting gut punched by Luke Cage and hit full force by a truck and leaving a Jessica sized dent in it with nothing but a few broken ribs to show for it.

Jessica is stronger,and has better durability.But Bane is MUCH greater fighter.I think Jessica wins due to her better stats,but not easely.

Jessica kills him. /thread

Jones for me. Stats are too high.

Batman barely showed any skill either. They both slugged it out in both of their fights. It was a joke.

Jones ftw

@Pokeysteve: Not doing a bunch of flips and flashy moves doesn't mean the fighters weren't skilled.

Whos Nuke?

@g2_:

Will Simpson, the guy Trish was dating.

@dstreet45: His name is William Simpson in the MCU.

@g2_: Yeah my bad. Meant to say Will.

@dstreet45: Its ok.

I think during defenders Jessica will be force to step it up combat wise and threads like these won't be so debatable.

What makes Jessica unskilled?

Jessica Jones

Yea but he is nuke in the comics. He just hasn't been given the name Nuke yet. And I find it more convient to call him Nuke rather than William or Simpson.

I know.

JJ stomps.

Jessica, if Bane got the upper hand and was about to kill her I doubt she'd still hold back

Its hard to gauge how durable Jessica is. I would choose her just because she tanked hits from Luke, someone who hits much harder than Bane.