Yes, five combatants. So?
Also, I have seen Assassin's Creed battle royales on this site, but never of all five of the assassins. Therefore, I do not believe the thread should be locked for that reason.
ANYWAY, I know one of these guys really well, two pretty well, and one not at all (here's looking at you, Arno). That said, I still think each should be included.
In a large city (yet no civilians would be harmed due to morals) which one would come out on top?
-NOT physical prime. This thread assumes these characters are at the point where their inventory of weapons is largest (I can't send Altair up against four men packing heat unless he has some himself). So basically, it won't be twenty-five year old Altair, it will be middle aged Altair with the hidden gun. However, this is standard equipment. The only weapons used will be used in the story, i.e. Connor's tomahawk and Edward's swords. No items that can be bought from stores are allowed
-Medicine and other healing items are not allowed.
-Morals on and in character. The combatants will not be using random civilians as body shields
-No stealth assassinations. First of all, they would all likely be trained well enough to know they were being watched. Second, it would lead to too many quick deaths. No hiding areas are allowed either.
-No Apple allowed!
I think I have everything. If you believe the thread is unfair, tell me so I can fix it. Otherwise, let's get battling!