@nightmare52
coz u don't have proof to proof that calculation is right.
Why exactly have you not disproved the calculation? You are telling ME to proof a calculation, but the calculation proofs itself. Want me to proof the calculation? Fine then. I'll "proof" it.
First things first, how big is the mansion? We were never explicitly told how big the X-mansion is in the movies, but in an article by Moe Vodacom, the article writers analyze the various requirements and floor levels of mansion has, and estimated that the Xavier school for the gifted should cover around seventy six thousand six hundred fifty four square feet. Next, how fast was the explosion? Well no one knows for sure so let's use the average detonation velocity of about 7,150 meters/second. If we assume the X-mansion is in the shape of a square, then each side of the mansion would have to be 277 feet long and the explosion appeared to be exploding near the center of the house so the distance between the starting point of the explosion to the walls shows us that it would have taken six milliseconds for the building to fully be engulfed in flames. But, in quicksilver's point of view the whole six milliseconds dragged on for two minutes and 20 seconds implying that one second for us is twenty is over six and a half hours for Quicksilver. Using the multiplier in the speed formula reveals to us that he could run up to four hundred fifty six times the speed of sound. But wait; he uses super speed while already in super speed-and this doesn't mean he goes twice as fast. Hear me out on this one. Simply just multiplying in speed by two means that under the super speed vision they would have been running at the speed of what Usain Bolt runs at, (around 28 miles per hour) which of course he wasn't, as he was obviously so much faster that he's appearing as a blur while time has already slowed down, running in and out of the X-mansion to save the kids while the explosion is happening in slow motion. So here, assuming that the explosion took place in the middle dimension let's just like this whole area with J-Lock, Mystique, and the third wheel over here a part of the center. Doing this won't make the outcome super exact; what it will tell us the slowest Quicksilver had to be running so he runs in to save mystique and this outside and comes back to Moira all in just 0.7330 seconds. Since this is under Quicksilver's perception of time though, in reality it only took him 0.03 milliseconds (with the measurements of the walls we set up earlier--keeping in mind we haven't even taken into account the distance he traveled from the safe zone where he placed mystique, then Quicksilver traveled well above eighty four point four meters and 0.03 milliseconds; over eight thousand two hundred two times the speed of sound; this is Mach 8,202.) And reminding you that's the slowest he had to be running. If you take into account the distance he ran from the safe area where he placed the survivors, this would be a much higher number.
I'll break it down from where you claimed it to be accurate (you literally said that his time calculations were right but his speed calculations were wrong.)
It took him a grand total of .03 milliseconds to get them IN and OUT of the mansion, excluding the safe zone. Keep in mind this was in the slow motion perception, NOT in the super-speed perception that Quicksilver was in (on top of the already super-fast super speed.)
- The mansion (bottom floor only) is about 76,000 square feet.
- To simplify things, let's assume the mansion is a square. It doesn't change the calculation much, since it is a relative square.
- If that is true, each side of the mansion is 266 feet.
- The speed formula is distance/time. If the explosion was in the center of the mansion, then then that means he would have traveled 532 feet, because he rescued both Mystique and Moira. That means he ran to through half of the mansion 4 times (their, back, their, back; basically 133 x 4.)
- 532 divided by .03 milliseconds is 17,733 feet per millisecond (we used milliseconds to divide so now we have to convert upwards from milliseconds.)
- By converting that number directly to the speed of sound, we get Mach 15,758. That's FASTER than the calculation that the video provided, by almost double. (The video says that he was OVER Mach 8,202 so technically still accurate. :P)
There. So Quicksilver is Mach 15,758. Prove me wrong.
have mentioned so many times if u use best feat for quicksilver i will use the best feat , if u try to low ball i would to the same.
But Quicksilver has literally 3 feats... Out of the hundreds, or thousands of feats that Barry has in the show. In my case, it really isn't a high-end feat, because of the lack of feats to make it high-end. The 2 other situations didn't require a high speed like the situation in the mansion scene.
if u want i can bring more proof but it would be useless since u don't understand COMPLEX calculation.
Translation: you really don't have more proof, or don't feel like bringing it. You honestly don't care about whether I understand or not, you just want to call me stupid and also give a reason to not do anymore calculations. This is a straw man here itself; now would be the perfect time to bring back the portion of the post that you conveniently ignore EVERY TIME that I post it (3 times so far.)
ur point is completely irrelevant now.
Or do you just not want to respond to it? I see what you're doing. And I'm tired of it.
straw manˌstrô ˈman/noun:straw man
1. an intentionally misrepresented proposition that is set up because it is easier to defeat than an opponent's real argument.
Essentially, you use an irrelevant topic as a distraction as an attempt to not have to respond to the opponent's actual argument. You did this, don't lie. Mentioning an old CaV we did, constantly not replying to my arguments with "assumption," instead of actually addressing the point, and replying to the ENTIRE post I made (shown above) with merely this statement:
i will reply to ur post next .
i will reply to the rest of ur post after that.
ur point is completely irrelevant now.
(All followed with no evidence of an actual response to my claim)
Let's see that definition again.
"an intentionally misrepresented proposition that is set up because it is easier to defeat than an opponent's real argument."
Noticed some similarities. First, you ask ME to do your debunking FOR you (or proof my calculation... which the calculation does for itself. It explains everything quite well.) Then you say that you wait until AFTER I do that you'd reply. I'm willing to bet afterwards you wouldn't ever come back to my post, but rather try to debunk my "proof." All in an attempt to ignore the arguments that I made, possibly because you fail to find a proper counter to it. This is literally a straw man. You want to make me calculate something because it is easier to counter than actually addressing my claim.
Moreover, you continue to dismiss my arguments with no actual claim, besides "ur point is completely irrelevant now." Another straw man you made, in an attempt to dismiss my argument. Best possible situation for you, and I don't respond to the quote because of how it is baseless. Even if I do, it's still a win for you, because I would address it, but argue on whether my point was relevant or not. Again, this is a straw man in every way. You also tried to twist what I said to make me look stupid, even though the phrase was FOLLOWED with a NO, and an EXPLANATION. You failed to notice both of these, and failed to understand that I was intentionally using a stupid argument by using your logic, to show you exactly how dumb the argument sounds. This, or you understood my claim, but had to counter to it, and replied with a straw man. I hope the latter is correct, because I genuinely hope you weren't stupid enough to take my comment literally.
You failed to properly respond to the rest of my previous post, and ergo, I will post it again so that you can properly respond to it, and so I won't have to reiterate.
Apocalypse reaction speed is same as human level which is 0.15 seconds for a touch stimulus(punching). considering that he throat was cut right after quicksilver scene.
What? Is Spider-man human level reaction because he's gotten tagged by normal humans? Is Barry someone with human reactions, because he has been tagged by humans? NO. Apocalypse CLEARLY has superhuman reactions, they SHOW HIM tracking the movement of Quicksilver while he runs. It took him a while, but he can react to VERY high speeds.
so what ever quicksilver did is within 0.15 sec.
and quicksilver didn't travel more than 100 m.
Debatable.
so his speed is around 666.66 m/s
so quicksilver's speed at that time is around mach 2.
My previous comment debunks all this.
fire proves the perception speed is above mach 2.
How does fire prove ANYTHING?
Apocalypse reaction speed is same as human level which is 0.15 seconds for a touch stimulus(punching). considering that he throat was cut right after quicksilver scene proves he doesn't have superhuman reflex .
Nope. Just because he was tagged in the film doesn't mean he has human reaction speed. Like, DAFUQ? That makes zero sense. So does Barry have regular human reactions? I mean, he's been tagged by normal humans, so by your logic he would have normal reactions.
Apocalypse clearly reacted to Quicksilver. His EYES tracked Quicksilver's movements, and he surprised Quicksilver because of this (causes Apocalypse to beat Quicksilver afterwards.) If Apocalypse had regular reactions, he would have NEVER seen Quicksilver. Once Apocalypse noticed Peter running, Peter was STILL IN SUPER SPEED. If Apocalypse saw Peter in super speed, he has superhuman reactions, period.
so what ever quicksilver did is within 0.15 sec.
and quicksilver didn't travel more than 100 m.
so his speed is around 666.66 m/s
so quicksilver's speed at that time is around mach 2.
This would be true and amazing, but Apocalypse has superhuman reactions.
his time calculation was right but his speed calculation is wrong.
Fine then, if you say so. But, please show the math of how you get YOUR OWN speed, and how the video's speed is wrong. Because I've seen plenty of accurate calculations from that guy, but none from you. Yours never make sense.
than don't ask proof next time !!!
Explain the calculation, obviously. You are using so many unnecessary variables, which have NOTHING to do with his true speed. The feat itself shouldn't be calculated, because there aren't enough variables to get an accurate calculation.
punching him at travel speed would kill quicksilver.
Yeah, but there is one small problem... He could have guessed the lock MUCH, MUCH sooner. maybe on his 20th try. You assumed it took him until his trillionth try? The odds of that are as equal as someone guessing on there first time.
odds of guessing in 20 th attempt out of 1,000,000,000,000 is less than 0.0000000005 .
it would take about 500 Billion tries to get the code right out of 1,000,000,000,000 (1 Trillion) combinations.
I know it wasn't on his 20th try. I'm saying that we don't know when he guessed it. You assumed he guess it at his last try, trying to say that he was FTL because of that. As far as we all know, he guessed it on his 3rd try. Nobody actually knows, but that's why you can't use that as a feat. You don't have a definitive number, so you are simply assuming what the number would be. This feat is not valid at all, period.
he should be FTL to block an a pulse and what i meant is he is mach 9.5 + light speed to counter the pulse .
But where the hell did you get the numbers from? Make it CLEAR! Your calculations are just saying the starting number, and sentences of some conversions, and finally getting a solution, without showing the true math.
it's my fault to think that u are good enough to understand it.
Lol, your attempts at making a straw man are hilarious. Nobody on vine can understand that incredibly vague calc.
punching him at travel speed would still kill quicksilver.
He has to be able to react to his travel speed to punch QS. Also, Flash NEVER blitzes, NEVER NEVER EVER. His morals are too restrictive, and its like he tries to lose.
so ,ur making a baseless claim to prove me wrong based on assumption.
Really? Baseless? Try to actually debunk my statement, instead of using a straw man.
Nope, it's impossible to be in two places at once. He either used the speedforce, created an afterimage, or when through time to perform this feat. In CWverse, none of these need any speed NEAR FTL.
(Responding to the rest of your post.)
he reacted to quicksilver after he got punched which is 0.15 sec.
How could he react to Quicksilver AFTER he got punched, even though Quicksilver was still in super speed? He wouldn't have seen Quicksilver at all if he had this human reaction speed.
if u have any other reaction feat to say that apocalypse has reaction speed better than human reaction speed(0.15 sec) other than quicksilver scene i am all ears .
Don't act like an idiot. You can't take away the reaction feat that he has, and then claim that he has normal reactions. That's like saying "What other speed feats does Quicksilver have, other than the kitchen scene?" as soon as DoFP comes out. Clearly Apocalypse little other reaction feats (besides blocking blasts from several characters with his shields, something that a normal human reaction time could not handle) because of the fact that he has one cinematic appearance, and no more than that.
untill then quicksilver's speed at that time is around mach 2.
Right... Even though you didn't address my counter to that very statement with anything more than "ur point is irrelevant now."
Oh, and one more thing. Last time I mentioned a straw man argument you never replied back (if you can't counter a claim, you could simply agree with the other person.) This time, I am EXPECTING a reply. You could always take the coward's way out and ignore the post, but then you should just leave the thread. Reply to this post, and the ENTIRETY of it.
Since I'm not a hypocrite, I'll respond to the rest of yours.
for example : he said jessie as mach 3 but in her first appearance she was able to hold 28500+ ton tanker ship(Seawaymax) in the air which at least need mach 20 .
You keep debunking his calculations of OTHER speedsters instead of Quicksilver. You can't assume that because one calculation is wrong that all of them are wrong, or the one of your choosing is wrong.
force produced by the ship = 28500 x 0.5 x 9.8 ^2 = 1231713000 j
assuming jessie weight is around 60 kg
her speed^2 =1231713000 / (0.5 x 60 ) = 41057100 (m/s)^2.
jessie speed = mach 18.8 ≈ mach 20 since the ship can't be completely empty.
this simplest proof is more than enough to say that his calculation is wrong and he wanted to quicksilver to be top since quicksilver wankers will post it everywhere and increase his views
Lol nobody fakes calculations for views, that makes you look unreliable and will hurt your channel.
Yeah I saw your "reply" which replied to about 10% of my post. I'll get to that later.
Hopefully you do, I'll be expecting one with a valid argument.
i reply to ur most of ur post since rest of ur post mostly based on assumption and speculation baseless theories and miscalculated videos.
Really? Not about how you use straw men, right? And I'm willing to bet you'll ignore it once again.
u need to provide proof to ur proofless assumptions if need an answer :
What? I don't get what you're saying. As for the pictures you posted, a statement of "we do impossible all the time" is merely a phrase. Impossible is LITERALLY impossible, unless you can reality warp. No statement changes that.
Yes. I was mentioning the ways that a speed mirage can be made.
You keep bringing up how Quicksilver wasn't going fast during the Apocalypse scene. Well, I have proof that he WAS going fast during the scene.
At the very beginning, you can see an electric spark in the background. It is moving at a snail's pace. That means that in this scene, Quicksilver was going FASTER than the electrical discharge in the spark. This means it is going as fast as lighting.
After all, you yourself stated:
FYI any electrical discharge in air is as fast as lightning it's basic physics.
So it's pretty clear than Quicksilver was moving faster than lightning, since he was running around MUCH MUCH faster than the spark. This puts Quicksilver close to light speed, and it's pretty insane. I'm not going to say he is that fast, we only know he can go faster than lighting (which is 1/3 of light speed.)
I know it wasn't on his 20th try. I'm saying that we don't know when he guessed it. You assumed he guess it at his last try, trying to say that he was FTL because of that. As far as we all know, he guessed it on his 3rd try. Nobody actually knows, but that's why you can't use that as a feat. You don't have a definitive number, so you are simply assuming what the number would be. This feat is not valid at all, period.
r u just assuming that he did get on 3rd ?????????
Lol no, not at all. I said as far as we know. You seem to take everything at its complete literal definition. I said AS FAR AS WE KNOW. That means, it's completely unknown. Barry could have guessed it at any point, from 1-1 trillion tries. This makes the feat invalid, because it is so vague. Also, how does typing help in a fight?
i used probability not an assumption like u did .
I didn't assume... I said that we can't use the feat, because otherwise we'd have to assume.
- "The minimum force of that pulse was enough to destroy an Earth (ignoring the dynamics of destroying a multiverse), so we'll go off that for now. It's estimated to take a minimal 2.4x10^32 joules of energy to destroy earth, though this is realistically significantly higher. That converts to the same quantity in newton-metres, which can be converted directly to ton-force. There are 9806.65 newtons in one ton-force, leaving 2.45x10^28 ton-force. To calculate speed we use the Force equation. Barry's mass is about 74 kilograms. We divide the force by the mass to get acceleration in meters per second. This comes out to 3.26x10^30 meters per second. There are 343 mps is 1 Mach.
- Barry needed to run a grand total of at least Mach 9.5x10^28 to counteract the Pulse. This is about 1.087x10^23 times faster than light. This is about 1.64x10^25 times faster than Quicksilver's mansion feat."
i was wrong when i explained u first about this since i never had the calculation now i do.
Here's the problem: there is no way you can accurately convert joules to speed. I researched, and the closest thing to any sort of conversion is joules to kinetic energy. You can't convert joules to ANY form of real distance. A newton meter converts the amount of energy (regardless of concentration) into an arm's length with newtons (the energy measurement) evenly spread as well. The pulse was HEAVILY CONCENTRATED energy. Destroying energy (which is against the laws of physics; it is impossible: energy cannot be created nor destroyed) does not convert to newton meters at all.
2.4x10^32 joules of energy to destroy earth- according to google > than actual value since it was a multiverse level
2.4x10^32 joules =2.45x10^28 ton-force
Barry assuming mass = 74 kilograms.
speed =2.45x10^28 /74 =3.26x10^30 m/s =Mach 9.5x10^28 = 1.087x10^23 times faster than light =.64x10^25 times faster than Quicksilver
Yeah now you are using ton-force to find speed? You realize that speed is distance/time... and you have NEITHER of these in your calculation. This is just as invalid as before.
proof for this statement and i am not gonna waste time by replying everything with a guy who runs stories on assumption as usually .
Hmm... I wonder what this is. Oh, I know!
straw manˌstrô ˈman/noun:straw man
1. an intentionally misrepresented proposition that is set up because it is easier to defeat than an opponent's real argument.
Let me guess, you're not replying to my straw man argument? I hope you do, because it makes you a MUCH better debater when you steer clear of such a strategy.
Reply to my entire post, this is the 3rd time you've failed to do so.
Log in to comment