A sinister salesman arrives in New York City who can apparently grant people's deepest desires. However, it soon becomes apparent that each of the granted wishes cause more harm than good — particularly for Eduardo, who becomes trapped in Kylie's pampered cat Pagan after wishing she would respect him more.
- Egon Spengler - Maurice LaMarche
- Janine Melnitz - Pat Musick
- Kylie Griffin - Tara Charendoff
- Eduardo Rivera - Rino Romano
- Roland Jackson - Alfonso Ribeiro
- Garrett Miller - Jason Marsden
- Slimer - Billy West