mighty_thorion's Earth 2 #1 - The Price of Victory review

Avatar image for mighty_thorion

The Epic Begins!

The epic begins! Announces the cover of Earth 2 #1 and for once that description is true. This is truly a 5 star comic and IMHO the best thing to come out this month.


Straight away the reader is thrown into the adventure that will bring the downfall of three of Earth 2's (and any world's) iconic heroes. The narration is a good touch as is the fact that it is done in the form of a pre-recorded broadcast. Tragic as some of the events of this issue are, these events are just the forerunner of what is about to emerge in future issues. Long-time DC readers will not only have picked up that two of the major players in the future are going to be Alan (Green Lantern) Scott and Jay (Flash) Garrick, but also that Hourman (re the mention of Joan going to work for Tyler-chem) won't be too far away either. Just for good measure, Robinson ensures the Earth 2 universe won't have any Bat or Super influence as he sends Helena Wayne and Supergirl through the dimensional barrier into earth 1, where they will continue their adventures in World's Finest. The stage is set for a roller coaster ride and after the events of this issue, who can say that any of earth 2's inhabitants - heroic or not - can consider themselves to have a long term future?


Nicola Scott's artwork is top-notch all the way through the issue. Using a wide variety of page and panel layouts, her artistic qualities are shown to the full. Facial expressions, action scenes, movement and (unlike in some "big" events I could mention!) perfect anatomical ratio are all here and through them all shine Scott's desire for perfection and love of the characters.


Earth -2 is off to a great start. With the shackles of continuity removed, Robinson has the freedom to develop familiar characters in any way he wishes - the opportunity to re-invent the Justice Society if you like - and he is clearly going to enjoy doing so. With the brilliant Nicola Scott on board, this series can be nothing other than a sure-fire hit from here onwards.

Other reviews for Earth 2 #1 - The Price of Victory

    Seconds the best 0

    I don't know what I was expecting when I first heard of Earth 2. Actually, scratch that. I thought it would be basically the basic DCU with a few cast changes and a bit of creative liberty. What drew me in was where this creativity could go.And man, did it go places.Let;s compare it to the obvious: JLA. Now, I say this without an ounce of Hyperbole, this one issue delivered more than the first arc of Justice League of America. I am not joking.One thing it had was weight, a feeling that stakes we...

    12 out of 13 found this review helpful.

    Lay Your Hesitation to Rest 0

    Wow.... I was probably one of the most nervous about this series. I trusted Robinson, and held to that amongst the overwhelming naysayers... but the concept seemed too eager to please too diverse a group. Dark and gritty mixed with JSA? BUT LO AND BEHOLD. It is great.This tells the same tale as the first arc of Justice League. Just 100% better.... which isn't saying a whole lot, but is DAMNED true. I FELT THINGS reading this. I choked up at a particularly emotional moment, and felt a stab in my ...

    12 out of 14 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.