Why did they make her part of the Brotherhood of Mutants?  Wouldn't it have made more sense if she had been on the X-men instead?  I'm not sure why did this?  Maybe they didn't want to confuse non comic readers by placing unfamiliar members on the X-men team?  What do you guys think?  

anyone care to weigh in?

Give people a chance to answer before you bump your own thread.

She was fighting for what she believed in.  She'd joined the X-Men in the future timeline though.

alternate reality, plain and simple. the "why" it wasn't like the comics could be applied to next to every detail in the series.
answer: altu with its own number designated by Marvel and all.  

i'm also only going on a guess here but character development. the show was planned for much longer.
they likely needed a starting point for new viewers, and one that would establish a checkered past right of the bat.
mercenary,ect. doesnt actually tend to hold a lot of water in cartoons, since most times it against the ratings to
commit the acts, so if you pay attention in most TAS type cartoons the character is usually shown right away
doing an act that could be held against them from then on out and setting the darker character tone. 
rule #1 of anything on film: if it didnt happen on screen it doesn't exist.

just a guess there like i said, i dont hang out with the shows producers (though the artist has a blog
although i understand he might be somewhat ticked about the way he got jerked around on that project, imo)

No one's characterisation in Wolverine and the X-Men made sense lol. Just accept it for what it was; dumb, very dumb fun.

" @FadeToBlackBolt:   cyclops was throwing a tantrum throughout the whole season because of Ms. Jean going mia so he was on a loose tangent and wolverine being a leader gives great dramatic foil and conflict while also throwing in some comedy effect rogue having a elektra complex....i am lost by what you mean..are you referring to Freud complex or just comparing her to the character elektra  overall its a kid show on nickelodeon they cant get to technical.... "

As much as Rogue's relationship put an anchor on her character I thought her relationship with Domino was great. Plus I kinda saw something there. So much subtext there.  We  have scenes of Rogue and Domino hand holding, looking into each other's eyes, and when Rogue goes to rejoin the X-Men... Domino looks like she was about to convince Rogue to stay with the Brotherhood with a kiss.

I liked her characterization.

" As much as Rogue's relationship put an anchor on her character I thought her relationship with Domino was great. Plus I kinda saw something there. So much subtext there.  We  have scenes of Rogue and Domino hand holding, looking into each other's eyes, and when Rogue goes to rejoin the X-Men... Domino looks like she was about to convince Rogue to stay with the Brotherhood with a kiss. "

" @Ladyspider said:

" As much as Rogue's relationship put an anchor on her character I thought her relationship with Domino was great. Plus I kinda saw something there. So much subtext there.  We  have scenes of Rogue and Domino hand holding, looking into each other's eyes, and when Rogue goes to rejoin the X-Men... Domino looks like she was about to convince Rogue to stay with the Brotherhood with a kiss. "

Or you're making something up for your own pleasure...  Since Mystique wasn't a large figure in Rogue's life, they substituted Mystique for Domino.  She was the same dominating, but caring older female figure who was willing to use Rogue as a weapon.  Just as Mystique had done originally. "

@fadetoblackbolt: what is wrong with Rogue being in love with Logan why can"t W/R fans have anything it is romy this romy that romy fans are so selfish it makes me sick.