In 1956, Jim Stearn works his way through a horde of vampires to get to his son, who is frantically trying not to be killed by his mother Lillith and her three vampire brothers. Ultimately, Jim is killed by a crossbow arrow intended for Strongfort. Driven by revenge, Strongfort takes the arrow out of his father and kills his mother with it.
In present day, Kelly Friday takes her parents through the Road To Eternity to the Judgement Chamber under Stearn Mansion. There, Jim Stearn is encased in ice. The remaining members of the Fluorescent Five explain to the guests how Jim came to be put on ice after his fight with Lillith. Confronted by Kelly about his past, Strongfort's memories about his father's death slowly return. Forgiving his father for almost breaking the lineage of Mr. Monsters, Jim's body breaks free from the ice. Jim's soul is freed and says his farewells to the guests.