Alright so this thought popped into my head moments ago, and I figured out of these 5 who looks the best dressed?  This is purely  appearance. For me....I can't decide between Vic, Rorschach or Sherlock...
 

Are you serious bro? You totally want people to say The Question.

I agree the Question does look the best, course they all dress almost exactly the same except for Batman. Still, when it comes to detectiving and dress The Question wins.

Yeah, I'm a bit of a fanboy.

@Wolfrazer: Sorry, you just sort of seem like a big Question fan. I guess it was wrong of me to say that.

The Question.

@jobiwankenobi said:

@Wolfrazer: Sorry, you just sort of seem like a big Question fan. I guess it was wrong of me to say that.

His Avatar gives it away.But I'm also a Question fan too.

@CrimsonCake said:

The Question.

@jobiwankenobi said:

@Wolfrazer: Sorry, you just sort of seem like a big Question fan. I guess it was wrong of me to say that.

His Avatar gives it away.But I'm also a Question fan too.

Hey! Me too.

I don't know guys a batsuit is pretty cool...

I'd say Rorschach. Nice hat, great coat, badass mask, and pinstriped pants.

Sherlock. You just can't go wrong with the original...

Question, you can't get cooler than not having a face

The Question without doubt, Steve Ditko always make recognizable and useful suits, and Vic is not the exception.

@Wolfrazer: I wasn't saying that.

Yeah, Vic is way better than Renee.

Batman is the world's greatest detective but Vic is pimpin' in that blue overcoat. Rorschach comes in second.

Alright so figured it out. 
 
1. Question(ya I know obvious) 
 
2. Rorschach 
 
3. Sherlock 
 
4. Spirit 
 
5. Batman 
 
Some reason for a detective character, while Batman's suit looks good...for detectives you just can't go wrong with a nice suit.

Was there ever any Question?

..........

....

..

... SEE WHAT I DID THAR!?

I'd have to go with The Question.. although I would like to throw in The Shadow and The Spider.

@Wolfrazer: Dodds should be somewhere on this list. But I guess you got the list from that drawing...

And Q's mask hides his face, so he wins.

The Question for me. I love Batman's costume however, it's just not what i think off when i'm thinking detective ;p

@Aiden Cross: I think of Dick. see what I did there

1. Batman (I am huuuge fan of the suit)

2. Rorchach

3. Vic

4. Sherlock

5. Spirit

@DarkKnightDetective:

Rorschach

@wolfrazer:

This guy: Bigby Wolf from Fables!!

@lyrafay: He's hardly the best dressed? Looks like he's slept in those things for a week lol

@hit_monkey: Well too be fair, he is a werewolf!

@lyrafay: True enough lol

The Spirit