James Corrigan was created by Greg Rucka and Ed Brubaker. He made his debut in Gotham Central #12.
James Corrigan was a corrupt Gotham City cop in the C.S.U. division who frequently stole items from crime scenes to sell to collectors on the black market. He first comes on scene where he finds the cell phone utilized by the Mad Hatter in his Arkham cell hidden in his toilet. Later during the course of investigating the shooting of the Black Spider by Gotham detective Crispus Allen, he steals the bullet auctioning it on iBid.
Montoya begins her quest to recover the missing bullet to exonerate Chris, heading to Finnigan's, a bar Corrigan frequents. They engage in an argument which, culminates with them having a physical altercation which, Montoya wins despite having two broken ribs. She then forces him to reveal that he sold the bullet to a woman who frequently buys super villain memorabilia.
Corrigan begins to drink more heavily while he plots his revenge on Detective Montoya. He continuing his underhanded dealings charging five grand to fellow officers involved in corruption to remove evidence. All the while Allen has been investigating Corrigan since learning what Renee did to clear him. This tainted any investigation I.A.D. did into Corrigan.
Upon learning of a betrayal by Bill Kenzie, Corrigan sends two officers, who capture and torture Kenzie, before Jim comes in and kills him with a wrench. Later when Allen shows up to meet with his snitch he enters into a gunfight, wounding his adversary before being shot in the back by Corrigan who then shoots Chris multiple times,killing him.
The detectives of the M.C.U. track down the weapon Corrigan had borrowed from the G.C.P.D. Armory to murder Chris. The range master promptly admits to allowing a weapon to be borrowed by Corrigan as a favor when threatened as a accessory for a capital crime.
The M.C.U. brings in Corrigan and his girlfriend Becky, whose partner tried to kill Chris for questioning. However, due to his alibi with Becky, and having been lied to by the range master who Corrigan had paid off is let go. Montoya spends the day drinking at a bar before leaving, and breaking into Corrigan's apartment. She knocks Becky unconscious before pulling a gun on Corrigan and preparing to kill him, she stops when he begs for his life.
Following this, Corrigan spends the next year drinking heavily, while Chris, in his new role as the Spectre comes for vengeance, but ultimately decided against it. However, once Corrigan leaves the bar Chris's son Mal appears to shoot and kill Corrigan. However, later stories contradicted this, by portraying Jacob Allen to be the killer.
No relations to the Jim Corrigan who became the Spectre nor Jim Corrigan of the Metropolis Police Department.