gmanfromheck's Detective Comics #876 - Hungry City, Pt. 1 of 3 review

Avatar image for gmanfromheck

There's a New Girl In Town...

A new story arc, a new mystery and the appearance of a new character with ties to an old one, all in one issue.


The Good 

How the heck does someone drop off a dead killer whale in the city without anyone knowing? There's definitely a new mystery going on in Gotham. What's great about this is it doesn't seem as if it was done by one of Batman's big villains. The fact that we might be seeing someone new for Dick Grayson is intriguing. Throw in the fact that this was done, you know we're dealing with someone capable of doing...interesting things. 

The dead whale opens up new doors for our characters. In a scene with Dick and Commissioner Gordon, we get to see the two interact with Dick being Dick and not dressed in the bat-cowl. I can't say that I'm too familiar with their civilian interactions. When I first started reading Batman in the early 80s, Dick was Nightwing and Jason Todd was Robin. There should be a history between them because of Barbara and it's great seeing them work together this way.

What about the revelation of a new character with ties to an old one? Normally I'm not crazy when new characters are thrusted into continuity and we're just supposed to accept it. The way this character is brought up and explained, it makes perfect sense. It's quite a bombshell and when it comes to Scott Snyder's devious mind, there's no telling what the character's true intentions are. We clearly get mixed signals here that adds spice to the overall story. Jock's art and use of shadows add to the experience and compliments the sense of mystery throughout the entire issue.

The Bad 

The mystery aspect is great but being the first issue of the arc with a new villain, it's almost a little hard to get excited about the villain. Dick should have his own rogues separate from Bruce's so this is just a minor complaint. There is the chance that the new character I mentioned will cause headaches for Dick as well. The final scene in the issue which leaves us with a cliffhanger until the next issue felt a little odd. I expect better from Dick. Then again, he does chastise himself for making a mistake. That's part of what makes his time as Batman different than Bruce's. We clearly have a different person and these aren't just regular Batman stories but instead, Dick stepping up into the role. 

The Verdict 

Detective Comics continues to have a feel that separates it from the many other Bat-titles. Scott Snyder is making Dick Batman in his own right. This isn't just a regular Batman story where the costume sequences feel like it could still be Bruce underneath. We also get some character development seeing Dick out of costume along with a (sort of) blast from his past which is bound to cause problems. The new arc brings up a new mystery. Anyone that can drop off a dead killer whale in the city and have no witnesses has to be a brilliant mastermind. New villains help keep Dick's identity as Batman separate from Bruce's. Jock's art creates an almost eerie mood and the expressions on the characters' faces speak volumes. Detective continues to be my favorite Bat-comic and is great as a stand alone Bat-series.

Other reviews for Detective Comics #876 - Hungry City, Pt. 1 of 3

    It's Been a Longtime, I Shouldn't Have Left You... 0

    Dick's introduced to the new breed of Gotham criminal when he's called in to help analyze a crime scene that's strange even by Gotham's standards.  The Good Really like this issue's cover by JOCK. I'm a big fan of Moby Dick and the biblical tale of Jonah. This cover perfectly alludes to both these tales and just gives off that primal feel. It very much connected to that bit of the universal unconscious in me. I always talk about how Snyder and JOCK's Gotham's a living, breathing beast, ever thre...

    5 out of 5 found this review helpful.

    Godfather used a Horsehead, but a Killer Whale Trumps It! 0

    Scott Snyder does a great job in his issues of setting up a strange occurence that leaves you wondering what in the world it can mean, then shows it to be even stranger than you thought, then twists the knife by making it very sinister!  Spoilers follow... but some you can suss out from the cover...  A dead killer whale is found in an independent bank, and the woman who runs the bank Batman learns is Tony Zucco's ex! Beautiful set-up, and you know Dick is fully invested already. Then he has it c...

    8 out of 10 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.