Batman and Robin attempt to stop Julian Marsh from committing suicide after he learns Nocturna is gone. Plus, Green Arrow investigates a clue left behind by a struck-down underworld informant.
- Cover by Gene Colan and Dick Giordano.
- "Strange Loves" written by Doug Moench, penciled by Gene Colan, inked by Bob Smith, colored by Adrienne Roy and lettered by John Workman.
- "Believe everything I Hear" written by Dean R. Traven, penciled by Trevor Von Eeden, inked by Dell Barras, colored by Jeanine Casey and lettered by Agustin Mas.
Note: The Batman story is not bannered as a Crisis on Infinite Earths Crossover.
Story continues from Batman #391.