cronoman66's Defenders #1 - Breaker of Worlds Part 1: I Hate Myself And Want To Die review

Avatar image for cronoman66

Prepare to Fight the Impossible

The Hulk recruits Dr Strange and a rag tag team of heroes to destory Nul the Breaker of Worlds, in the aftermath of Fear Itself. The team Includes Namor, Iron Fist and She-Hulk. Very quickly events take a turn for the worse. With a surprise appearance opposing them.

Good

The setup for this book is great, having them hunt down the Breaker of Worlds is a good setup for a team led by Dr Strange. Each member has their own introduction and is a good setup for their personality and their current circumstances, giving insight into their own current events. There is some very charismatic artwork and some very intricate scenes in places, overall very good art. The interactions between characters a snappy and fun. It gives the book a very light feel and a good contrast to the dread of the villain they face.

Bad

There are Spoilers for Mighty Thor ahead, don’t read if you don’t want to know.

I have a slight issue with this book, one of continuity. So the Silver Surfer is part of this team, who was deeply involved in the Galactus Seed storyline in Mighty Thor. At the conclusion of this story he agrees to stay in Broxton to make sure no one takes the Seed, while Galactus takes a new herald. Galactus states that the further he strays from Broxton the weaker he’ll become. This story as far as I know ended just before Fear Itself happened. So it leads me to question how the Surfer can be in the Cantabrian Mountains, which is in Spain, surely he would be severely weakened, yet we see him at full power. The confusion is cemented as we see the Surfer de-powered in Mighty Thor #8, and Hulk stating he is asking Strange to find Nul before he goes into hiding in Incredible Hulk #1. How can he be in the team, surely his responsibilities with the Seed, and he’s tethering to Broxton prevent this.

It’s a minor error in continuity that I have gone to long lengths to describe. But It is a weird error as Matt Fraction writes both books so I would have thought he could have forseen it, or not be bothered by it I guess.

Verdict

Minor Continuity weirdness aside I enjoyed this issue. I enjoy Fraction’s characterisation of Dr Strange, and it’s good to see him in comics again, the assembled team is good but there doesn’t appear to be specific reasons for some of the character aside from pure practical reasons such as using Iron Fist’s jet. Overall a good issue and a good start to this new book.

For More Reviews and articles and my own comics series go to www.abandonearthcomics.com

Other reviews for Defenders #1 - Breaker of Worlds Part 1: I Hate Myself And Want To Die

    The Impossible Is Here! 0

    THE GOODI really enjoyed this issue. I thought it was great how each new main character was introduced - each with their name in the font we recognize from their respective series. The narration style each character takes, each in a specific color thought square, was a nice touch as well. Though at times "cheesy", it was nice to feel like the characters were breaking through the fourth wall.Art - I liked the art. It was interesting to see all these characters drawn in the same way, with the same...

    8 out of 8 found this review helpful.

    These Are Not The Characters I Know 0

    As of late, I've earnestly began to question just how much I trust Matt Fraction to give us a good story. Yes, Hawkeye is fantastic, but, beyond that, I've had a hard time finding something of his that has resonated with me. So, with this Marvel Digital Flash Sale (all works of Matt Fraction), I thought I'd give The Defenders a go; it's an interesting team and a really cool art style to work with. However, the characterization is so bland and out of character that I could hardly make it through...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.