What if....

Avatar image for lantern_of_hatred
#1 Posted by Lantern Of Hatred (1626 posts) - - Show Bio

Maul is a pawn.

Avatar image for warlock360
#2 Posted by warlock360 (28181 posts) - - Show Bio

Darth Maul had beaten Obi Wan?

seriously without no Obi Wan... No Anakin, no star wars 2-6, and i think Maul should of won, for the fact that he had beaten Obi's Master but couldnt kill the apprintince even though he was doin quite well fighting the BOTH at once.

so... what would it look like if the Sith had won? (which they should have)

Avatar image for lordraiden
#3 Posted by lordraiden (9586 posts) - - Show Bio

Warlock360 says:

"Darth Maul had beaten Obi Wan? ------------------------------- seriously without no Obi Wan... No Anakin, no star wars 2-6, and i think Maul should of won, for the fact that he had beaten Obi's Master but couldnt kill the apprintince even though he was doin quite well fighting the BOTH at once. so... what would it look like if the Sith had won? (which they should have)"
Yeah, I think most people would agree Maul should have won, or at least have obi wan with help beating him! but that's Lucas and star wars in general! you know maul had to loose to obi wan at the end, they just didn't do it too well! I think that was obi wans best fight outa all the movies, even better than his fight with anakin (even if the maul fight was much shorter, it was hell viscious and awsome). I mean lets get real, how much time did maul have to react before obi wan spent forever doing his sommersault and summoning his masters sabre while maul stood there like an idiot just watching? he still even had his light sabre on him, for crying out loud! he could have cut obi wan down while he was sommersalting over him, kinda like obi wan did to anakin when he cut his legs off! Like i said, maul had to loose to obi wan, they just did it in a very pis manner, not really well thought out!
Post Edited:2008-02-22 18:55:56
Avatar image for warlock360
#5 Posted by warlock360 (28181 posts) - - Show Bio

lordraiden says:

"Warlock360 says:
"Darth Maul had beaten Obi Wan? ------------------------------- seriously without no Obi Wan... No Anakin, no star wars 2-6, and i think Maul should of won, for the fact that he had beaten Obi's Master but couldnt kill the apprintince even though he was doin quite well fighting the BOTH at once. so... what would it look like if the Sith had won? (which they should have)"

Of course he should have one, or at least have obi wan with help beating him! but that's Lucas and star wars in general! you know maul had to loose to obi wan at the end, they just didn't do it too well! I think that was obi wans best fight outa all the movies, even better than his fight with anakin (even if the maul fight was much shorter, it was hell viscious and awsome). I mean lets get real, how much time did maul have to react before obi wan spent forever doing his sommersault and summoning his masters sabre while maul stood there like an idiot just watching? he still even had his light sabre on him, the idiot! he could have cut obi wan down while he was sommersalting over him, kinda like obi wan did to anakin when he cut his legs off! Like i said, maul had to loose to obi wan, they just did it in a very pis manner, not really well thought out!"

yeah and heres Maul mowing down armies of the Black sun and hes got a problem with 2!!?!?!?!

Avatar image for lordraiden
#6 Posted by lordraiden (9586 posts) - - Show Bio

aztek_the_lost says:

"Sidious would have killed him and found a new teacher for Anakin"

He wasn't/wouldn't be alive for sidious to kill him! a fight with the jedi's is a fight to the death, I seriously doubt he would have been left to walk away!

Avatar image for lordraiden
#7 Posted by lordraiden (9586 posts) - - Show Bio

Warlock360 says:

"lordraiden says:
"Warlock360 says:
"Darth Maul had beaten Obi Wan? ------------------------------- seriously without no Obi Wan... No Anakin, no star wars 2-6, and i think Maul should of won, for the fact that he had beaten Obi's Master but couldnt kill the apprintince even though he was doin quite well fighting the BOTH at once. so... what would it look like if the Sith had won? (which they should have)"
Of course he should have one, or at least have obi wan with help beating him! but that's Lucas and star wars in general! you know maul had to loose to obi wan at the end, they just didn't do it too well! I think that was obi wans best fight outa all the movies, even better than his fight with anakin (even if the maul fight was much shorter, it was hell viscious and awsome). I mean lets get real, how much time did maul have to react before obi wan spent forever doing his sommersault and summoning his masters sabre while maul stood there like an idiot just watching? he still even had his light sabre on him, the idiot! he could have cut obi wan down while he was sommersalting over him, kinda like obi wan did to anakin when he cut his legs off! Like i said, maul had to loose to obi wan, they just did it in a very pis manner, not really well thought out!"
yeah and heres Maul mowing down armies of the Black sun and hes got a problem with ***2***!!?!?!?! "

Tell me about it! there's holes through out the star wars prequals! they just looked good visually and had some awsome fight scenes!

Avatar image for warlock360
#9 Posted by warlock360 (28181 posts) - - Show Bio

aztek_the_lost says:

"lordraiden says:
"aztek_the_lost says:
"Sidious would have killed him and found a new teacher for Anakin"

He wasn't/wouldn't be alive for sidious to kill him! a fight with the jedi's is a fight to the death, I seriously doubt he would have been left to walk away!"

with his power, I don't see it being that easy

especially since the only Jedi anywhere near his location were Qui-Gonn and Obi-Wan (who would be dead)

he could then return to his master and be killed, the way of the Sith, except reverse"

if Obi would be dead and Anakin wouldnt live =no Darth Vader = no 2nd Apprentice = Darth Maul stays beloved apprentice :D

Avatar image for warlock360
#11 Posted by warlock360 (28181 posts) - - Show Bio

it doesnt matter because Obi wan wouldnt be there to be his master

Avatar image for thedrifter
#12 Posted by TheDrifter (24811 posts) - - Show Bio

Maul

Best. Sith. Ever.

Avatar image for xer_jumper
#13 Posted by xer-jumper (81 posts) - - Show Bio

period

Avatar image for constantine
#14 Posted by Constantine (16127 posts) - - Show Bio

he would've died by another jedi's hand later on, and seeming it was the death of Qui-Gon Jinn that influenced the councils rethink, two dead jedi would probably have the same effect, not much would change.
Plus Maul would never defeat Obi he's to great a jedi

Avatar image for admirallogic
#15 Posted by AdmiralLogic (4121 posts) - - Show Bio

Maul could have won. It wasn't even much of a fight for him. Just hold the lightsaber for Obi won to land on. But, unfortunately, they had him killed because he was proud.

I considered him the best villain in the movies and very cool in the clone wars series. That guy's a master of the sword(s) and he never even got a fight with yoda! Only minor jedis and a bunch of villains (cool or not) I consider Obi won a minor jedi because he could have been a lot better but wasn't. Now mace windu, kit fisto, yoda, those are masters and I don't think he fought any of them.

What if Maul killed his master first and became the master himself? Who would be his apprentice? Would it still be savage opress?

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.