no_name_'s Daredevil #512 - Shadowland: Part 5 review

Avatar image for no_name_

The End of Matt Murdock?

 This may not necessarily be the end of Daredevil as we know it, but it is certainly the end of Matt Murdoch- at least for now.

The Good

Daredevil is one of my favorite Marvel comics characters. He is dark, brooding, and has a ton of depth- and those are some character attributes I generally find really interesting. But the ending to Daredevil #512, and the ultimate outcome for Matt Murdoch that has been woven over the course of the last several months was rather anti-climactic. I was a little bit disappointed. But I'll get to what I thought was wrong later; let's start with what was good about this issue. The art, of course, has been consistently good in the series since Shadowland began. Marco Checchetto does an absolutely fantastic job with his pencils, capturing the dark and gloomy tone of the book perfectly. To get the most out of this issue, follow the instructions on the inside cover and be sure to read issue 5 of 5 of the Shadowland series first. In that issue, you'll see Murdoch endure a physical and mental transformation that ensures he will forever be changed. But we're not talking about issue #5 of Shadowland, we're talking about issue #512 of Daredevil. The transition between scenes is good, but I'm not so sure the issue was altogether necessary. It's primary purpose is to tie up the events of Shadowland, which it does, and to fill in the new role of Daredevil. Sorry, spoiler. But not really, since Marvel sort of spoiled that months ago (in fact, I think it was announced on G4's Attack of the Show in September.
So what happens to Matt now? Is he dead? You'll have to read the book to find out.
So what did I really like about this issue? The scenes featuring Foggy Nelson, who refuses to give up on his old friend Matt Murdoch are really touching- and we find in this issue that the Foggy's future and his relationship/ties with Dakota North and Becky Blake are in a very rocky place. The dialogue in these scenes were really lovely, and the art that accompanied them was equally stunning. These moments were perfectly matched, and it was these scenes where the issue climaxed, at least for me.

The Bad

I don't really know how to discuss what I didn't like about the issue without spoiling it, so for those of you who don't want to be spoiled, then please refrain from reading further.
The idea of having Black Panther take on the mantle of Daredevil is just seems really weird, and the cryptic manner in which he addresses Luke Cage and Iron Fist is as well. The line where he reveals that Hells Kitchen is his turf now, was kind of corny, and has been done before.

The Verdict: 2.5 out of 5

This was kind of a filler issue. Sure it introduces a new Black Panth- erm, I mean, Daredevil (but we already knew that), and sure, maybe I would have enjoyed it more had it not been spoiled for me months ago. Unfortunately, this issue, at least for me, was somewhat anti-climactic. However, for fans of Matt Murdoch this is a must read, as it addresses the future of one of Marvel's most prominent characters.


Avatar image for fantasgasmic
Posted By Fantasgasmic

Maybe its just me, but I feel like this entire arc was a huge letdown. I remember seeing the music video promoting Shadowland this past summer and I was like "oh daredevil, a character I haven't followed in over a decade, appearing in a nitty-gritty brawl with major heroes, and NINJAS, awesome!" But the whole arc seemed contrived, kinda cliche, and overall bleh.

Avatar image for longbowhunter
Posted By longbowhunter

I liked this better than Shadowland #5, but thats not to say it was all that great. If I wasnt a Daredevil fan I would have absolutely hated this and Shadowland both. It just felt like a story I've read a hundred times over. I too felt it to be cliche.
Avatar image for 137
Posted By Om1kron

I think I can live with black panther taking daredevils place, is it necessary to keep the character alive? No not really, if you're going to kill someone off don't be half assed about it. On the other end of the spectrum however as long as this doesn't spawn a Miss Daredevil,  which Marvel seems notorious for when they want to kill an important character and then try to bring them back as a woman so they can cash in on the 8 years too late danger girl trend. Then by all means, have at it Marvel. 

Avatar image for jonesdeini
Posted By JonesDeini

I got into DD again after reading a bit of the last arc of DD before this big "event" started. Having not read DD consistently over the years I did like the whole Murdoch taking over the hand thing and the internal plotting of the Hand against him. So I decided I'd give SL a peek especially after the hype it was billed with and the promise of Cameos from my fav NY capes. Well needless to say I was VERY disappointed with the first issu, especially with the "BIG SHOCK" at the end (smfh @ that bujou). So yeah, glad I sat out this run of the title. I'll also be sitting out Black Panther's (WTF?!) time as the guardian of Hell's Kitchen. I mean I love T'Challa, but dude, really?!

Avatar image for foxxfireart
Edited By FoxxFireArt

I originally wasn't going to comment until I read what was in the spoilers. That is just bizarre on many levels. Why is THAT PERSON of all people taking on the role of Daredevil?
I think comics go to a really weird place when they start having all these heroes standing in for another using their identity. It just gets confusing. It always feels as if a size six it putting on a size nine shoe.

Avatar image for thecheckeredman
Posted By thecheckeredman

-sigh- Again?  Seems like we just went through this not too long ago?  Oh wait that was Batman....  ;o) 

Avatar image for the_mast
Posted By The Mast

Shadowland was a potentially amazing story, but it was horrifically mismanaged and altogether felt so out of step with what Daredevil had been known for throughout the runs of Bendis, Brubaker, Mack and even earlier Diggle.

Other reviews for Daredevil #512 - Shadowland: Part 5

    Did This Book Miss the Memo That Shadowland Wasn't Very Good? 0

    Here's the funny thing about the Daredevil title's tie-in issues for Shadowland. If you were to only read them and nothing else, you would probably come away thinking that there was a very compelling and character-driven event going on over in Shadowland. This whole time there has been a weird disconnect between the Daredevil title and Shadowland. It is like the Daredevil title believes that Shadowland has actually delivered on the really dramatic story it kind of promised it would instead of tr...

    3 out of 3 found this review helpful.

    Daredevil No More? 0

    Shadowland has come and gone now we see how the cast of Daredevil are coping and the start of Matt's road to redemption for his behaviour during Shadowland. The Story Hell's Kitchen comes to term's following the events of Shadowland.  The Good  If the main series was like these last few issue's of Daredevil then Shadowland would have been good. Marco Checchetto art suit's the mood of the story as he capture's the dark and gloomy tone of the book and his art would have suited Shadowland more than...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.