In, Marvels Civil War, do to the law past in the U.S. that requires all Super Heroes to register their identity. Would you give away you secret identity? Why or Why Not?

No, however as a a citizen I would expect the superhero's to do it. Vigilantism is illegal, and with a mask the blame shifts and realistically ppl arent as reponsible as in the comic universe. they would get away with thing that they may have done during the act of "serving the public will." The Public did not ask for them, therefore they should not be treated as superiors. If the governement were to lay down strict rights and exemptions, as well as try them in court when necessary, the public would feel better.

It depends if revealing my identity would endanger me or my friends or family. If it wasn't a safety issue, then I wouldn't mind giving my identity.

I don't think the Freedom of Information Act covers personal data, but I'd still worry who would have access. Since they can access you library records to see if you're a terrorist (it might catch literate but stupid terrorists), I'm sure they can give any flimsy excuse to open your files.

I wouldn't, there's a reason the masks are in first place

I wouldn't be on the business to be aclaimed, I would to make a diference in the world

I understand the arguments that u guys are saying, but if ur scared of endangering your family... then just stop. Its really simple. (cept if that happened in the Marv. U therewould be no more comics so thats not happeneing anytime soon)

well sometimes the masks are really stupid

It is happening in the Marvel Universe. The new series Civil War Tony Stark A.K.A Iron Man is behind the law and is rounding up heroes who refuse to register but continue to save lives. Captain America is the leader of the group who wont register. Stark has turned to using force, and all captured super heroes are sent to Zero Dimension prison.

Time Captain says:

"It is happening in the Marvel Universe. The new series Civil War Tony Stark A.K.A Iron Man is behind the law and is rounding up heroes who refuse to register but continue to save lives. Captain America is the leader of the group who wont register. Stark has turned to using force, and all captured super heroes are sent to Zero Dimension prison."

no I mean ppl wont give up being superheros, because then thers no comics

Time Captain says:

"It is happening in the Marvel Universe. The new series Civil War Tony Stark A.K.A Iron Man is behind the law and is rounding up heroes who refuse to register but continue to save lives. Captain America is the leader of the group who wont register. Stark has turned to using force, and all captured super heroes are sent to Zero Dimension prison."

I tell stark to don't mess with me or I'll bring a big magnet

Time Captain says:

"It is happening in the Marvel Universe. The new series Civil War Tony Stark A.K.A Iron Man is behind the law and is rounding up heroes who refuse to register but continue to save lives. Captain America is the leader of the group who wont register. Stark has turned to using force, and all captured super heroes are sent to Zero Dimension prison."

Dude The Civil war series ended a long long long long long time ago. Like last year.

I know it ended it's just part of the discussion. I can also agree that most real people that became super heroes probably wouldn't give up the mask. If I would, whats to stop them from calling on me for every minute little problem.

Time Captain says:

"I know it ended it's just part of the discussion. I can also agree that most real people that became super heroes probably wouldn't give up the mask. If I would, whats to stop them from calling on me for every minute little problem. "

No thats not wat would happen. Most likely u would still be a freelance crime stoper, working for the government, be called on every so often. However you would also be responsible for your actions (though with support from the gvtment u could prbbly get alot of clearance and leeway) However, u would be able to get sued, and charged.

Time Captain says:

"I know it ended it's just part of the discussion. I can also agree that most real people that became super heroes probably wouldn't give up the mask. If I would, whats to stop them from calling on me for every minute little problem. "

Yeah like, Fix my plumbing problems, or save that kitten in the 2 inch tall tree, or Do my shopping. That would be annoying. Thats why I would use my cybernetic based powers for EVIL if I had any and my prosthetics were like the cybernetics of sci fi!!! And destroy said Douche filled goverment.

There is a thing called villainy Invest in it. Oh and I have 5000 posts ok This is a little late news but who cares WOOHOOOO!!! HOT DAMN!!! ARIBA!!! TIME TO ZELEBRATE!

Ya, getting sued would blow. What if they called me to do something that I felt went against my morals. If I said no they might have ground to send me to jail for not following orders, because you'd be like part of a new branch of the army. Plus I don't have complete trust in the current gov.

If it comes right down to it and the gov did pull a hat trick I sure would show them a thing or Four. Besides that I'd like the public fame to much, and helping people makes he feel good. Corny or not.

I would kill the goverment and Take over and then conquer the world if I had super powers and they did that. I never said this.

Time Captain says:

"If it comes right down to it and the gov did pull a hat trick I sure would show them a thing or Four. Besides that I'd like the public fame to much, and helping people makes he feel good. Corny or not."

and if ppl dont like you. and there would be certain things you cant do. U cant save everyone. Thats wen the angry mobes come. and wat if no one wants u. U would be forced to step down, so in the end revealing urself could put an end to ur career

crazy spidey says:

"Time Captain says:

"If it comes right down to it and the gov did pull a hat trick I sure would show them a thing or Four. Besides that I'd like the public fame to much, and helping people makes he feel good. Corny or not."

and if ppl dont like you. and there would be certain things you cant do. U cant save everyone. Thats wen the angry mobes come. and wat if no one wants u. U would be forced to step down, so in the end revealing urself could put an end to ur career"

All the more reason to become evil and destroy the goverment and take matters into your own hands.

Dreadnaught says:

"crazy spidey says:

"Time Captain says:

"If it comes right down to it and the gov did pull a hat trick I sure would show them a thing or Four. Besides that I'd like the public fame to much, and helping people makes he feel good. Corny or not."

and if ppl dont like you. and there would be certain things you cant do. U cant save everyone. Thats wen the angry mobes come. and wat if no one wants u. U would be forced to step down, so in the end revealing urself could put an end to ur career"

All the more reason to become evil and destroy the goverment and take matters into your own hands. "

yes yes we know, Alla Acbah Death to America, good luck with that

Beside you two. Is there anyone else how has an opinion?

crazy spidey says:

"Dreadnaught says:

"crazy spidey says:

"Time Captain says:

"If it comes right down to it and the gov did pull a hat trick I sure would show them a thing or Four. Besides that I'd like the public fame to much, and helping people makes he feel good. Corny or not."

and if ppl dont like you. and there would be certain things you cant do. U cant save everyone. Thats wen the angry mobes come. and wat if no one wants u. U would be forced to step down, so in the end revealing urself could put an end to ur career"

All the more reason to become evil and destroy the goverment and take matters into your own hands. "

yes yes we know, Alla Acbah Death to America, good luck with that

"

Actually I don't want to kill it. I want to rule it. And I can't run for president because I wasn't born here. So I have to use more violent means.

Post Edited:2007-11-05 19:00:06

Time Captain says:

"I respect your goals. I don't like how this gov is going myself but why does violence have to solve all your problems."

They are never ever going to change the law that says only natural born us citizens can be president. And I'll be killed if I protest against the law like the last people who tried to protest against the goverment Remember the students who argued against the vietnam war? Quite a few of them died So that leaves only violence, Stupid laws that cannot be removed peacefully can only be removed by force.
Post Edited:2007-11-05 19:04:00

I respect your goals. I don't like how this gov is going myself but why does violence have to solve all your problems.

Oh and I'll make the U.S Communist Yes I'm a communist the sworn enemy of Nazis I do not fear you Crazy Spidey. Lenin Forever!

OK. I'm out. You two talk amongst yourselves.