dark_noldor's Civil War #5 - [untitled] review

Avatar image for dark_noldor
  • Score:
  • dark_noldor wrote this review on .
  • 1 out of 1 Comic Vine users found it helpful.
  • dark_noldor has written a total of 1014 reviews. The last one was for HC
  • This review received 2 comments

Trapped in the Negative Zone

The Story - Following the footsteps of Sue and johnny Storm, Spider-Man goes rogue on Iron Man, leaves the Avengers and almost get himself killed by the Jester and Jack O´Lantern, but he´s rescued by Frank Castle. The Anti-Registration group has plans to rescue their friends from the super prision designed by Reed Richards in the Negative Zone.
The Writing - I guess the most significant moment in this issue is Spider-Man saying good bye to Iron Man. That was, not unnespected, but at least hard to guess, ´cause he´d exposured his whole life by going public, believing in Tony´s words, so this was very hard on him (and it took all the Anti-Registration group by surprise too).  Millar made himself very clear that Tony didn´t apreciated this act at all (he really had put a lot on chip in Spider-Man). Other than that, the only thing that actually happened in this issue was Steve´s plans to break in the Baxter Building to get the blueprints of the project number 42 (the prision in the Negative Zone). This issue was way behind the other 4 issues, it was very well written but didn´t showed the magic of the past ones - even the conflictuous idea, the paradox of good and right has a weak aproach (only with Tony do DD, Happy Hogan and She-Hulk). 
The Art - If the plot wasn´t the best, definitely the art was. McNiven´s on fire drawing Spider-Man (the Jester´s toy exploding on his face and Jack O´Lantern holding him by his throat were the best scenes). Only McNiven could have penciled Peter Parker getting his ass kicked by such low rated criminals (and they think they´re A-List, how funny!!!). Two splashes in this issue (one was good - the Punisher carrying Spidey and the other was unnecessary - showing the prision). His characters are great, the uniforms, the precise details continues to improve in every issue. Magnificent colors by Hollowell. Great finishes by Dexter Vines.
The Bad - Thor´s been cloned? I will never let this one down. Even Reed agrees that was a terrible idea: "Sometimes I wish we´d never gotten involved. Do you ever stop to think how much easier things would be if we hadn´t spliced Thor´s DNA with Hank Pym´s cyber-tech". Yes, Reed, sure it would be tons easier, but unfortunally Millar (or Marvel) didn´t think like you (and 99,9% of the fans). Nothing really happened in this issue, just the desertion of Spider-Man, and that was it!!! Come on, a whole issue for that? And did Captain fall for Tigra commitment with his cause? Didn´t he sensed that she was a spy?
The Verdict - Even not being the strongest issue, it still gots lots of magic brought to you by Mr. McNiven - he makes it worth it, so Pick it Up.
4 out 5 Ways to sneak Spideys in a sewer

No Caption Provided

Other reviews for Civil War #5 - [untitled]

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.