coinreturnslot's Charmed #1 - Charmed Lives review

Avatar image for coinreturnslot

Charmed #1 Review

I am one of the Charmed fans, who was very displeased with how the series ended. For the longest time after the Charmed series finale, I felt they should do a comic based on the series (much like Buffy or Angel) to make up for the atrocious ending, and my prayers were finally answered by Zenescope! I am very pleased to say that Charmed #1 is not only much better than I was expecting, but it is actually a great way to kick off the re-boot of Charmed. The time frame left unseen between the series finale and where the comic starts off is essential because it not only makes it easier to adjust to the new format of Charmed, it also gives the characters time to change into their new personas, and to adjust to a ’normal’ life - which makes it easier for a reader new to the franchise to get into the story. Paul Ruditis is one of my favorite TV-tie in authors, and I was very excited to see him as an author on this project. On the topic of issue art, I absolutely love the cover art for this issue (all versions), and how the characters are drawn, but - I may be the only person with this problem - Why is Paige a redhead (like in season 5) in the actual comic, but a brunette on the cover? And why is Phoebe the conservative one of the bunch? She was always so flamboyant with her outfits in the show. Aside from a few small problems with the issue art, I expect great things from this series, I just hope I’m not let down. 4.5 stars.    

Other reviews for Charmed #1 - Charmed Lives

    Something Wiccan This Way Comes 0

    As a steadfast lover of Charmed and somebody who has seen every episode and owns most seasons of the show, I had very high expectations for this comic. I am happy to say that they were met and then some. I will admit that I was more than a little wary at first, the show ended on such a perfect note that I didn't think there was really any way to continue without reconning the happy ending, fortunately Paul Ruditis found a way around that. The issue picks up about fifteen months after the show le...

    31 out of 37 found this review helpful.

    The Charmed ones are back... 0

    When did carrying on a television show in comic book form become a fad? It has been happening for years but lately it has become more abundant and sometimes it makes sense to do so and sometimes it doesn’t. Charmed is one of those times where it makes a lot of sense.The comic takes place 18 months after Season 8 ended, or happily ever after as it affectionately referred to. The Halliwell sisters are trying to live their lives and bring up the next generation of witches but that is proving a lot ...

    4 out of 5 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.