keith71_98's Captain Atom #1 - Evolution of the Species review

    Avatar image for keith71_98

    Visually and emotionally flat from start to finish


    "Captain Atom" was one of those DC New 52 titles that really needed to blow me away to keep me on board for more than one issue. Not only did it not blow me away, it turned out to be a drab and almost laborious read. J.T. Krul tries writing a story that both introduces us to a character and makes us care about his plight but I found it hard to invest in Captain Atom or his story. We get a sequence in the middle of the book that introduces us to the supporting characters working in a hidden research facility in Kansas. It's here that we find out that Captain Atom's powers are endangering his life. But these scenes don't pack any punch and these side characters aren't that interesting. The issue starts and ends with flat, drawn-out monologues that don't help the almost lifeless story. And then there's the dialogue. It's not that it's poorly written, but at times it feels more like a college nuclear physics lecture than a comic book story. It just didn't work for me. 

    Perhaps even worse than the story is the scraggly, borderline ugly art from Freddie Williams, II. There was very little that I found appealing about the look of this issue. Neither Captain Atom nor any of the supporting characters look particularly good with Dr. Megala looking especially bad. The opening and closing action sequences are visually flat and are seemingly void of any attention to detail. The story really needed the art to pick it up and stand out. Unfortunately the book looks worse than it reads. 

    There's just not much positive I can say about "Captain Atom" #1. It fails to create an interesting character worth investing in and it certainly doesn't look like the kind of title that can sustain an ongoing monthly series. Captain Atom and his particularly cool powers should make for an interesting book but Krul never cashes in on it. He's not helped by very sub-par art that only brings down the book more. I was hoping this would be one of those surprise titles from DC's New 52. That's certainly not the case.

    Other reviews for Captain Atom #1 - Evolution of the Species

      Wait, Why Is There a Volcano in New York? 0

      Offering up some small signs of potential, Captain Atom ultimately doesn't show much else as it takes some obvious cues from the well known analogue of the title character and turns Captain Atom into a mash-up of them both. A lack of real character depth and personality dilutes it all, though.This issue features Captain Atom with a flame-like poof coming off the top of his head and with the power to apparently transmute matter. So my question is... did Firestorm's revamp come out a week early?Si...

      6 out of 6 found this review helpful.

      A fine line between dedication and obsession 0

      In reading this issue i couldn't help but to compare it to the Mister Terrific title which had come out previously in the new 52.  In terms of theme and content both seem to be very similar on the surface for two very not similar heroes.  A focus on more realistic scientific principles as opposed to comic book science seemed to be a hallmark of both, but this issue fell a little short of the other one.  Mister Terrific seemed to be trying to edge in on the fan base for Iron Man, and to be honest...

      7 out of 8 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.