What character's would like to see in the Brotherhood of Mutants? Dead or alive doesn't matter. You can use good guys to if you want....

@judasnixon: Dead or alive? Well, my favourite Brotherhood was Mystique and Destiny's, from the Days of Future Past up until they became Freedom Force, so I'm inclined to say that crew. Plus maybe Sabertooth and/or Spiral.

But I like you're suggestion of Lady Mastermind as a nod to the original crew, and her thug mentality would probably make her a good fit with characters like Pyro and Blob.

@judasnixon: a full new team in fact? I like it!

I like the classic line ups spliced together to be the ultimate Brotherhood.
 
Magneto-leader
Mystique-field leader
Quicksilver-field leader
Blob- though, I would have him the threatening powerhouse he was back in the Claremont days, not the fodder he has become
Pyro
Avalanche
Scarlet Witch
Toad- I would look to the movie version where he was actually competent and deadly

Mystique

LAdy DeathStrike

Blob

Toad

Juggernaut

Magneto

Poison Ivy

Cassandra Nova, Magneto, Mystique, Daken, Sabretooth, Rogue, Blob, Avalanche, Toad

Classic Team:

Magneto

Mystique

Sabertooth

Destiny

Rogue

Toad

Pyro

Blob

Optional:

Scarlet Witch

QuickSilver

(Mystique - Leader) (AoA Nightcrawler - Right Hand) (Kid Omega - Telepath) (Daken - Feral) (Hellion - Telekinetic)

(Avalanche - Powerhouse) (Frenzy - Strong Gal) (Strong Guy - ...Strong guy) (Bishop - Ranged Combat)

My 10 Mix n Match BoM

Magneto

Omega Red

Sabretooth

Bishop

Storm

Silver Samurai

Juggs

Iceman

Emma Frost

& Scarlet Witch

somethin' like this..

Gallery

1. Mystique

2. Daken

3. Avalanche

4. Frenzy

5. Mimic

6. Exodus

7. Blink

8. Xorn

I'd stick with the classics

@In_the_zone said:

Mystique

LAdy DeathStrike

Blob

Toad

Juggernaut

Magneto

Poison Ivy

Poison Ivy is a DC character...

@papad1992:

I know -_- But she is still in My dream brother hood. Also I would like to add Sage as intelligence in the brotherhood

Mine would be different. In the wake of avx cyclops reforms the Brotherhood of "gifted" mutants.
Cyclops is the leader. He throws on a sicky leather jacket and let's his hair out again.
Next I Mags. Scott's right hand
Telepaths are Emma (Scott's old lady) and psylocke
their muscle is Warpath and Colossus
Teleporting sword wielders are Magik and Kurt DARKHOLME the Aoa nightcrawler.
Their powerhouse and enforcer is King Namor
Their nerd is Danger. Offering tech support and field intel!
So they wouldn't be the brotherhood that wants to kill all humans but rather a leave us alone humans we fight for mutant kind when necessary. But sometimes their methods don't sit we'll with the likes of the X men And the avengers
They would have their own title and would throw down with heroes like on a regular basis. Heroes to mutants and vigilantes to everybody else.

@Imperius_Rex: so, basically the Extinction team?

I do sort of like that idea, but I can't see them being the true villains that one would want the Brotherhood to be. Or Cyclops not calling them the X-men.

My Brotherhood

Base: Asteroid M

Roster: any and all X-Villains (GOOD villains, 60s-90s only, because I really don't give a damn about any X-character, hero or villain, created after 1999), except other A-Class "big muthas" ( Apocalypse, Mister Sinister, Stryfe, Mojo, Bastion), and competing powers (Hellfire Club. Mutant Liberation Front), and Omega Red, who probably cannot be trusted.

Members

Magneto (in another anti-humanity moodswings),

Scarlet Witch (in another antisocial moodswing, but in loyalty to her father)

Mystique, Sabretooth, Toad, Blob, Pyro, Avalanche, Destiny, Unus the Untouchable

Exodus, Fabian Cortez (yes, despite past begrudgements, Magneto shall accept him once more)

Mesmero, Sauron, Spiral, Lady Deathstrike, Vanisher, Mastermind, Callisto, Mimic, Post, Phantazia,

Super Sabre, Stonewall, Crimson Commando

Black Tom, Burner, Lifter, Shocker, Peepers, Slither

Non-Mutant Members

Juggernaut "honorary mutant", based on power, usability, potential loyalty to cause)

Arcade (financier)

Sentinels (Asteroid M sentry reprogrammed by Magneto)

@In_the_zone said:

@papad1992:

I know -_- But she is still in My dream brother hood. Also I would like to add Sage as intelligence in the brotherhood

No not SAGE!!!!

I love threads like this.

My lineup would be:

1. Magneto

2. Toad

3. Mastermind

4. Quicksilver

5. Scarlet Witch

6. Blob

7. Pyro

8. Avalanche

9. Mystique

10. Destiny

11. Crimson Commando

12. Super Sabre

13. Stonewall

14. Unus the Untouchable

15. Persuader (He appeared in Spectacular Spider-Man issues)

16. Sunstroke (He appeared in West Coast Avengers)

17. Phantazia (She was a member under Toad's leadership in X-Force)

18. Vanisher

19. Mesmero

20. Sauron

My dream Brotherhood Team would go like this: Random,Exodus,Daken,Avalanche,Omega Sentinel,Sabretooth.