shroudofsorrow's Batwing #0 - "They Will Pay for What They've Given Birth To" review

Avatar image for shroudofsorrow

We'll all miss you Judd

You know, its been quite a while since I've written a review, but that's just the way things turned I guess.

Judd ends his run on Batwing with a beginning, as corny as it sounds, and to his credit he does it well. This issue, while business as usual for Batwing, really just serves to show why Judd Winick's leaving the book is a huge loss on DC's part and I really do dread what will happen to Batwing with Judd no longer writing this book.

But more on that later.

In keeping with the theme of the 0 issues, this is a sort of prequel to the first issue, but because much of Batwing's origins have already been shown to us, Judd doesn't waste time telling us what already know and instead shows us the events leading up to his becoming Batwing. Its well-told, if maybe not feeling a bit on the short side. But all the same, its well-written, and as always, Judd has a strong grasp on Batwing/David's character. The little reference to Massacre that he sneaks in is also a nice touch, and it is fun to see a montage of David fighting crime in a more Nightwing-looking form before donning the hi-tech armor. Less well done is Judd's introduction of other African superheroes that David apparently has some history with. These chaps just appear out of the blue with no context whatsoever behind them, and while its obviously not possible to delve into their backstories while simultaneously going into Batwing's, their roles are so minor its extremely generous to call them roles at all, and as a result they feel completely unnecessary. But that is a minor problem.

Marcus To's art is more or less of the same quality its been in previous issues but I'd be lying if I said I prefer it to Ben Oliver's art, which aside from being very nice I felt also fit the book's tone and environment perfectly, but that's just me. At the end of the day, Marcus To is a solid alternative and a few what I call "lazy drawings" aside, he doesn't disappoint.

I can say with full confidence that Batwing has been my absolute favorite of the Batman books of the New 52, even more then Batman itself, and that's got Scott Snyder on it! Now that Judd Winick is leaving DC, Batwing's future is uncertain, and its hard not to be scared by that. Maybe its the cynical side of me talking, but my faith in DC's ability to replace Judd with a replacement who knows what he's doing is not exactly high. I mean, Fury of Firestorm went down the toilet pretty fast after its original writers left. Of course, on the opposite end of the spectrum, I don't think a single person was shedding any tears when Tony Daniel left Detective Comics, so I suppose it could go either way.

As already made clear, Judd ends his run on Batwing with a solid entry in DC's new string of zero issues. As it is, its probably for the best that Judd's last issue be something like this rather then part of an arc he would never get to finish. Its just too bad that this has to be his last issue at all.

2 Comments

Avatar image for eivion
Posted By Eivion

I was actually disappointed Daniel left Detective. I thought he wrote solid though forgettable stories with at least or two fairly good issues.

Anyways I agree with your review more or less. It was a good issue for Winnick to leave on. I'm also disappointed that he is leaivng just as he shows other African heroes. I also share your uncertainty on the book w/o Winnick. With the numbers it does sales wise I'm honestly expecting nothing more than ok placeholder before they cancel it come the fourth wave.

Avatar image for twentyfive
Posted By Twentyfive

This isn't Winick's last issue. He continues through at least issue 14. I am glad that you are enjoying Batwing, though. I hope it does not get cancelled. DC should get someone who knows how to write African characters, and an African setting.

Other reviews for Batwing #0 - "They Will Pay for What They've Given Birth To"

    Batwing: Year One 0

    Marcus To gives us one of those very standard Zero Issue covers that makes most of them blend into the woodwork. It takes the concept and really doesn't do anything with it. It's a cover that would be a little better if it wasn't competing with the rest of the Zero issues.This issue fills in the last major gaps we had in Batwing's origin story. Previously we saw where his raw talent and thirst for justice began, but we never got to see that transitional period. How did he go from 'angry former c...

    2 out of 2 found this review helpful.

    What Makes a Bat 0

    This has been a brilliant series and this is probably my favourite new character series in the New 52. I really like Marcus To's art although I have mentioned I liked Ben Oliver's art more. Judd Winick has also handled this character which was probably the best thing out of the original Batman Inc series whilst also making the character his own.This issue we see how Matu Ba and Rene Diallo came too raising David into the man he becomes.One year beforethe New 52 we see David as a police officer w...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.