batwatch's Batman: The Dark Knight #16 - Touch of Crazy review

Avatar image for batwatch

The Dark Knight #16

Touch of Crazy

To see this review with images, Click Here.

I've been a harsh on Gregg Hurwitz recently, the writer of The Dark Knight. He just concluded his previous arch on the Scarecrow, and though it wasn't awful, it also wasn't good. Apparently, many others share my dislike for the series since not one of twenty people thought he was the best current Batman writer on the BatWatch poll. Still, he has a chance to redeem himself now with his current arch. However, its going to be an uphill battle as he uses the Mad Hatter as the prime villain of the piece, a character some say has never had a good story. Does Hurwitz manage to prove his writing chops by making the Mad Hatter an A-list villain, or is this arch, much like Hatter, difficult to take seriously?

In this issue, Batman attempts to intervene with a rash of kidnappings.

I Don't Even Care

Maybe it is just because I am on testosterone withdraw, (I stopped producing testosterone a year or so ago. Nobody has no idea why, and now I've run out of testosterone ointment for a couple of days. It's a whole thing. Very weird. I'll stop oversharing now) but I just can't make myself give a crap about writing an in depth review of this one. However, I suspect it has less to do with the lack of testosterone and more to do with the lack of issue substance. Truly horrible issues are fun to mock while great issues usually have a lot to unpack, but this is just “meh” through and though.

The basic plot of the arch appears to be that Mad Hatter is kidnapping people who he will no doubt use for some twisted purpose relating to Wonder Land. As with the Scarecrow story, this seems like like a reimagining or expansion of the character than simply a rehash of past stories. The Mad Hatter only has two gimmicks; he can control minds with hats and he is obsessed with Wonderland. This story seems to be relying on those two tropes and nothing else.

There is a very entertaining concept for a set piece chase where Batman takes the Batplane on the streets of Gotham City, and I give Hurwitz big props for that imaginative concept, but I immediately deduct those props for the poor execution as Batman somehow rips the door off of the fan without any apparent action,(Batman is telekinetic now perhaps) explodes part of the fan in a way that would probably kill everybody inside, leaps through the van to rescue a victim, and then plows the Batplane into a building along with the van of bad guys who do not know how to use a break. Presumably, Batman's actions would have killed dozens between the bad guys and the destruction of the building.

(Spoiler) It also appears that the girl rescued by Batman was also being hypnotically controlled based on the hair matching the rescued girl containing a hidden chip. What could possibly be the motivation for faking a kidnapping? That plot element could actually develop into something, or maybe I am misunderstanding the scene.

Ethan Van Sciver

Ethan Van Sciver (former artist for Impulse) takes over the art for this issue, and I have to say, his style is not working for me. I hate to say that because I cannot identify what I dislike; it just rubs me the wrong way somehow. The only specific problem I can point out is that I dislike Batman's cape which, as drawn by Sciver, is much wider and bat like than usual. It does not look right to me, and it would drag on the ground, but that is just a nitpick. It is something about his work in general I do not like, but he definitely has skill, so this is just some odd hangup with me. Most readers might enjoy it.

Sciver did do a really cool layout during a conversation between Bruce and Natalya based off of a piano. Sciver also managed to make The Mad Hatter look truly menacing, so major props for that. The Mad Hatter is not a dude I would want to mess with in this issue.

Say Something Nice

There were some good things in this issue. The dialogue was strong. There was a cute scene featuring a grade schooler that was amusing despite the fact it was ripped off from The Dark Knight movie. The scene between Bruce and Natalya was interesting and could serve as either a conclusion to the relationship between the two or a springboard for something more.

Sadly though, I think that is about all I have to say on the positive side.

Conclusion 6/10

There is nothing major wrong with this issue, but it is just so generic. I can't really recommend buying it unless you have some major attachment to The Mad Hatter or some member of the creative team, but you might enjoy reading it in stores.

Other Recent Reviews

Batman and Robin Annual #1

Teen Titans #16

The Dark Knight #16

Batman, Incorporated #7

Talon #4

Legends of the Dark Knight #35

8 Comments

Avatar image for drreneninja
drreneninja

91

Forum Posts

3

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 60

User Lists: 0

Edited By drreneninja

I wholeheartedly agree with your review. There's nothing bad about this comic, but I guarantee I won't remember anything I read in here a week from now; it left no lasting impression. This was technically sound, but considering comics is an art medium, I never felt like this was art, more like a job that had to be done.

Avatar image for batwatch
BatWatch

5487

Forum Posts

274

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 238

User Lists: 1

Edited By BatWatch

Yeah, I really don't relish ripping a writer, but I don't feel like Hurwitz has much of a creative spark. He seems to be going through the motions.

Avatar image for the_mighty_monarch
The Mighty Monarch

3743

Forum Posts

2815

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1450

User Lists: 4

Pretty good review, but it's 'arc' not 'arch'.

@BatWatch said:

Yeah, I really don't relish ripping a writer, but I don't feel like Hurwitz has much of a creative spark. He seems to be going through the motions.

I actually think Hurwitz has a real talent for capturing the deep darkness of the really insane villains; he just lacks in the actually storytelling.

Avatar image for batwatch
BatWatch

5487

Forum Posts

274

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 238

User Lists: 1

Edited By BatWatch

@The Mighty Monarch said:

Pretty good review, but it's 'arc' not 'arch'.

@BatWatch said:

Yeah, I really don't relish ripping a writer, but I don't feel like Hurwitz has much of a creative spark. He seems to be going through the motions.

I actually think Hurwitz has a real talent for capturing the deep darkness of the really insane villains; he just lacks in the actually storytelling.

Think so? I will grant that his work has been dark, and I didn't mind the darkness explored in the Scarecrow arch, but I was not much impressed with this issue. Hatter just doesn't strike me as operating with such brutality. It's not an issue of darkness but of character in this case that strikes me as off.

Avatar image for the_mighty_monarch
The Mighty Monarch

3743

Forum Posts

2815

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1450

User Lists: 4

@BatWatch said:

@The Mighty Monarch said:

Pretty good review, but it's 'arc' not 'arch'.

@BatWatch said:

Yeah, I really don't relish ripping a writer, but I don't feel like Hurwitz has much of a creative spark. He seems to be going through the motions.

I actually think Hurwitz has a real talent for capturing the deep darkness of the really insane villains; he just lacks in the actually storytelling.

Think so? I will grant that his work has been dark, and I didn't mind the darkness explored in the Scarecrow arch, but I was not much impressed with this issue. Hatter just doesn't strike me as operating with such brutality. It's not an issue of darkness but of character in this case that strikes me as off.

I dunno, Mad Hatter seems about right to me. He's always been a little extra insane compared to some of the others, read Joker's Asylum: Mad Hatter and you'll see what I mean. And I was even less impressedwith this issue than you were I have it a 2/5 because I found everything but the Mad Hatter scene incredibly lacking.

Avatar image for batwatch
BatWatch

5487

Forum Posts

274

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 238

User Lists: 1

Edited By BatWatch

@The Mighty Monarch:

Thanks for the tip about arc not arch. I missed that when I responded earlier.

(sigh) Yeah, it really was not a very good issue, but I don't give something less than a six unless it really bugs me. This one was very much a "meh" in my book where I did not have any strong feelings one way or another. Like I mentioned, the plane chase was a cool idea, but the execution was horrible. I don't know. This whole series is just disappointing.

I guess my perception of The Mad Hatter is of a loser and incompetent fellow. He just seemed bloodthirsty and vindictive here. I'll keep an eye out for that story though.

Avatar image for the_mighty_monarch
The Mighty Monarch

3743

Forum Posts

2815

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1450

User Lists: 4

@BatWatch: Frankly, considering that you're obviously a big Batman fan, I would highly recommend the entire Joker's Asylum 'series.' As a whole it's one of my all time favorite Batman comics; two sets of 5 one-shots, each a tale about a different villain narrated to the reader by The Joker, and each by a different creative team. It's collected in two trades, the first has Joker, Penguin, Poison Ivy, Scarecrow, and Two-Face; the second, Riddler, Harley Quinn, Mad Hatter, Killer Croc, and Clayface.

Avatar image for batwatch
BatWatch

5487

Forum Posts

274

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 238

User Lists: 1

Edited By BatWatch

@The Mighty Monarch said:

@BatWatch: Frankly, considering that you're obviously a big Batman fan, I would highly recommend the entire Joker's Asylum 'series.' As a whole it's one of my all time favorite Batman comics; two sets of 5 one-shots, each a tale about a different villain narrated to the reader by The Joker, and each by a different creative team. It's collected in two trades, the first has Joker, Penguin, Poison Ivy, Scarecrow, and Two-Face; the second, Riddler, Harley Quinn, Mad Hatter, Killer Croc, and Clayface.

Sounds pretty cool. I've always wondered about that series. I've heard about it in passing, but nobody explained it to me. I'm starting to keep a list of suggested readings, so...added.

Other reviews for Batman: The Dark Knight #16 - Touch of Crazy

    Batman: The Dark Knight #16 Review 0

    ***SPOILER-FREE REVIEW***This issue of Batman: The Dark Knight, while technically sound and not having many noticeable flaws, also lacks anything that makes it stand out of the pack. To make use of the vernacular, this issue is the very definition of "meh."I had high hopes for Gregg Hurwitz when he jumped aboard this series. I really enjoyed his Penguin: Pain and Prejudice mini-series, and his Scarecrow arc started off well, until it dragged on for far too long. Hopefully, he won't make the same...

    3 out of 3 found this review helpful.

    Balderdash Of the Haberdashery Variety 0

    Right off the bat, the cover establishes that, like the Scarecrow arc, Gregg Hurwitz is making this more of a horror Batman series. The cover is deliciously creepy, with The Mad Hatter's eyes peeking right at you from the tiniest sliver of his visible face; and the balance with Batman coming out of the top of the hat is pretty great as well.Gregg Hurwitz was a HUGE improvement over the writing of David Finch, but in the long run, the Scarecrow arc was pretty shaky, and this new Mad Hatter arc is...

    2 out of 2 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.