omertalvendetta's Batman, Incorporated #4 - The Kane Affair review

Avatar image for omertalvendetta


Angles.  And more angles.  Actually, all kidding aside, it's a very cool looking cover.  I really dig how it portrays Batwoman at the top and Wayne down below, and the angular (if you couldn't tell) approach taken. 
The Good: 
For maybe the second time this series I am able to understand an issue.  This one relates to the last issue a great deal, but it's also a terrific stand-alone issue.  What I mean is that it gives you a beginning, a great retrospect of old characters and then redefines them in comparison of new ones, and hence some sort of resolution as well.  Yes, we do get somewhat of a retcon, but it works well here, and it really makes you wonder how it will all pan out.  I'm curious if Batwoman (and Gaucho, for that matter) will join Batman Inc. soon; I think that it would only make sense, at least for Kate Kane.  
The Bad: 
I know that old issues should not reflect on newer issues, especially when they're better.  I also realize that each issue should be reviewed by itself.  But sometimes that's really hard to do when an issue seems like it's making up for the previous issue.  I know many liked Batman Inc #3 (personally, I didn't), and I feel that my dislike for that issue hinders my judgment a little bit.  All that simply to say that I think the main bad thing for this issue, at least for me, was that I was so lost from the previous issues and the overall relevance was very unclear that I came into this issue with a sour taste in my mouth.  Also, slightly more relevant, after two issues, I still don't care a single bit about El Sombrero nor Scorpiana.  Hopefully that changes. 
This issue was a much better improvement over last issue, and it certainly gives me as a reader something to look forward to.  I had actually considered dropping the series if this issue didn't do it for me.  Thankfully, it delivered in both story and art, and hence it remains in my pull list.  Let's hope that we get more issues like this one, and less of the weak caliber of the previous issue. 

Other reviews for Batman, Incorporated #4 - The Kane Affair

    I need my Batwoman fix man. 0

    Issue 4 of Batman Inc and the reason im getting it because Batwoman is in it and I need my fix of her.  The Story: Batman and Gaucho are still in EL Sombrero's trap and Batwoman is chasing after a woman and meets another women dressed up as Kathy Kane Batwoman.  The Good: Morrison is able to pull in anything from the Batman mythos and have it make sense.Here we have how the orginal Batwoman fits in Batman's early days,Whats also cool about the art in those portions are the same as you would back...

    8 out of 8 found this review helpful.

    Review: Batman, Incorporated #4 0

    The new Batwoman gets an odd crash course in the life story of her predecessor at Kane's Kollosal Karnival.  The Good Good lord, does Morrison remind you why he's an A-List writer with this one. From the dreamy, surrealistic mood to the virtuoso storytelling devices, it's hard to miss why he's such a master of the field. Burnham's art is just gorgeous to look at,  evoking the work of Quitely, Williams and classics of the Silver Age while still maintaining an identity all his own.   The Bad It d...

    15 out of 17 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.