jlat89's Batman and Robin #17 - The Sum of Her Parts, Part 1 of 3 review

    Avatar image for jlat89

    "Now You can see what You've been missing!"

    Batman and Robin, for all intents and purposes has acted as the premiere Batman book the past year and a half, but with Grant Morrison leaving the title to write Batman Inc., would Batman and Robin fall behind as just another Batman book?  The quick answer: No.  Batman and Robin will continue to be one of the best Batman books, if not the best out, until it proves itself otherwise.  Originally this issue was set to be the introduction of the new creative team for the series, Peter Tomasi and Patrick Gleason of Green Lantern Corps fame, but was delayed, so a "fill-in" arc was added and if this first issue is a sign of what's to come, then I'm more than happy with where it's going.  
     
    Paul Cornell is a very popular person at the moment, I personally don't recall ever reading anything by him, so I was a little hesitant to  go into this arc assuming it would be fabulous.  I was pretty amazed with how much he gets the characters that had been so well done by Grant Morrison.  With the return of Bruce Wayne, there seems to be an air of change and dare I say respect of Dick from Damian, and it doesn't feel forced.  They converse very fluidly, it doesn't come across as stiff or forced.  The Dialogue is pretty top notch, and it's nice to see that Batman Inc., is being addressed, not heavily, but enough so you know where this story takes place.  Alfred has a nice little scene with Dick and Damian.  It was a very effective story, throwing you into the middle of it, then sending you back so you understand why they are doing what they are doing.  The ending was interesting to say the least.  
     
    Scott McDaniel draws an amazing issue.  I enjoy his style.  It's very reminiscent of another Bat artist who I can't remember at the moment.  The only problem I really had with the art was in one scene, Damian appears to be fairly tall, and at 10 that just seems a little off.  Other than that I had no complaints.  Gordon is basically traditional Gordon, and Batman looks like how he should considering who's under the cowl.  Overall the art was top notch.  
     
    Overall the issue was a hit for me.  Definitely something Batman fans should pick up.  If you were worried about the direction of the book after Grant Morrison, this arc shows that it's in good hands.  If you weren't a fan of Morrison, then I suggest you pick it up because while it's similar, it has it's differences, as it should.  While I viewed this as a fill-in arc, it doesn't present itself that way and it looks to be a fine opening arc for post-Morrison Batman and Robin
     
    4.5/5

    Other reviews for Batman and Robin #17 - The Sum of Her Parts, Part 1 of 3

      A new villain incorporated. 0

      Batman and Robin #17 It looks like most of the Batman titles lay under the Batman Incorporated arc now. So basically in this issue Dick and Damian are tracking down a new crime and trying to solve the mystery of a dead woman. Her name is Una Nemo and Bruce used to be fond of her. She's dead now and there is a peculiararity to the finding of her body"parts".  Dick and Damian come face to face with the woman behind the plan at the last scene of the issue.  THE GOOD! I have a feeling that the Batma...

      6 out of 6 found this review helpful.

      Not the best start 0

      Going into this title, I was expecting great things, especially seeing Paul Cornell take over for a few issues. I think he's a terrific writer, just not here. I know his placement on this title was kind of last minute, so I understand that the story might have been rushed, and that's exactly how this book feels. The story, for me, also seems to be all over the place. It starts out with Dick and Damian breaking into the church to save some guy, and then it goes into a flashback of sorts. For most...

      5 out of 5 found this review helpful.

    This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

    Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

    Comment and Save

    Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.