mrmazz's Avengers Confidential: Black Widow & Punisher review

Avatar image for mrmazz

Close but No Cigar

No Caption Provided

After interfering with a SHIELD operation, one too many times, Frank Castle, the vigilante known as The Punisher is captured by SHIELD. Fury however dosen’t want to send him to prison, he’s to useful to be locked away. Instead he pairs him with the Black Widow Natalia Romanova to investigate the shadowy organization Leviathan.

I have not enjoyed the majority of Marvel and Madhouse studios collaborations. This isn’t an aesthetic distaste, while I find some of the “fan service” moments to be awkward there is a consistency of style that is appreciated. I enjoy the works of directors such as Hayao Miyazaki, Satoshii Kon, Mamoru Oshii, and Hideaki Anno.

The biggest hurdle for these ventures both feature and serial has been in the writing. With Captain America: The Winter Soldier soon due in theaters, there has been renewed prognostication of just what it is Marvel Studios dose right for the masses and critics so consistently. The best of Marvel cinema (Captain America: TFA, The Avengers) has let its characters drive the plot and inform genre instead of the other way around. This is not the case for features such as Iron Man: Rise of Technovore . Avengers Confidential: Black Widow & Punisher manages to find a decent if underdeveloped halfway point between these two dramatic theories. As such it approaches something of quality and may be the best anime property this partnership has brought to the market. This step in the right direction doesn’t stop it from feeling hollow as it gets through a spectacle laden third act on a Black Widow wink and smile. Shirking any attempt to explore or evolve the morality of its titular characters.

This feature with story credit by Marjorie Liu and screenplay credit by Mitsutaka Hirota, tries to be an odd couple espionage story, the latter of which works rather nicely due to generic necessity. Beyond these espionage tropes, there isn’t really much to the relationship between Punisher and Widow. They have their differing moral codes. Punisher with his binary morality of all crime is punishable by death circumstances be damned. Widow has her belief in a higher authority and service to that. The feature tries to explore and perhaps evolve Punisher’s morality with trite moments of melodrama that do not work and in the end function more on plot necessity to move things to Madripoor instead of actually build pathos with the cold blooded killer.

No Caption Provided

The third act involving Mandripoor really undoes any of the half steps towards quality this feature takes. Having infiltrated the base, Punisher is tasked with NOT killing the controlled drones who are being auctioned off to the highest bidder. And then the Hulk comes in and smashes…everything. This kind of tone deaf handling of tone and rules isn’t new to Marvel Anime but it continues to be a key pillar of these products failing. Worst yet, the titular characters are lost in the shuffle one the Avengers show up. Which as spectacle isn’t bad, it’s really cool to see The Avengers square off against Graviton, Grim Reaper, Griffin, and an innumerable amount of drones. This is hollow spectacle that belongs in a different film.

The non-stop action pacing in which every scene is ended with a fight just about makes none of the action feel special. There are several sequences that are rather nicely done but in totality they like the characters are lost in a sea of mindless action for the sake of action and means of transition to the next plot point.

Frank Castle, The Punisher, is a character that translates to animation easily and spectacularly. The limitless potential of the medium allows Castle to be both an insane gun toting weapon of vengeance and boogeyman slasher all in the same sequence. An early sequence in a warehouse makes it quite evident as Punisher rips through goons with a brutality that wouldn’t fly in PG-13 live action features, don’t worry Punisher doesn’t make anyone too “wet”. The Punisher hits with an audiovisual thud, giving him the appearance of power equivalent to a metahuman. The Punisher’s brute force is contrasted nicely with the acrobatic dynamism of Black Widow. Always jumping insane heights with flash kicks or jumping off a wall to kick someone in the face. She provides a fun stylistic difference in how action is orientated.

Avengers Confidential at times resembles what is expected of “good” narrative structure. But almost only counts in grenades and just left me more annoyed that it nearly had it. Confidential forgoes character development for recycled fight sequences and spectacle. The problem continues to be the writing, true for most poor films. It isn’t the run time at 83 minutes it’s a bit longer than most DC animated features who manage to properly capitalize on the restraints and tell an actual story.

I am Michael Mazzacane and you can find on Twitter @MaZZM and at

Other reviews for Avengers Confidential: Black Widow & Punisher

    Really Great Animated film from Madhouse & Marvel 0

    AVENGERS CONFIDENTIAL - BLACK WIDOW & PUNISHER (2014)___- opening credits are fantastic, the rough detailed characters are very very well rendered and brought to life. very comic booky but hard edged- would love for the character designer and artist of this movie to draw a marvel comic series- city and port backgrounds are lush and beautifully detailed and rendered- action is fast and brutal, hits hard, character movement even for human characters such as punisher and widow are exaggerated, ...

    2 out of 5 found this review helpful.

    Avengers Confidential: Black Widow & Punisher Review 0

    Avenger and S.H.I.E.L.D. agent, Black Widow, must stop a terrorist organization known as Leviathan, from spreading fear and chaos across the globe through advanced weaponry and biologically enhanced soldiers. However, a job like this is too big for even one S.H.I.E.L.D. agent turned Avenger, that's why she's going in with the best backup one could possibly hope for; The Punisher! This is probably one of Marvel's BEST animated movies. We know by obvious facts that Marvel is dominating the live ac...

    2 out of 7 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Comic Vine for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Comic Vine users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.